Topic: Mafia XXXVI: Donkey Kong. Day 3. Underwater Aquatica.

[Khushrenada]

Lousy Pale not even choosing a character. He got his.

[Khushrenada]

Announcement Post:

The following people are dead:

Pale - Townie (killed by vote)
DrewMG - Townie (killed by mafia)

So much townie bloodshed.


Voting ends at the same time. Midnight EST. Night actons due due by 30 minutes thereafter. With that, I'm going back to bed. Night everyone.

[Stratos]

I vote Mop it up.

Her PMs have convinced me that she is Mafia and she is more evasive than usual.

[that Baby guy]

Day 1's rundown

--Thatguy: un-vote Vudu (Doesn't like Vudu)
--Mop_it_up: un-vote Stratos (Traditional Day 1 vote)
GP: Vote Stratos (Following Mop_it_up's vote)
Dasmos: Vote DAaaMan (Posted first in the thread out of him and Pap)
DAaaMan: Vote Dasmos (Retalliation vote)
--thatguy: un-vote Stogi (Stogi's claim of ignorance to PM'ed roles.)
Spak: Vote Insanolord (hunch
Pale: Vote Insanolord (Likes Spak's hunch)
Pap: Vote Dasmos (No reason cited)
--Maxi: un-vote Pale (Just to see what happens)
--thatguy: un-vote Vudu (It was possible Stogi made a mistake)
Stratos: Vote Dasmos (Break the tie between he and Dasmos)
Thatguy: Vote Stogi (Stogi asked people not to vote)
Maxi: Vote Insanolord (No reason cited at the time, lack of participation stated later)
--Stogi: Un-vote someone. (Not sure who or why, it turned to un-vote Bubba Khush)
Stogi: Vote Pap (No reason cited)
Mop_it_up: Vote Insanolord (To break the tie; wouldn't be here, so wouldn't be missed)
Vudu: Vote Insanolord (To prevent possibility of a tie)

End tally:

Stratos: 1
DAaaMan: 1
Pap: 1
Stogi: 1
Dasmos: 3
Insanolord: 5

Day 2's rundown

--thatguy: un-vote Stogi (Believes post about not having a PM to be a charade)
Dasmos: Vote Pap64 (Has a '64' in his name)
Spak: Vote Pale (Followed Spak's hunch about Insanolord yesterday, effectively beginning a bandwagon)
--DrewMG: un-vote Stogi (Likes thatguy's logic)
--vudu: un-vote Nickmitch (Nickmitch is experienced, but hiding)
--thatguy: un-vote Vudu (Vote to eliminate chance of Day 1 tie, taking things out of nullifier's hands)
stevey: vote Pale (Kills off stevey for always outing Khush)
Pale: vote Vudu (guaranteed Insanolord's death on Day 1)
Vudu: vote Pale (Pale's logic is poor; I wasn't around last night to prevent a tie, so a tie could have been worse)
Stogi: vote Kracken (no reason cited)
DAaaMan: vote Dasmos (no reason cited; "DAAAASSSMMMOOOSSSS")
Mop_it_up: vote Pale (Pale's previous post, "I like bandwagons," reminds her of how he played as mafia before)
thatguy: vote Pale (Pale latched on to Spak's vote)
Pap: vote Pale (Joined the bandwagon, no idea who else to vote for)
kraken: vote Pale (likes to follow, not sure what else to do)

Day 2's end tally:
Pap: 1
Vudu: 1
Kraken: 1
Dasmos: 1
Pale: 7

If anyone would like me to make an alteration to their stated motives that does lie in with what was said during the previous day, just let me know and I'll make the change, as long as it's brief, less than one line, and honest.

Late Edit:  Day 2 accidentally said my first vote was for Vudu, when in reality, it was for Stogi.

[that Baby guy]

I hope no one minds the double post, but I'm going to keep that post by itself, trying to avoid any bias that I would show in usual posts.

Anyways, I'm shocked by the insignificant number of people who've contacted me about the nullifier role.  I'm truly surprised about it.  As far as who I believe is mafia, my short list, with reasons, is this:
Vudu -- He sealed the deal on Insanolord, preventing a tie.  Had he been familiar with the rules, due to the nullifier, ties may not be a bad thing when the alliance of the voters are unknown, because the fate of the tied players is in the hands of a bonafide townie.  Beyond that, had things stayed a tie, in this game, it would mean all tied players live, a theme I'm personally against, but it doesn't mean double deaths, like most Khush games.

Stogi -- Now Stogi's even admitted to me, though via PM, that he was feigning ignorance when he made his post.  His reasoning was that he believed by acting stupid, people would believe he's a townie, and a townie alliance would begin.  I then spoke to him about Vudu, and afterwards, he accused me of being a member of the mafia.

Mop_it_up -- I just doubt that Stratos would seriously go after Mop_it_up if he didn't absolutely believe she's in the mafia.  Also, I don't see why she switched her vote on the first day, from Stratos to Insanolord, but that said, on Day 2, I did just about the same thing with little reason.

I'm going to un-vote Mop_it_up for now, I think she's a good lead, but I'm willing to shift to the other two on my list, as well.

[Dasmos]

Stogi voting for another random player out of the blue without a reason strikes me as odd.

[Stratos]

I agree with your thoughts on suspects, Thatguy.

[Stogi]

Now just vait a minute



Thatguy, I think your forgetting the most important part of conversation.

It is true, I, Kashogi Y. Stogi feigned ignorance of the rules but not for the reason I stated to thatguy. I told him I wanted people to instantly believe I was townie and thus begin a townie alliance. The plan, I admitted, was stupid. But that was just a ploy to see how he would react. And react he did.

Little did he know, my real plan was to see who was dumb enough to instigate me as mafia for such a pitiful reason. Everyone else thought I was playing dumb for dumbness sake, but thatguy thought I was trying to be clever even though it should have been laughed at for being so transparent.

Now why is that? It's because he is mafia. He was trying to use me as any mafia player would in order to kill an innocent townie. When I told him that I had lied, he merely shrugged it off and stated something to the effect of "well I guess we're back to square one." That sealed the deal.

VOTE THATGUY

[that Baby guy]

Wait, so what's the original reason you posted that you didn't receive a PM?

You have made it clear that you knew townies weren't supposed to receive PMs this game.

You told me you did it to gather a townie alliance because you believed they'd believe you were ignorant to that rule.

Now you're saying from the start it was a charade to catch me for being suspicious of your admitted lie, right?

[kraken613]

Voting Mop_it_up because anyone who like Wii Music is up to something. Its all part of a big conspiracy!

By the way its Kraken not Kracken....

[Spak-Spang]

I can't jump on the Mop it up band wagon yet.  Sorry.  But I do believe Thatguy may be on to somebody, so I will go with that. 

투표 Vudu

Stogi, you are debating too much...you are either a very guilty mafia or a troubled desparate townie.  I am not voting for or against you today.  There is just not enough to go on yet. 

 

[that Baby guy]

Mistake fixed, kraken.

[Stogi]

I can't jump on the Mop it up band wagon yet.  Sorry.  But I do believe Thatguy may be on to somebody, so I will go with that. 

투표 Vudu

Stogi, you are debating too much...you are either a very guilty mafia or a troubled desparate townie.  I am not voting for or against you today.  There is just not enough to go on yet. 

 

Your comment is laughable considering all that thatguy has written up.

It's laughable and curious.

[that Baby guy]

I'd still like to know the pathway at which you arrived to the conclusions, and your goals behind your actions.  I don't see how what you did at the beginning would create a pathway to believe I'm in the mafia.

I called you out.
You confessed I was right.
I posted what you said.
You say everything that happened was an elaborate scheme to out me as mafia.

I don't get it.

[Stratos]

I'd still like to know the pathway at which you arrived to the conclusions, and your goals behind your actions.  I don't see how what you did at the beginning would create a pathway to believe I'm in the mafia.

I called you out.
You confessed I was right.
I posted what you said.
You say everything that happened was an elaborate scheme to out me as mafia.
Then you try and divert attention to another player

I don't get it.

Hmm

[Stogi]

It was simple really.

[that Baby guy]

All I did was say what I believed, followed by saying what you told me.  Where's the scheme, and why does that make me a mafia member?

[Stogi]

Well it was two things:

One, you forced the issue. While everyone else saw through my "terrible" plan, you are desperately trying to use it as proof.

And two, when confronted with the truth, after two whole days of KYS brand shadiness mind you, instead of being justified and screaming to high heaven what I had done. You SHRUGGED IT OFF.

Now why would anyone in public desperately try to prove I was lying, then in private not care?

Mafia.

[that Baby guy]

I didn't shrug off anything.  You ended your last PM to me with the phrase "Checkmate."  I replied.  From there, a new day began, and I still hadn't heard anything from you, so in the end, I decided to post what you said the idea was.  You were the one who shrugged things off, and stopped talking with me, Stogi.

As far as everyone who "saw through" your plan, I don't think that makes sense, either.  Which of your stated plans was it that everyone but me saw through?

Edit: For the record, I'm sticking to the "Mop_it_up" vote, though.  You've got to clear the crumbs off the floor as the first step to keeping the pests out of the house.

[Spak-Spang]

Hmmm....Isn't it too early in the game for this type of thing?

[Dasmos]

I don't know about this Mop-it_up vote, is the only lead the Stratos one? I guess I'd like a little more info on these so called PMs.

So for now I'm gonna VOTE KASHOGI. He seems to be squirming now.

[Stogi]

What have I written to show any sign that I'm uncomfortable?

My logic is sound.

[DAaaMan64]

 This is dumb, I'd like to kill the guide now, because we've killed enough townies for once.

I'm voting thatguy

[nickmitch]

Vote Vudu  He may not have started the Pale bandwagon, but got it rolling.

[vudu]

Guys, we have two people here (Stogi and Daaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaman) who are voting for thatguy, someone who we know is a townie.

Why am I the only one who has a problem with this?

VOTE STOGI

You don't have to like thatguy, but you need to accept that he's on our side.

Attention:  If you are the nullifer and you are not thatguy it is imperative that you come forward.  You don't have to post it in the day thread but you need to PM someone so they can alert everyone that thatguy is a dirty liar.