1201
TalkBack / Re: The Positives and Pitfalls of Review Democratization
« on: April 10, 2017, 09:08:10 AM »
Tangentially related question, but do consumers really use metacritic? I feel like that website, along with things like Rotten Tomatoes are more commonly sourced by the industry itself and "reception" sections on Wikipedia articles, than by actual individuals.
However, that's an entirely unfounded hypothesis. Would be curious to hear if anyone on here uses it a lot? I've looked at Metacritic a few times for games, less so for movies, but never found it super useful. The user reviews are often absolute garbage for one, and what I personally dislike is that the Critic scores use so many websites I've never heard of.
Just clicked the first game on the site, Persona 5 right now, and you've got notable sources like the Guardian, Washington Post, EGM, Gamespot etc. alongside things called SixthAxis and Cheat Code Central. Not to disparage those websites, since I don't know them, but that's not very helpful to me. Similar thing with Rotten Tomatoes.
It's probably my fault for defaulting only to places I've heard of and not stepping out that comfort zone, but I'm just trying to illustrate how the score aggregators don't really help out an average joe like me since they're not at all aligned with my personal outlets of choice. Not saying they SHOULD only display my preferred filter bubble, that'd ultimately be even worse probably. But yeah in reality that's what I'll end up doing myself. Just wondering if others have similar experiences with review aggregators?
However, that's an entirely unfounded hypothesis. Would be curious to hear if anyone on here uses it a lot? I've looked at Metacritic a few times for games, less so for movies, but never found it super useful. The user reviews are often absolute garbage for one, and what I personally dislike is that the Critic scores use so many websites I've never heard of.
Just clicked the first game on the site, Persona 5 right now, and you've got notable sources like the Guardian, Washington Post, EGM, Gamespot etc. alongside things called SixthAxis and Cheat Code Central. Not to disparage those websites, since I don't know them, but that's not very helpful to me. Similar thing with Rotten Tomatoes.
It's probably my fault for defaulting only to places I've heard of and not stepping out that comfort zone, but I'm just trying to illustrate how the score aggregators don't really help out an average joe like me since they're not at all aligned with my personal outlets of choice. Not saying they SHOULD only display my preferred filter bubble, that'd ultimately be even worse probably. But yeah in reality that's what I'll end up doing myself. Just wondering if others have similar experiences with review aggregators?

Still secretly wishing for an F-Zero entry on Switch but will accept this as substitute!