Clearly up the BS.
The board of directors run the show, and nintendo's man the the freaking chairman for crying out loud (IE president).
And no they are not the judges, developers can summit this opinions (follow the rules on AIAS Website for information.
"Since its inception in 1996, the Academy of Interactive Arts and Sciences has relied on the leadership and direction of its board of directors. These men and women, all leaders of the interactive software industry, have volunteered their time and resources to help the Academy advance its mission of promoting awareness of the art and science of interactive games and entertainment. Each director has lent his or her talent and prestige to the common concerns of the interactive entertainment industry.
The Academy's Board of Directors is composed of the following industry leaders:
Don James, Nintendo of America, Chair (Like I said, top dog)
Ted Price, Insomniac Games, Vice Chair
John Sutyak, Infogrames, Secretary
Yves Blehaut, Infogrames
Rick Giolito, Electronic Arts
Lorne Lanning, Oddworld Inhabitants
Douglas Lowenstein, IDSA
Laird Malamed, Activision
Stuart Moulder, Microsoft
Ray Muzyka, Bioware Corp.
Paul Provenzano, Academy of Interactive Arts & Sciences
Mike Ryder, Sierra Entertainment
Jesse Schell, Walt Disney Imagineering
Bruce Shelley, Ensemble Studios
Shuhei Yoshida, Sony Computer Entertainment of America "
Voting ProceduresWhich means there's 100's if not 1000's that can cast votes, it's a developers award show after all :0.
Comparing one review site like GS really doesn't mean much in the majority don't feel the same way, take it's review of SMS for example, it recieved a mere 8 which is quite a bit lower than most.
*Shinning the light* back in the eyes of the blind
.