Quote
Originally posted by: vudu
Well that was officially the worst movie ending of all time.
Music was good, but kind of cheesy in an overly-dramatic kind of way. But then again, it's the 70's, so what do you expect?
Did you really just call the ending to Chinatown the worst movie ending of all time? Because I'm reading those words and I have a rough time believing anyone actually thinks that.
The music in that film was actually more inspired by the 1940s; at the very least, it's a nostalgic look back at 40s movie music. Jerry Goldsmith himself was a hack (check him on IMDB), but he has plenty of good scores to his name (among them Chinatown, The Burbs, Patton, and Gremlins).
But back to Joel.
This is the best part of the press release:
Quote
[Joel Goldsmith's style has] come to be marked by big, bold, symphonic scores.
Ahahahahahahah, right right, like I can name a hack movie composer that isn't "marked" by this "style."
Sorry for being pretentious, but this press release is insulting. For one, Joel Goldsmith is a famous composer's son, not a famous composer. Jerry Goldsmith himself was famous only through prolificacy, and his work varies in quality. Secondly, Joel Goldsmith may be able to write great music for this video game, but the question is why? I am fully in support of crossover between mediums; having John Williams or Philip Glass score a video game would be great. However, the framing of this release makes it seem as though Joel Goldsmith got this job because otherwise it would be done by just another worthless video game composer. It's like saying we got Steven Spielberg to direct the cinematics, or Charlie Kaufman to write the script. Why are video games so often trying to imitate dramatic film? It's a problem plaguing the War genre especially (among other things).
The problem is that even video game makers see their art as inferior. If we can get a "real" artist to help us, maybe we'll make better art. Please, Hollywood, teach us how to make games! It's pathetic. Make your own music, your own story, your own rules, otherwise there will be truth to the statement that videogames are just movies with options. If video games are art, they have to be able to stand on their own.