Nintendo World Report Forums

Gaming Forums => Nintendo Gaming => Topic started by: Mannypon on March 19, 2004, 10:32:12 PM

Title: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 19, 2004, 10:32:12 PM
I was just at gamecube europe and they ran a story on a rumoured ff game.  Visit their site for the info and link to a picture.  Basically Vjump (of Never Happening rumour fame) is goin to shed some light on the game in their next issue.  On the link on their site, they show a picture of a teaser wit the title Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing and at the bottom there is text where you can see ps2 and gcn.  If this is all true, its basically a definite we getting another ff on gamecube.  What do you think this game could be like.  Ive read that it could be a ff game combining some of the themes of ff 7-9 but I aint sure what that means lol.  Aint sure why gamecube europe is the only site that Ive found thats running the romour given that theirs a link with some info to go by.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mario on March 19, 2004, 11:02:57 PM
Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing.

Now there's an unattractive name.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: akdaman1 on March 19, 2004, 11:30:06 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Mario
Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing.

Now there's an unattractive name.


Whoa your Avatar ...know theres an unactractive face...LOl  
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: DrZoidberg on March 19, 2004, 11:43:38 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: akdaman1


Whoa your Avatar ...know theres an unactractive face...LOl


now there's an unnatractive post.

oh a 'traditional' FF on the cube? cool i guess, but doesn't really pique my interest, unless it's about Pirates
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: KDR_11k on March 20, 2004, 12:58:30 AM
I just wish there was some truth to that, but the chance is so slim...
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 20, 2004, 01:20:36 AM
Here's the link to the Cube Europe article.

The bar at the bottom is pretty easy to translate, even if you don't know any Japanese, because it's using extremely-well-known words.

It clearly says "Kingdom Hearts 2 PS2 - GCN Final Fantasy A.C- DVD".

The "A.C" obviously means "Advent Children", the new movie-sequel to FF7.

So I think it's saying that KH2 is on both the PS2 and Cube (instead of PS2-exclusive, as was previously reported/assumed), and FF:AC is on DVD (which we already knew).

The bottom line with "GCN" doesn't seem to have anything to do with this "FF: Guilty Wing" that was just mentioned.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Uncle Rich AiAi on March 20, 2004, 01:56:19 AM
Very good pickup rudy_onix!  I know a little Japanese myself too.

This doesn't 100% confirm that Kingdom Hearts 2 is coming to GC (until we get an announcement from Sqare-Enix themselves that is), but I'm wondering, isn't it a direct sequel to the first game, and needs to be played to know the story?
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 20, 2004, 02:42:15 AM
I haven't played Kingdom Hearts myself, so I don't know how much you may need to have played the first one.

The ony thing I know about the plot is that some people have said that it stole it's plot idea from the "Revolutionary Girl Utena" anime movie (the movie, not the TV series). So... umm... yeah. If you've seen the movie, that might say a lot. If not... well... I don't think I could describe it. So don't ask...

This link from RPGFan seems helpful.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: joshnickerson on March 20, 2004, 03:01:24 AM
I've seen one of my friends play Kingdom Hearts and it looked pretty sweet. I'd be more excited about that sequel on the Cube than another Final Fantasy game.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Pale on March 20, 2004, 03:21:46 AM
Wait, if nintendo can take away sony's exclusivity on a game like Kingdom Hearts, this is HUGE news.  Remember that article a while back that said Square Enix whats the KH franchise to be one of their pillars?  This is almost as big as if FF XII was annouced for GCN as well.  I'm excited if this is true.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Termin8Anakin on March 20, 2004, 03:33:32 AM
The pic of the big guy in inverted colours seems to be the Squall from Final Fantasy 8.
Perhaps Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing is Final Fantasy XIII-2?
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Aretak on March 20, 2004, 04:03:55 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Termin8Anakin
Perhaps Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing is Final Fantasy XIII-2?

Final Fantasy XIII-2? That's thirteen-two, not eight-two. I assume you meant Final Fantasy VIII-2.

Anyway, Kingdom Hearts 2 would be a good title for the GameCube to have. I remember there were rumours of a port of the original, but the developer said that he didn't want to put Kingdom Hearts on the GameCube just because it featured 'kiddy' characters. He noted that everyone was expecting him to do it for that reason alone, and he didn't want to play up to the stereotype that games that are seen as 'kiddy' always appear on the GameCube.

However, if this rumour turns out to be true, I'll be the first in line to buy it for the Cube. The original is an excellent game.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Uncle Rich AiAi on March 20, 2004, 04:08:43 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: ruby_onix
I haven't played Kingdom Hearts myself, so I don't know how much you may need to have played the first one.

The ony thing I know about the plot is that some people have said that it stole it's plot idea from the "Revolutionary Girl Utena" anime movie (the movie, not the TV series). So... umm... yeah. If you've seen the movie, that might say a lot. If not... well... I don't think I could describe it. So don't ask...

This link from RPGFan seems helpful.

aha!  Square don't always come up with original storylines after all!  Thanks for that!

Quote

Originally posted by: Termin8Anakin
The pic of the big guy in inverted colours seems to be the Squall from Final Fantasy 8.
Perhaps Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing is Final Fantasy VIII-2?

Good lord.  I hope not, and it seems unlikely.  I tried out the FF8 demo, and hated it.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: yellowfellow on March 20, 2004, 04:42:13 AM
keep in mind next month's issue will be the april 1st issue...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 20, 2004, 04:49:58 AM
I hate how Final Fantasy games end up, but I wouldn't mind Kingdom Hearts...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 20, 2004, 07:29:42 AM
dam thats a buzz kill, I wasnt a big fan of the first kindom hearts gameplay.  The fightin felt a little stiff.  I still think squareenix and nintendo should team up again to do another mario rpg.  I was a big fan of the original.  Still wondering what the ff guilty wing is.  My guess, judging by the title, that it could be the action game I heard of with ff characters such as cloud.  The title sounds more like an action game title moreso than an anime.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: PaLaDiN on March 20, 2004, 10:18:39 AM
Call me a cynic, but I'm pretty sure this is fake.

I don't think Japan uses "GCN"... they just use "GC".

What I heard anyway.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Draygaia on March 20, 2004, 01:48:58 PM
I wouldn't mind another Final Fantasy.  I don't see where you guys have this dislike towards the Final Fantasy series.  I like them better than most console RPGs out there.  Skies of Arcadia was kinda well not as interesting as any Final Fantasy.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Pale on March 20, 2004, 04:13:05 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Manny
dam thats a buzz kill, I wasnt a big fan of the first kindom hearts gameplay.  The fightin felt a little stiff.  I still think squareenix and nintendo should team up again to do another mario rpg.  I was a big fan of the original.  Still wondering what the ff guilty wing is.  My guess, judging by the title, that it could be the action game I heard of with ff characters such as cloud.  The title sounds more like an action game title moreso than an anime.
The fighting wasn't very deep and does need some polish.  Thats what sequels are for!    Anyway, I'm so psyched about KH2 and KHCoM that I can't even stand it.  Being able to play it with the greatest controller ever would just be icing on the cake.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: KDR_11k on March 20, 2004, 05:57:42 PM
Even if it was just the sequel, sequels are designed in a way so you can play them without having played the first part and won't miss out more than a few references. Considering how many Disney games appeared on the Gamecube, maybe Disney applied some pressure?

That Guilty Wing is either a joke or a special feature, I doubt it's a real game. Even if, it'd fit in with the orange blob on the right (something about PS2, PC and online, probably FF11). If you ask me, that "Guilty Wing" is probably a comic they made using FF11 and print only in their own magazine (therefore "only for"). Or maybe they're making an online cometition or something.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 20, 2004, 07:51:43 PM
Quote

The bottom line with "GCN" doesn't seem to have anything to do with this "FF: Guilty Wing" that was just mentioned.


But then again...

I was bored and tried to translate some of the purple stuff near the bottom.

The first two lines say "fu a i na ru fu a n to shi-" (Final Fantasy)
...and "gi ru te i- u i n gu !" (Guilty Wing!).

I don't know what the four Chineese symbols mean.

The last line is "ge- mu kyu- bu" (GameCube).  


Edit: The red part to the right of the logo says "Sugoi!" (Japanese for "Wow!")
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 20, 2004, 09:21:22 PM
GameCube Heaven has more stuff translated than I've been able to manage.

The top big-letter stuff is "Next Issue" and "Exclusive News".

The Chineese symbols under the logo that I couldn't translate say "Fully Loaded Information".

I still don't know what the stuff on the right says, but it obviously has something to do with the PS2, the Network Adaptor, and a PC version. Most likely some sort of large article about FFXI. Probably not breaking news, or anything we really need to hold our breath until the next issue for.

Edit: I just noticed that I've been spelling "Chinese" wrong. Sorry about that.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Deguello on March 20, 2004, 11:38:32 PM
Kingdom Hearts 2 looks ok.  The first Kingdom Hearts I sorta liked, but I still ended up hating the game every time I play it.  It's not the Disney stuff.  The whole "romp through Disneyworld" is actually kinda neat.  It's the fact that I can't play for 10 minutes without seeing some lame Final Fantasy cameo that bothers me.  Hell "cameo" is putting it mildly, as it seems they are integral characters.  These FF people, whether they died in their respective games or not, totally disjoint the game.  It makes the general plot read like a Yahoo! Groups fanfic.  And I hate fanfics.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: KDR_11k on March 21, 2004, 02:28:22 AM
ruby: Now that sounds a lot more interesting. The whole logo was probably a mock up to fill the space, then.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 21, 2004, 06:34:17 AM
"The game will be titled Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing and is planned as a GameCube exclusive. It is being developed by Game Designer's Studio and is said to follow the more traditional style of Final Fantasy games that most all fans have grown to love.

On another note, Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing takes "inspirations" from Final Fantasy 7-9, and Squall Leonheart from FF8 will be the main character. "

GCA

Meh...I can't stand FFVIII... ;___;
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Pale on March 21, 2004, 07:00:30 AM
Wait, so is it true that it says "Kingdom Hearts II PS2 * GCN at the bottom? or is that just a confusion???
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 21, 2004, 07:34:19 AM
Well no one really knows for sure yet... :\
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Aretak on March 21, 2004, 09:08:48 AM
Final Fantasy VIII was an amazing game... the story was complex and interesting, the world was vibrant and large, and the battle system was a big improvement over Final Fantasy VII, in my opinion. It has the best FMV of any of them, and probably the best ending as well. Squall was a decent lead character, and the supporting cast were interesting enough.

Despite the fact I still don't believe this news, a new Final Fantasy game starring Squall would interest me greatly.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Chongman on March 21, 2004, 10:49:43 AM
ff VII was an above par game...but the battle system was stale and bland rather then original as it was supposed to be. The fmvs rocked and the story was top notch, but man the battle system just wasn't FUN.

If this IS true, and both guilty wing AND kingdom hearts II are BOTH coming to the gamecube...oh square enix....could it be true?

I would parade down the streets proclaiming dreams can become reality.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Aretak on March 21, 2004, 11:44:18 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Chongman
ff VII was an above par game...but the battle system was stale and bland rather then original as it was supposed to be.

It's easy to say that now after experiencing the perfection that was Final Fantasy X's battle system, but at the time VIII's was pretty damn good. I liked the fact that it was more complex than VII's, and required a little more thought about what to do for each turn (be it to draw, attack or otherwise).
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Koopa Troopa on March 21, 2004, 11:58:36 AM
Quote

On another note, Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing takes "inspirations" from Final Fantasy 7-9, and Squall Leonheart from FF8 will be the main character. "

GCA

Meh...I can't stand FFVIII... ;___;




NOOOOO! Not Squall, good God, anyone but Squall. This sucks. I swear if they use that stupid magic system from VIII I'll kill someone.  
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Darc Requiem on March 21, 2004, 12:46:10 PM
Well the stories a fake so don't go worrying yourselfs. GCadvanced.com has the info confirming the story as false. FF8 was the worst Final Fantasy game I've played. So I'm glad its a fake. I despised FF7 and FF8 was even worse. I'm sure there really is a traditional Final Fantasy game in development for GC though. There is too much smoke around this story for it to be baseless. After the travesty that was FFX-2 I'm weary of a sequel. If they did make another sequel, I wouldn't mine one to Final Fantasy 4 but that would be contigent on Square not botching it.

Darc Requiem
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 21, 2004, 12:54:45 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Bill
"The game will be titled Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing and is planned as a GameCube exclusive. It is being developed by Game Designer's Studio and is said to follow the more traditional style of Final Fantasy games that most all fans have grown to love.

On another note, Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing takes "inspirations" from Final Fantasy 7-9, and Squall Leonheart from FF8 will be the main character. "

GCA

Meh...I can't stand FFVIII... ;___;


GameCube Advanced has updated, saying it's fake.

"Update: It seems that the story has proven to be false according to Japanese sources. Apparently, the newest issue of V-Jump does not report on any new information regarding a Final Fantasy title for GameCube."

But I think GCA was jumping the gun, saying that V-Jump said it's a "traditional" FF game, and that it'll be starring Squall, and all sorts of other stuff not supported by that page scan. If this teaser page is right, then V-Jump isn't reporting anything about a new FF game right now. They're teasing us, saying that they will say something next month.

Quote

Wait, so is it true that it says "Kingdom Hearts II PS2 * GCN at the bottom? or is that just a confusion???


It says "ki n gu do mu ha-- tsu 2  PS2 - GCN  fu a i na ru fu a n to shi--  A.C-  DVD" (a long dash is supposed to be held for a second while pronouncing it).

Cleaned up, that's "Kingdom Hearts 2 PS2 - GCN Final Fantasy A.C- DVD"

"Final Fantasy A.C- DVD" seems to mean FF: Advent Children, so it should probably be split like this.
Kingdom Hearts 2 PS2 - GCN
Final Fantasy A.C- DVD

But that's assuming it wasn't a typo, or a Freudian slip, or (as most of the naysayers seem to believe), maybe the entire page isn't real, and was made up by someone with Photoshop (even though nobody has found the slightest evidence to suggest that, beyond simple "doubt").
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Uncle Rich AiAi on March 21, 2004, 03:36:45 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: Darc Requiem
Well the stories a fake so don't go worrying yourselfs. GCadvanced.com has the info confirming the story as false. FF8 was the worst Final Fantasy game I've played. So I'm glad its a fake. I despised FF7 and FF8 was even worse. I'm sure there really is a traditional Final Fantasy game in development for GC though. There is too much smoke around this story for it to be baseless. After the travesty that was FFX-2 I'm weary of a sequel. If they did make another sequel, I wouldn't mine one to Final Fantasy 4 but that would be contigent on Square not botching it.

Darc Requiem

I'm glad there's someone I can agree with on FF8 and FFX-2!

If GC gets a "traditional" FF game, I would like it to have new characters & story, not Squall.

Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Pale on March 21, 2004, 04:45:12 PM
I want the gamecube to get a traditional FF *style* game from square...  And I want the main character to be named Link.  
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Berny on March 21, 2004, 05:30:07 PM
Are you implying that you want a Lara Croft RPG?
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: KDR_11k on March 21, 2004, 06:47:15 PM
If they ever again include Squall, please, give us the option to kill random people. This guy let Seifer run away waaay too often when a single decapitation could have saved the world. They should use a character like Ryudo from Grandia II (I could at least identify with him and didn't get the urge to kill him or his girlfriend, as opposed to Squall).
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 21, 2004, 07:37:12 PM
if they were to make a sequal to any of the ff games I'd say either 4 or 6 (def 6 IMO) 6 had a huge selection of characters and the majority of them were all great and memorable.  Also, on a side note, I hope they let us name the dam characters.  I used to love naming everyone in my group.  I know it sounds stupid but it helped me feel more involved in the game.  I doubt it though, with all the voice acting and whatnot in rpgs today, they dont give the option of customization anymore cuase the names are in the voice acted scripts.  Sh*t sucks ass.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Ocarina Blue on March 21, 2004, 10:12:07 PM
FF II and III are awsome. Although (except an hour or so of FFVII which I hated) I haven't played the more recent ones. Personally, I don't see why Square-Enix shouldn't just make something original: like they did 90% of the other ones.  
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Ian Sane on March 22, 2004, 06:20:32 AM
"Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing takes "inspirations" from Final Fantasy 7-9, and Squall Leonheart from FF8 will be the main character."

So let's see here.  FF7 is argueably the most popular RPG or all time and FF9 has a huge cult following.  So naturally the main character from FF8 is used.  I don't quite see the logic there.

This "teaser" is from VJump.  The last time they "teased" something it created the whole stupid MEGAT0N thing.  I think I'm going to assume that all of this is bullsh!t and not get my hopes up.

If we get something else from Square Enix I would like it to be something unique and original instead of another Final Fantasy game.  There's some really irritating flaws in the FF formula (random battles for example) that reappear in EVERY game because it's "tradition" or some equally stupid excuse and if they make something unique they can do whatever they want and not be limited by the FF license.  Do you know what types of games Square makes when they have complete freedom to do what they want?  Games like Chrono Trigger and Vagrant Story.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 22, 2004, 06:38:33 AM
Agreed...Random battles should be a thing of past by now...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Sirmorphix on March 22, 2004, 07:32:32 AM
I don't understand why everyone hates random battle so much.  Personally I couldn't care one way or the other.  If anything I almost prefer it, the only big exceptions that come to mind are Chrono Trigger and Earthbound.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Chongman on March 22, 2004, 07:35:00 AM

So should Ralph Nader and the presidential ballot, but somethings never do change...
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 22, 2004, 07:39:28 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Sirmorphix
I don't understand why everyone hates random battle so much.  Personally I couldn't care one way or the other.  If anything I almost prefer it, the only big exceptions that come to mind are Chrono Trigger and Earthbound.

I like having the option of avoiding battles...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Ian Sane on March 22, 2004, 07:44:47 AM
"I don't understand why everyone hates random battle so much."

Because they're random and I'm not a big fan of being forced to battle when I want to get to the save point or I desperately need to heal.  I don't like having my ability to explore compromised by enemies poping out of nowhere.  And most important of all Chrono Trigger and Super Mario RPG didn't have them and sure enough they're about a hundred times better than any other RPG I've ever played.  The main reason I hate random battles is we've had BETTER so it makes no sense to stick with an inferior design.  Plus most developers use them to artificially make a game longer and those sort of tactics in ANY game design piss me off.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: rpglover on March 22, 2004, 10:28:32 AM
i will say about random battles that i am not bothered by them, but i would rather have a game without them
but has anyone realized that the rpgs without random battles are usually the ones with really great battle systems- for example the grandia series, mario rpg series, chrono trigger, earthbound, and one of my favorite rpgs of all time- valkyrie profile- of course there are some exceptions- some of the tales series games have random battles, but the battle system was very fun
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: WesDawg on March 22, 2004, 11:01:53 AM
I kind like Random Encounters. They're what made RPG's RPGs for a long time. They're also a huge part of what makes 'em challenging. You can't just run ahead all the time, or your party might not be strong enough. So you spend time training 'em and looking for better weapons and such so that you don't end up almost dead hoping you can reach the next save point. Taking 'em out kinda changes the whole genre in a way. In a way that makes it easier for pansies to play. HA HA HA! Yeah that's right. You're a big pansy whoever it was that doesn't like 'em. Role playing used to be about playing a role. Building a team that was unique and your own. Now its more about telling some retarded love story where you really have no control over your characters. Ok thats not true, but nobody complained about 'em when RPGs first came out, and it wasn't cause we couldn't imagine better. It's because they were a big part of the game. Beating FF1 wasn't just about fighting Chaos in the end, it was about the uber-difficulty you had to contend with just to get to him and then to hope you still had enough energy/magic left for the fight. They were part of the challenge. Anyways, I like 'em despite also being discouraged by 'em occasionally. I think you're just not an RPG fan (Mario RPG, while fun, would not be most people's favorite ever), but some sort of half-breed fan of these weird new hybrid genre's that have come out in the wake. That's just my opinion though.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 22, 2004, 11:37:16 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: rpglover
some of the tales series games have random battles, but the battle system was very fun

And that's what Tales of Symphonia improves on... ^_^
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: mouse_clicker on March 22, 2004, 11:39:49 AM
I don't think random encounters is necessarily inferior, I just prefer seeing the enemies. It gives the player more freedom since they can decide whether or not to fight, and hence level up, whereas random encounters keep you on a fairly strict schedule. As a result, nearly all of my favorite RPG's, like Grandia 2, Chrono Trigger, and Earthbound, show the enemies on screen. I still love RPG's with random encounters, though, like Pokemon, Golden Sun, and Skies of Arcadia.

Quote

I think you're just not an RPG fan (Mario RPG, while fun, would not be most people's favorite ever), but some sort of half-breed fan of these weird new hybrid genre's that have come out in the wake.


Simple dislike of random ecounters doesn't make Ian any less of an RPG than you. I hate it when people say you're not a "true" RPG fan unless you like straight turn based titles with completely random encounters. Grandia 2 is, in my opinion, the finest RPG ever made, and not only does it show the enemies on screen but uses a battle system that seamlessly combines elements of real time and turn based combat. I'd rather developers keep trying new things with RPG's than sticking to one style.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 22, 2004, 11:40:15 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: WesDawg
They're also a huge part of what makes 'em challenging. You can't just run ahead all the time, or your party might not be strong enough. So you spend time training 'em and looking for better weapons and such so that you don't end up almost dead hoping you can reach the next save point. Taking 'em out kinda changes the whole genre in a way. In a way that makes it easier for pansies to play. HA HA HA! Yeah that's right. You're a big pansy whoever it was that doesn't like 'em.

Meh, it's more challenging to take on your enemy with a weaker party...That should be easy to see...

And Pokemon and GS need to random, considering the limitations of the GBA (And even in Pokemon, you can sometimes choose when you want to fight or not by just staying out of caves/tall grass)  I'm really hoping the next Golden Sun(console version) won't be "random-battled," but I know the story will make up for it if it's not...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Ian Sane on March 22, 2004, 11:41:16 AM
"You can't just run ahead all the time, or your party might not be strong enough. So you spend time training 'em and looking for better weapons and such so that you don't end up almost dead hoping you can reach the next save point. Taking 'em out kinda changes the whole genre in a way."

Well it should be my CHOICE if my party isn't strong enough.  The game shouldn't FORCE me to level up and battle.  I should be able to do what I please.  And how does removing them change the genre?  SEEING the enemies ahead of time isn't going to completely change RPGs forever.

I've noticed the random battle arguement tends to fall into two camps.  RPG fans support them because they enjoy a very specific genre and thus like everything the way it is.  General videogame fans (like myself) hate random battles because to us they're out-of-date and annoying and we're used to having more choices and control in other videogames.  I've always been turned off by dumb limitations in videogames.  This includes enemies that kill you because you touched their nose with your toe, invisible walls, forced camera angles, and random battles.  Thus to me an RPG cannot reach perfection if it uses random battles.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Draygaia on March 22, 2004, 01:42:57 PM
I to also don't like random battles and I do believe they can avoid that.  Although if I do see the enemy I don't want to be able to go into another area and then go back and see it do the exact same movements.  But to me I really like the FF series and random battles aren't going to just make me not play the game because I really like the story.  What they could do is use something similar to the Aurora or Infinity Engine of D&D RPGs and if you do come across a boss the battle area can change and you can play it like FF but I still want to directly control the characters like the Tales of Phantasia/Symphonia.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: NinGurl69 *huggles on March 22, 2004, 04:14:09 PM
I wish Tales of Symphonia came out already so I wouldn't have to "randomly encounter" these threads.  
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: jmoe316 on March 23, 2004, 03:59:57 AM
well it looks like its confirmed:

Final Fantasy: Guilty Wing on Cube-Europe

Although I guess it could still be false, since like what was said above, this is the magazine who dropped the Never Happening bomb. Let's just hope it's true though! Hopefully some PGC staff can confirm/deny this for us??
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: KDR_11k on March 23, 2004, 04:34:58 AM
Your story doesn't prove anything, look at the last line (the one saying "Source: Spong")
C-E claimed there was no article, now they claim there was one... What in the name of all seven-and-a-half hells???

Random Encounters suck. Plain as that. They limit your ability to move (since you want to move as little as possible when every step counts), they're f###ing annoying (in SoA:L it took longer to load the battle than to mow 'em down!) and they're rarely challenging. Also, the dungeons look pretty empty without all the monsters displayed.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Chongman on March 23, 2004, 04:35:10 AM

we don't sound like those guys on this forum, now do we? *shudders* Makes me appreciate the general intelligence of PGC forums...

anywhos, that's kickin information. Whether it's true or not remains to be seen. I think the whole net should be taking this with a grain of salt until it is officially announced by Square-Enix, less we have nintendo fanatics run down the streets proclaiming the second coming (FF that is).
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Draygaia on March 23, 2004, 08:05:06 AM
If there was one game I liked with random encounter battles it would have to Pokemon.  I mean it wasn't that bad IMO.  The areas you have to go through with pokemon weren't that life threatening and after a while they became place you would go to for a hunting kind of thing instead of them hunting you.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 09:21:31 AM
personally I like the random encounters but only to an extent.  I do feel you on some of the things youve said like hinderin the exploration process or gettin in the way while you tryin to run to a save point.  I think the only place for random fights are in the overworld and once you go into a location then you have the enemies visible.  Thats the perfect mix IMO.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: nitsu niflheim on March 23, 2004, 09:39:14 AM
I like random battles, but I like it better when you are given a choice to stop them, like in several Final Fantasy games, 8 and 10 especially.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Procession on March 23, 2004, 12:49:44 PM
Goddamn, this whole thread has degenerated into a lame fight about random battles.

NEW FINAL FANTASY.

Who cares if it has Squall as the main character? God, honestly. NEW FINAL FANTASY.

I can't believe anyone would whine about that, no matter the circumstances.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 01:20:04 PM
true, back to the topic at hand.  I read that story in gamecube europe and they speak of the initial picture, the then sources which claimed it all to be false and then they speak of the actual issue of vjump that has addition pictures ( not in game shots) regarding the story.  I dont know exactly how true this can be but if they seen it right from the issue itself then odds are that its true.  They say the game takes play in the ff7 universe so I dont see how squall of ff8 will fit in.  Rumors before this have said that the rumored ff game in developement for gc was either 7,8, and 9 all in one or more recently that the game was goin to take influences from those 3 games.  So far its all coming together I guess.  FF7 univers, FF8 character and we still have yet to see what else is planned for this.  Hopefully the story is true and this is actually a true RPG and not the experiment that FF:CC was (even though it was a good game but it upon playing it, they couldve done so much more and you can see all the potential)
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Ian Sane on March 23, 2004, 01:32:35 PM
"I can't believe anyone would whine about that, no matter the circumstances."

What if it's Final Fantasy Mystic Quest 2?
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Draygaia on March 23, 2004, 01:50:56 PM
Guilty Wing......... 7,8,9......  I trust G-Spot for them not saying bogus.  The only thing I want them to bring back from FFVII was that complex story only.  Nothing else.  FFIX owned them in that section.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 01:57:54 PM
where did you read that about gspot sayin not bogus?  The one I read said ff12 beind delayed as not bogus but the ff game for gc rumor as bein bogus.  I hope this all turns out to be true, cuase a new more traditional ff is always welcome.  Also, I want to see how they'll combine the 3 games themes and what is the meaning to the title.  I think the title guilty wing sounds like an action game but I hope I'm wrong.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2004, 02:01:58 PM
A traditional FF-style RPG has actually been in the works at GDS for a while now, though I really doubt it will be aligned with the stories of 7, 8, and 9...Maybe it's because I'm praying for something fresh and original...
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 02:21:00 PM
from the rumors Ive read, I dont think it'll be allied but it supposed to take inspiration and sample some themes from those 3.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Termin8Anakin on March 23, 2004, 02:51:59 PM
I love the love stories (i'm a hopeless romantic of the typical asian kind ) of the main FF series like FFVIII and FFX, and if they give GC something like that, then I may be tempted to buy my first FF game - and my first RPG.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: jmoe316 on March 23, 2004, 03:42:09 PM
hmmm, well according to IGN, *puts up shield* they say this is false, and say there is no such thing in V-Jump. Guess will have to...*puts up second shiled*...wait for E3 04!

IGN Mailbag
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ruby_onix on March 23, 2004, 03:55:40 PM
Of course, IGN also says that Square has "something else" in the works for the GameCube, which is what GameSpot's rumor control claims to be "bogus".

I'm not going to take anyone's word on this stuff. Nobody seems to know what the heck is going on.
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 04:00:35 PM
dam, someone needs to get some scans up of these supposed pages in the vjump
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Uncle Rich AiAi on March 23, 2004, 04:33:47 PM
The only thing I'm certain is going on, is someone is playing the spin doctor very well!
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: ThePerm on March 23, 2004, 05:18:03 PM
meh i think theres a ff in development...but this looks like a hoax
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Berny on March 23, 2004, 05:24:12 PM
Hoax? Or NOT hoax?
I hope it doesn't (ab)use the GBA linky thingy as much as CC did.
Title: RE: Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Mannypon on March 23, 2004, 05:29:56 PM
sh*t sucks, wish it was e3 already lol
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Chongman on March 23, 2004, 05:47:21 PM

Madness! IT'S ALL MADNESS!!!!!!!

*runs down the street on fire*
Title: RE:Final Fantasy:Guilty Wing???
Post by: Metroid masked on March 24, 2004, 01:44:07 AM
thats looks so fake!!!!