So I finished Uncharted last night. Simply spectacular. In case anyone hasn't finished it yet I won't spoil the story, but it is certainly compelling enough to keep you thinking, "Ok, just one more chapter" through the first play through. In fact, it was my wife who usually urged me to keep going so she could see what would happen next, and that has NEVER happened with a game in our house.
All in all, I would easily give this game 5 Cigars out of 5. The only gripe I had, and a minor one at that, was picking up weapons and ammo, it can be a bit skittish. Other than that though, the game is an absolute pleasure to play through the first time, with enough to drag you back in for some of the harder difficulty settings down the road.