Well, you just had to complicate things. The tally of votes is as follows:
Stogi - 3
Lucario - 2
Dasmos - 1
Pokepal148 - 1
TOPHATANT123 - 1
The problem is that Silenced has two votes in play. One for Pokepal148 and one for Stogi. When that happens both votes would be cancelled out which would be a tie between Stogi and Lucario. As per the precedent I set last game I hosted with the Majority Vote Rule, in the case of a tie, neither person is eliminated since you've had 48 hours to resolve the situation and the focus is on a majority vote not ties.
However, Silenced complicates it further by putting in a bold unvote before his vote for Stogi. I'm thinking he put that there to show he was changing his prior vote from Pokepal148 to now vote Stogi. However, he doesn't mention Pokepal148's name after the unvote so it's just sitting there blank. My guess is that he is playing and voting in a way that is done on a different forum but I'm not sure which forum that might be as I've never seen it that way. Although, deduction and logic would imply that Silenced would cancel his vote and may have been implying that he was cancelling his vote against Pokepal148, it isn't clearly or explicitly stated that is what he is doing. For all I know, he typed in the bold unvote by accident in his haste to post his long message.
My policy as a host has always been to stick to the rule as much as I can of letting the players decide the game. In situations, like this, where there could be interpretations of what was meant and an arguments made for or against cancelling his Pokepal148 vote, I feel it best to just invalidate his votes and not take it upon myself to play for the player or players involved. Moreover, Silenced has plenty of experience at this point with our Mafia games and should fully be aware of the fact that he needs to edit to unbold or unvote his previous vote/post before making a new vote. My guess is that tomorrow will result in the Majority Vote Rule being enacted so this won't be a huge sticking point.
As such, the official final tally will be:
Stogi - 2
Lucario - 2
Dasmos - 1
TOPHATANT123 - 1
We now enter the night action period. For those with night actions, you have 12 hours to submit them. If you have submitted them, you have an hour after submission in case you want to change your mind before it is locked in.