in reply to dr synthetic ...
Quote
GC users are totally different than PS2 users. Most of us aren't just looking for a game to play until our next game... the standard GC user seems to me to be interested in *all* good games
i honestly couldn't agree with you more. for me, money isn't the limiting factor in the games i play...time is. i simply do not have enough time to play all the great games that are coming out. however, when master quest was released for free with wind waker, it was enough that i had to push another game i would have played instead off my list (probably resident evil 0, in this particular case). thus, nintendo lost out on money. and i'm sure that i'm not the only one this happened to.
Quote
ports of old games are merely incentives for true fans (people who buy Nintendo's product already).
if true fans are going to buy the game anyway, why do they need incentive?
Quote
Also, in response to why we'd want to play Mario Kart or Mario Kart 64... some of us were around for these games when they came out, and we appreciate and love them to this day.
i have to say, i almost resent this comment. it seems like you're insinuating that i'm some 12 year old punk kid who wasn't around for the snes. i'm 23 years old, i've been playing nintendo games since the original nes, and i've owned both existing versions of mario kart. all i was saying is that with some types of games--most often sports games--when the new version gets released, the old version gets replaced. and while i'm certainly not saying this holds true for everybody or for all games, it happens fairly often. (example: madden 2003 pretty much replaces madden 2002)
Quote
As for my suggestion?
the only worthwhile suggestion in the bunch was the starfox 64dd add-on. the point of the oot/master quest bonus disc (as joshnickerson so kindly pointed out) was to get master quest into the hands of u.s. consumers. since it was never released, we had never had the chance to play it. if you want to play mario 64 break out your n64.