Quote
Originally posted by: theaveng
What does FF6 (akaFF3-US) have that FF7/9 do not? (just curious) I've played FF6 and it was a very good game, but I didn't think it was superior to FF7 or FF9. What does FF6 have that makes it so outstanding in your mind?
Also would you rate FF4 (akaFF2-US) beter or worse than FF7/9? (again just curious)
I haven't checked this topic in so long; this response may be a bit late, but here it goes. (hopefully the question was directed at me)
The main reason I liked FF6 over 7 and 9 was the story and characters. Gameplay wise I liked all the Final Fantasy games (except 8 wasn't my thing; too slow and monotonous for me.) FF6's story and characters were a good blend of deep and simple. There are magical beings, known as Espers, and an evil empire wants to suck out their magic to conquer the world. (That is the short version.) When FF7 went on the whole "save the planet/sprit of the earth" thing I was just waiting for Captain Planet and the planeteers to show up. And there were parts of the story that did not seem fleshed out or explained enough to me, such as the ancients and their origin and such.
The character's lacked the same charm that the old ones had in my opinion. Part of the problem is the newer Final Fantasies are moving to more movie like presentations, no longer presented in sprite animations and text boxes, but in cut scenes and such. This thematic direction is not a problem to me in and of itself, but it just throws the story of the game even further into the foreground, thus making the flaws or weak spots in the stories all the more visible and dissapointing. The newer generation of Final Fantasies just reek of the same crap they used to make the "Spirits Within" storyline. That was not a good movie story wise, and as the games become more akin to movies, that kind of thing won't cut it.