Ceric, you can't reject being recruited. Recruitment is supposed to be one of the ways the mafia is evened out with the uber-powerful townies and their librarian and the myriad roles they have. Yes, the townies also had a cop, the mole, and the magician (if used properly) to tell them who mafia were. This game, at least with the addition of the 2nd mafia, was stacked for the townies.
And now you're denying a legitimate action that was basically only one small way that the mafias could hope to even out with the townies. Sorry, Shy, but that's just not cool. As a mafia member (which you were, whether you agreed with it or not), your allegiance changes. You don't like it? Too bad. It's called playing fair.
BigJim used a mafia power and, with some luck, made the play of the game. And you won't honor that great bit of strategy? It's like playing chess, and someone gets their pawn all the way across the board, but you won't give them a queen. In fact, you take the queen they should've been given, change its color to your own, and set it up to checkmate him. Does that seem fair? Because that's basically what you did.
So, congrats, townies. Revel in the sacrifice your friend made. You may think I'm a sore loser or something, but in my book, the first sore loser was Shyguy.