I don't currently have the time to read all of this thread, but from what I have experienced in these forums........ Strict?....... Too Strict??? Man, I don't know about you, but I have been to many Forums throughout the years (PlanetHalfLife/Unreal/Fortress/SoldierofFortune/etc.) and many more, and if you want to see strict Forums, look around, because this isn't one that is too Strict.
It has rules, yes, but simple rules that are not hard to follow in order to still enjoy the information that is here. These rules are here and if they do seem strict to you, it is because There are a lot of idiots who find it ammusing to be jackarse's in forums and screw everything up for everyone, and these Rules help keep them at bay, and stop things before they get out of hand.
I have seen what happen's to Slack Forums and they turn into crap and just popping on is a waste of your life, because there is nothing worthwhile to read, except things that are similar to something you would find on Jerry Springer.
Want an example? "Planetcounterstrike"
Now I don't know if they cleaned up the place recently, but for the last year or so it has been active, it has been nothig but a sheeite-hole.
And besides, not to be an ass, but if you don't like it, leave. Online Forums.... especially ones that are free to view, are not a Democracy, and you can complain all you want, but it is up to the moderators to actually do something about it.
(BTW: I am not picking on anyone in paticular, just speaking my mind)