My journey in this game was somewhat unusual. It was so busy that I didn't participate/keep track of the game at all through the first two game days. I figured I'd be killed off for non-participation or whatever. When I checked the game for the first time early into Day Three and saw I was still in the game, I started messaging a few people. Really, just to get their views of the game rather than directly asking who they were. My intial suspicions of the mafia settled on insanolord (since I thought it would be perfect if the Jon Lindemann character was the godfather) and BeautifulShy.
What's funny is that BeautifulShy sent me a PM, but because of how the forum showed the message, I thought it was an old message from the previous mafia game and ignored it! So kind of felt bad about that, especially when I joined in voting her out.
Started talking to Khush. He kept pushing me to double vote Shy out (after I pointed out to him that such an option was even available in this game!) to prove I was a townie. But there were so many voting against her that I wanted to take a chance and see if I would survive to double vote at a more opportune time. Plus, I didn't see why I had to prove myself to Khush since if he was a townie, all he could do was try to vote me out. He was acting just whacky enough that I was a little suspiciuous of him. I figured if BeautifulShy really was mafia, that would prove Khush could be trusted. He kept veering between thinking I was mafia or the killer. :p
As of the end of Day Four, Khush still suspected me of being mafia. :p I double-voted stevey seeing as how eliminating the killer would give the townies a chance.
Starting toward the end of Day Three and increasingly during Day Four, I suspected ShyGuy of being mafia as he was supposed to talk to insanolord and he never got back to me, even after I brought it up again to see what J.P. said. Still, ShyGuy's the man, so I hated voting against him. I did it to end the day early, but Lucario was busy, etc. so the majority wasn't reached until late anyway. If I had known that, I would have changed my vote to someone else.
Khush's suggestion that ShyGuy kill Mr. Bungle to end the game early was interesting, as I didn't know that was possible.