Changing to vote TOPHATANT123 for a few reasons:
1) I buy the logic of replying to day 1 thread without some form of participation in voting dubious, as stated before.
2) Not a fan of a tie, and while I didn't see anything regarding tiebreaker rules in the sign-up thread, don't want anything to prevent the progression of this game.
3) Not that I necessarily buy that Insanolord is innocent, but this is the most active he's been in a game lately that I can remember. A silent game is a dead game for townies.