Community Forums => General Chat => Topic started by: Grey Ninja on September 18, 2003, 11:01:49 PM
Title: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 18, 2003, 11:01:49 PM
First of all, I want to say that I have drank one hell of a lot tonight, and I apologize in advance for all spelling and grammatical errors. I am not really up to such a task right now. But I also want to say that regardless of your country of origin, I REALLY want to say that it's ok if you don't like Canada for whatever reason. You are also free to boast about your own country without fear of any sort of retalliation from me, and it's my wish that the other Canadians here follow the same rules.
But I just watched "The Arrow". It's a dramatized story about Canada's "Arrow" project back in the '50's, and it's one very well done movie. It especially hit home with me. I used to have a dream to become an Aerospace Engineer. I dropped out after my first year of school though, and switched my major to Computer Science. I wasn't in a school that offered the whole Engineering program, and only had a transfer program where you switched schools after the first year, and I accumulated 4 'D' grades in my first year. It was a shock to me, since I had never gotten a grade below a 'B' before, but 4 non-transferable courses meant that I would have to retake the entire year of school. I wasn't prepared to do that, so I just switched majors. But that aside, this movie really touched home with me. If I had picked a better University, I might be well on my way to becoming a Computer or Aerospace Engineer (I never really decided).
In short, I feel an honest love for my country for the first time. It was Canadian troops who turned the tide of World War I. There were Canadians landing on the beaches of Normandy. There were Canadians training British Pilots in World War II. There were Canadians developing modern fighter aircraft TWO DECADES BEFORE the United States. And most importantly of all, two Canadian game developers are showing world class game design. EA Big has long been standing the only part of EA that I actually like, after developing SSX Tricky. Silicon Knights, I am sure you all know is currently my favorite game developer, and the place I would VERY much like to work one day. (In fact... I have made it my life's goal).
Canada isn't a bad place. Our people seem to be extremely tolerant of other viewpoints for the most part. A Black man can feel at home pretty much anywhere in our country, which doesn't seem to be the case with the US. Canadians also seem to be respected world wide. I have not heard of anyone really (other than Canadians) who have a serious problem with us.
You know why Canada isn't a superpower? The reason is because Canadians have notoriously bad judgement. We tend to elect idiots, and most Canadians seem to choose the WORST console. "The Arrow" seems to have destroyed a bit of the apathy in me. I have long accepted that the Canadian politicians are corrupt as hell, and there's not much that can be done about it. You know what? It's going to be true tomorrow too. There's not much I can do about it.
I took a trip through the US a couple of years back. I was surprised about how many American flags I saw... how many symbols of patriotism I saw... how much stuff I saw that showed that somebody actually cared about what the flag actually symbolized. To me, the flag always showed to me how much Eastern Canada cared about Western Canada (there are no Maple Trees in Alberta, BC, Saskatchewan, North West Territories, or the Yukon... or... other places I am sure! (and nobody speaks french in western Canada either).) But the flag has taken on a whole new meaning for me now.
Anyways, I am way drunk and on the verge of throwing up, so I am going to bed. Night night.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: PIAC on September 19, 2003, 02:03:24 AM
well australians invented the lawnmower, and err invented the aussie thread, i think it safe to say we have done our part for the world *folds arms*
and i told you to wait a bit, then swallow the rest of the drink!
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Shift Key on September 19, 2003, 03:01:36 AM
Aussies are definitely a strange mob. We have a heap of pride in our sporting teams and athletes, and we couldn't give a stuff about the rest of it. We also like to bag the hell out of everyone else, especially Kiwis and Pommies.
And we make the best beer EVER!
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Bill Aurion on September 19, 2003, 04:12:49 AM
In the U.S. critics say that there was no patriotism before September 11th, but that's absolutely not the case. It's just that it was more noticable afterwards...Though I can't stand the way bureaucrats run our government, I will always stand up for my country. And it's nice to see that you guys do too
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 19, 2003, 05:27:36 AM
Quote and i told you to wait a bit, then swallow the rest of the drink!
I did wait. The drink is still sitting here half empty though. It looks kind of gross right now actually. It went kinda bad over the night.
Quote And we make the best beer EVER!
Nah, that's Canadians.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KnowsNothing on September 19, 2003, 09:27:45 AM
Well, there has been the on-going theme of "Canadians are dumb" in my school. But that was last year, and it pretty much stopped after tha trip to Montreal. What does that mean?
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KDR_11k on September 19, 2003, 10:19:00 AM
We have no patriots here. At least not many. Maybe that's because noone wants to be called a neo-nazi?
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Caliban on September 19, 2003, 03:38:09 PM
I did once watched a documentary on the Avro Arrow when I was living in Portugal. I was even more proud of having dual citizenship(Luso-Canadian). I was quite furious(and still am) with the americans because they suppressed the Canadian government to stop the project. I was sad when in the documentary they said that the person that started and headed the project died in New York(not quite if it's the right city) as a drunk homeless. BTW I too want to follow Aerospace Engineering(for propulsion development) but I'm still undecided because my other option is Materials Chemistry Science(or materials engineering depending on the university).
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 19, 2003, 03:50:42 PM
It enfuriated me because Canada gained so much after World War I. We were on almost equal ground with the US, and with the Arrow, we could have become the second superpower in North America. I was very angry that one dumb f*ck of a politician just decided to stand down and let Canada lose it's new found freedom from Great Britian. We are no longer a British colony, but it seems we have become an American colony in the process. And it was needless.
That's actually one of the reasons I don't mind Cretien. (or however the hell you spell the damn frog's name. ). He's been in office so long that he really just doesn't give a crap anymore, and he is constantly standing against the US.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 19, 2003, 05:30:50 PM
yea i thikn its good that other countries stand up to the us. i didnt understnad why everyone "hated" the US before, but i understand more now. i am an american so no flaming....proud of my country and all that. however if i was in a different country i wouldnt want it kissing americas ass all the time.....the one country that has their ish together is Switzerland. if every country was like them at least when it comes to economics and foreign affairs, everyone would be better off.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Caliban on September 19, 2003, 06:11:47 PM
nolimit19 Switzerland isn't so evolved as some people think. It's just another place in this planet that scum like Nazis are kept protected. Because of them being neutral is one reason to never trust there past, present and future policy.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on September 19, 2003, 08:37:45 PM
I have a dislike for nationalism, as I type I know racism in my country is already surging upwards, being fueled by nationalism.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: The Omen on September 19, 2003, 09:26:16 PM
Quote nolimit19 Switzerland isn't so evolved as some people think. It's just another place in this planet that scum like Nazis are kept protected. Because of them being neutral is one reason to never trust there past, present and future policy.
Very true.. The nazis live like fat cats over there, ever since WWII.
Grey Ninja: Always love your country and stand up for it, but don't be afraid to question. If you except the status quo, you'll be rendered a robot.
noilimit19: People hate America because its a superpower. If we were just another country, nobody would give a sh!t about us. But every country government wants the exact power they ridicule....i dont agree with everything, (some would say anything_), the government does, but i was born here, i live a reasonably good life(besides my mental problems) and i was able to pursue my dream ...what is not to like.? Do we flex our muscle, ? Sure. But so does every country (in varying degrees)
Bottoms up!!!
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 19, 2003, 09:37:57 PM
Quote Originally posted by: Ocarina Blue I have a dislike for nationalism, as I type I know racism in my country is already surging upwards, being fueled by nationalism.
Just so you know, I am not caucasian.
Anyways, back to the more important matters in life. DRINKING!!!!!
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: PIAC on September 19, 2003, 11:48:31 PM
*lifts pirate mug of gin in salute*
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on September 20, 2003, 05:26:55 AM
To be a super power, don't you generally have to have a massive economy, enormous political clout, and an extremely large and powerful militairy?
To be honest, Canada never was one of those.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: The Omen on September 20, 2003, 05:47:40 AM
I think Ninja was saying they had the potential to be a superpower 50 or so years ago.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KnowsNothing on September 20, 2003, 05:54:39 AM
But they didn't, and now there a place where everyone says "eh?" and puts maple syrup on everything, loves hockey (Blegh!) and eats Canadian bacon, which is really ham. What a weird country!
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on September 20, 2003, 06:27:46 AM
I don't wave a flag around, but yes, I am patriotic. And racism is not fueled by patriotism. . . they are just two things common in the same people, for some reason or another. And they are idiots, and despite what you may think, those are not the people that make the difference. Nor am I, simply because I choose not to, but it's not them either
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: The Omen on September 20, 2003, 06:40:22 AM
Quote But they didn't, and now there a place where everyone says "eh?" and puts maple syrup on everything, loves hockey (Blegh!) and eats Canadian bacon, which is really ham. What a weird country!
It sounds like you're describing a wednesday night for me in December, and i'm from New Jersey! Alright, i only say eh when being sarcastic, but everything else is a-o-k with me.
Hostile creation, more intelligent words have never been spoken....common sense is back!!!
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 20, 2003, 10:25:50 AM
Heh... this reminds me of my Anthropology class. My teacher was a hillbilly from the US, and she was always studying us and asking us questions about our culture. I remember one day she asked us what it meant to be Canadian. There were several answers.
BEER! (This is the foremost symbol of being Canadian. Canadian Beer) eh? (When taking Japanese class, I found it very amusing that the Japanese have a direct equivalent to "eh", and they use it just as much) Hockey (Undeniable. Most Canadians love hockey. I do not however) The Beaver (The professor stopped at this one. She said that every class she had asked had mentioned the Beaver. She said: "I had no idea the beaver was such a potent national symbol". It actually is too. I think it's just weird and funny enough that most Canadians will remember it.
Quote To be a super power, don't you generally have to have a massive economy, enormous political clout, and an extremely large and powerful militairy?
Canadians played a really big part in winning World War I. They were also invaluable allies in World War II. They had lots of political clout in the '50s.
When Canada developed the Arrow, they had created a fighter plane that was decades ahead of its time. Canada would have been able to sell it EASILY on the foreign market.
Canada had a great thing when they created the Arrow. But because of a corrupt politician, they took blowtorches to the 37 Arrows that were created, and destroyed all things related to them. That moment is when Canada became a puppet country of the US, and lost any chance of being a superpower. The reason for that is that Canada allowed the US to provide military defense of all of North America, and Canada scrapped its own weapons programs abandoning their own defense.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on September 20, 2003, 04:12:35 PM
Quote Originally posted by: Hostile Creation And racism is not fueled by patriotism. . . they are just two things common in the same people, for some reason or another. And they are idiots, and despite what you may think, those are not the people that make the difference. Nor am I, simply because I choose not to, but it's not them either
Well said, but I believe that in my specific case, nationalism is to blame for the upsurge of racism. In most places that have been affected by racism, people are discriminated because of the colour of their skin, or the way they speak. In my case however, racism is fueled because of an influx in immigration. Around 70% of our immigrants are still from Europe and North America, dominantly Anglo-Saxon countries, and people never had a problem with that. But in the past 2 years in particular, immigration from Asia has soared. Immigration as a whole has not risen by a huge amount, but the media has gone wild, with stories about terrible driving habits and people who cannot speak English sucking the culture from my country are not uncommon. Naturally, anyone who has heritage from Asia is stereotyped into this category. The racism itself is born from biggitism and stupidity, but the reason people are driven to biggitism and stupidity is fear of change from what my country is in the first place. If people had no pride in my country, then I believe racism here would not be as widespread as it is. Fortunately, racism is still not at an irreversible level, and I'm optimistic it will be quashed before it gets more serious. I apologize for not explaining my train of thought earlier, and I certainly wasn't trying to accuse anyone of being racist if they are patriotic.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Termin8Anakin on September 20, 2003, 06:58:08 PM
I think Shifty summed up the national Aussie ideal right there. And in a past issue of FHM, they had '15 reasons why we [Australia] are the best country'. Funny sh*t, considering that it's actually pretty true. Here is just the list, while my fave ones have the details:
1. Gambling
2. Cheap Booze
3. Laziness
4. Drunkeness equals respect
5. Idiocy is rewarded Being the egalitarian bunch we are, we don't demand intelligence for success. You can buy a farm, tear down all the tress, ruin your soil with salt and erosion, build a damn upstream an watch as everything upstream dies - the government will give you money, and the general population will hold telethons and benefit concerts to compensate for your idiocy, short-sightedness, and general incompetence! Now that's mateship!
6. Deadly animals
7. We root for the underdog
8. Nothing's Scacred
9. We blame the English You can blame everything on the English; in fact, we hate the English so much, we voted to keep them as our head of state, just so we can keep heaping sh*t on them instead of taking responsibility for ourselves. And they wonder why were known as 'the clever country'.
10. The dole No need to go further into details about this Us aussie know why. Haha.
11. The climate
12. Indifference Aussie are ofthe praised for their laid back nature - a nice way of saying we don't really give a sh*t about anything, even if it's important. We may have national pride, but the truth is that no-one even cares about something as simple as the national anthem - even sportsmen and politicians don't seem to know the words. No one worries about civil unrest here - no-one could ever be bothered to turn up.
13. All-year-round sport
14. Crap local music
15. Porn access ...it's not too difficult to get your hands on some quality wirst fuel - newsagents stock a fine selection of educational mags and most till jockeys will give you the benefit of the doubt, even if you're in school uniform and short pants. And if you're lucky enough to live in Canberra, you can watch hardcore x-rated porn while letting off fireworkds and growing weed! Genius!
Hahahaha.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Bill Aurion on September 20, 2003, 07:07:22 PM
"6. Deadly animals"
Those koalas are some mighty fierce creatures. They act all tame and innocent with their cute little eyes and big noses, but when you are sleeping they sneak through your window...ever so quietly...and
....
and....
AND THEY GO FOR THE JUGULAR!
....
^_^'
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Termin8Anakin on September 20, 2003, 07:14:48 PM
here's what FHM said about Deadly animals:
"Australia has an amazing array of native wildlife - much of which can kill you. We have the world's deadliest snakes, long with crocs, spiders, sharks and even evil jellyfish. Luckily, most Aussies are too lazy to go anywhere near them, so it's only tourists who cop the brunt of their killing power."
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Matrix on September 20, 2003, 08:09:09 PM
It is unlikely the Arrow was not surpressed by the US government. Price and practicality are probably the more likely killers of the Arrow. Producing it would have just been way to costly for Canda, and any other country.
Also, it's doubtful that the Arrow would have made Canada a super-power. Missiles were the way of the future, which is one of the main reason the Arrow ran out of steam.
Yeah, it's a nice dream to think Canada could become a Super Power with the Arrow, and everything is all America's fault-blah-blah, but it's just that. A dream.
Edit: Very interesting link. Read 3 and 4. It's not based around conspiracy theories, which is what most Arrow stuff in the media is. http://www.vectorsite.net/avarrow.html
Of course, you're free to believe what you like. I'm not one for arguing political stuff, since it'll only get me upset. I probably shouldn't even have posted.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 20, 2003, 08:53:05 PM
Quote Also, it's doubtful that the Arrow would have made Canada a super-power. Missiles were the way of the future, which is one of the main reason the Arrow ran out of steam.
The simple thought that SAM launchers could ever replace manned fighters just strikes me as ridiculous. There will always be a need for capable fighters. That was proven decades later when aircraft such as the F-15, F-16, and F-18 came into service... with many of the same characteristics as the Arrow I might add. Similar flight ceilings, and performance characteristics for example.
Quote Price and practicality are probably the more likely killers of the Arrow. Producing it would have just been way to costly for Canda, and any other country.
The costs which the Diefenbaker government quoted were based on the costs of the prototypes. The production model would have been MUCH cheaper. The estimated cost of the Arrow would have been about $20 Million, which I think is pretty reasonable. Our currency has devalued greatly since that time, but I still think that's a pretty fair price. More than you might expect for an aircraft of the time, but it truly wasn't an aircraft of its time.
Quote (From the link you provided) On 20 February 1959, Prime Minister Diefenbaker cancelled the CF-105, with the order taking effect immediately. The prototype Arrows had completed 66 flights, for a total of 70 hours of flying time. The first Mark 2 prototype was almost ready for flight tests, with four more Mark 2s virtually complete. All the Arrows built or in production were scrapped, and design documentation and production tooling was generally disposed of, apparently as a security measure. None of the Iroquois-powered Mark 2s ever flew.
That doesn't sound a little dumb to you? It's from things like this that the conspiracy theories come from. The Canadian government really wasn't justified in doing this, and it's pretty much undeniable that it cost Canada a great deal. It laid off almost 20,000 people, and Canada had contracts to deliver Iroquois Engines to France for use in their Mirage fighters that was cancelled as well, as a result of the loss of the Arrow. The profits of the sale of the engines would have cut a great deal of price off of the Arrow.
And no, I don't blame the US. I blame the stupidity of the Canadian government.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Shift Key on September 20, 2003, 11:56:53 PM
Grey Ninja: Three words - Coopers Pale Ale. It's an Aussie beer that you can find in some pubs in the USA. Give it a go if you come across it. As for Canadian beers, i haven't come across any here, yet. We've got "Canadian Club" bourbon (i think) and that's not bad.
Termin8: IT'S TRUE. IT'S SO TRUE! The comments may look crazy, but their not far off the mark. The Dole - nuff said.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Termin8Anakin on September 21, 2003, 01:21:41 AM
I love being so laid back don't you? hehehe.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 22, 2003, 07:43:58 PM
yea i realize that Switzerland isnt perfect, but i still think it has the best foreign policy...i understand why america does do some things it does, but i think over all, if america just got out of everyones back yard and stopped taxing the crap out of everything, we would be better off. i am taking a plolitical science course this semester and a really interesting topic came up. we always think of midevil times when the kings taxed the crap out of the people right?? well according to my professor, americans get taxed much more, percentage wise, then they did. about 40 percent of our total income goes to income tax, social security, sales tax, property tax, death tax, ect. the point is our government gets way more involved in our lives then they should. thats 2/5ths of our money that we never see and that is being given to some drug addict that doesnt have a job. basically 2 days of the week we work for the government...if you look at it like that you cant be happy with the current policy our government takes on taxes...and its not bush or clinton or any one guy you can blame...its the system....to me america is far to left...giving money to all these people who havent earned it. medicare, medicaid and social security all need to go in my opinion...but anyways im off topic, i am proud to be an american and i wouldnt live anywhere else.....unless i absolutely had to. obviously its not perfect, but it is a good place to live, but it would have been better if the liberals didnt take over. and yea i know why everyone hates the us, and that was my point...i understand why...it goes deeper then just being a super power, its the flexing of the power, not just militarily, but politically and economically as well.
and sorry i realize everyone here isnt from america, but when i say "our country" i mean the us...just to clear that up.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 22, 2003, 08:05:46 PM
The difference between now and medieval times nolimit is that nowdays people actually make money. More than enough to live comfortably. If you can't live comfortably, you get your taxes back, and don't pay the government anything. It's really that simple. In medieval times, people barely made enough to feed and cloth themselves, and they had to pay a ridiculous amount to their rulers.
Just some food for thought.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on September 22, 2003, 08:56:30 PM
I see the only real difference as more efficent production procedures. Most people still go through life working most of the time, and can retire nicely if they're lucky. While some of your money may be given to people who don;t try to get work, there are many people who try but can't find work aswell who do not get tax.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Grey Ninja on September 22, 2003, 08:58:46 PM
Yes, but the number of people starving to death has drastically reduced.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on September 22, 2003, 09:03:52 PM
Sorry, that's what I meant to say through the more efficent production procedures. That was worded pretty poorly.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: RABicle on September 23, 2003, 01:20:02 AM
Quote Originally posted by: nolimit19 ...and its not bush or clinton or any one guy you can blame...its the system....to me america is far to left...giving money to all these people who havent earned it. medicare, medicaid and social security all need to go in my opinion...
Left? IMO, if America was any further to the right it would be bordering on Facism. I think my avatar sums up my political position.
Actually on a semi related note, Lenin looked at Australia, which was the most socialist country in the world at the time, when seting up communist Russia. Australia is now only slightly left, but I say we need more leftness!
Um, yeah where was I? Oh yeah i dont like patriotism much, I really dont like Australia too much. Proabbly the proudest I've ever felt being Australian was when 4 men fell over to give Steve Brabury the gold of the Mens 1000m ice skating last year. Oh it was magical.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Shift Key on September 23, 2003, 04:21:59 AM
Steven Bradbury - that guy is now the classical Aussie athlete! And I'd say my proudest moment to be an Aussie is the AFL Grand Final - best sporting day on the calendar. Followed closely by Bathurst.
And Australia is among the highest taxed countries in the world. Up yours little Johnnie! Luckily I don't work enough hours to get majorly taxed. I guess that's another reason why the dole is so popular. Meh.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: RABicle on September 24, 2003, 02:01:12 AM
Yeah average taxation is 50% here, which for the lousy mathmeticians is more than your easy going 40% in America. The dole is important though, one of the most important parts of any economy. Can you imagine what would happen is the dole and other unemployment benefits were taken away? crime would surge upwards as people would be forced into crime to live, the moral of the lower class would drop, because suddenly all the people on the dole wont have any money then a lot less people will be participating in the countries economy, so people would be spending less, making business and commerce drop, in an effort to maintain profits business would have to sack employees, putting more people out of work. Basically it would all end in a major depression.
And what are you crapping on about crappy local music? Australian music is great.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Shift Key on September 24, 2003, 03:00:32 AM
*points at self* ME? WHAT? I'm a huge fan of Aussie music.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: PIAC on September 24, 2003, 03:08:48 AM
frenzal rhomb, area 7, bodyjar etc etc are all great! take THAT rest of the world.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 24, 2003, 07:08:28 PM
yea dont give me that....we have thousands of illegal immigrants that seem to find jobs without any problem at all. the problem isnt a lack of jobs....its that there arent jobs that people want. and for that, i dont htink anyone should be getting hand outs. im all for everyone being able to get the basic things in life like...education, food, housing, health care....but i dont think the way to do that is by just giving them to people...for instance....a "universal health care system". what makes america what it is, is its competition. if we just start giving things away....no one will compete and we will just have a bunch of lazy commies not willing to work. we have all seen the horror stories of women on welfare having more babies on purpose so they can get more money. dont get me wrong i think that people should give back the comunity, i just dont think they should be forced to if they dont want to. and let me remind you. no one have ever starved to death in america because they couldnt afford food. if you need something that bad and cant pay for it, there are plenty of people that would help/doctors that would provide free health care. there are countless organizations in america that are here for humanitarian benifit, and i dont htink that it is necessary to have the government pay for all these things. the problem of course is that people dont wnat ot work for health care or for their own retirement...they want other people to do it for them, so certain politicians take up these things and pass them with the front that its for the best of man kind. it will catch up sooner or later. i am some what of a classic liberal...or a libertarian....the less government the better. not this big brother crap. absolute power corrupts absolutely.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on September 25, 2003, 01:16:08 PM
Uhh, are you retarded? Have you heard of the depression?
The only reason those programs were set up are for the same reasons as universal health care; competition is good but we don't want to kill people because it gets too intense...
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 26, 2003, 04:44:56 PM
i understand why those things were created, but they are not necesary now. the standard of living and the amount of money in the us economy is much better now(even in this recession). i understand that people did not have jobs and couldnt afford retirement....that is out dated now... social security is going to fail...we all know that. its a fact. the only reason it ever worked was because of the baby boom. there were all these young workers paying a little for social security. now the population numbers have leveled off and its only a matter of time before it colapses. it should be abolished. not right away mind you. the government should just assign a cut off date for certain age. maybe health care benifits for the old and poor are good ideas(medicare and mediaid) but a universal medical system is strait socialism. free hand outs go against everything america stands for. working hard and having it pay off. and yes people starved in the great depression, i wasnt thinking that far back, so my bad. however, in the current situation we are in, no one starves to death unless it is self-enduced. there are plenty of homeless and unemployed now, but no one is starving. america is very different from what it was during the depression. america produces enough food to feed the world like 3 times over. we live in a time where poor people are fat are rich people are healthy/muscular....there is no worry of people starving to death. and many argue that the only reason anyone is homeless, is because they are crazy/vietnam vets/drug addicts. i dont think we will have to worry about that though. we are seeing the rise of conservatives in recent years.
to change the topic though...who do you guys think will win the democratic nomination?
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Ms.Pikmin on September 26, 2003, 06:19:20 PM
nolimit, you are heartless and ignorant. I cannot believe you would say that there are no starving people in this country unless it is self inflicted. There are POOR families that cannot afford enough food to give their children a decent full meal. Maybe we don't have infomercials with dirty naked crying children but there ARE hungry people here. Yes, we have enough food to feed everybody, but that doesn't mean everybody gets it.
As far as healthcare, not everyone gets it or can afford it. Many employers get around giving their employees benefits by only hiring part time workers. If a low wage worker can get benefits, a problem is also that an employer does not have to cover that employees family. Medical insurance is expensive and many people cannot afford it on their own.
Why don't you get out of whatever suburb you live in and go see what is really happening out there? It's really easy to sit back and say that people should get it together and not allow poverty to happen to them, but not everyone can help themselves. I really hope that "conservatives" like you don't wind up running this country. Poor people would be in a lot of trouble, having someone like you saying their poverty doesn't even really exist.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: RABicle on September 27, 2003, 03:40:37 AM
And if you cut those unemployment benefits then people WOULD start starving to death.
I have a friend at school, her mum is on the dole (unemployment benefit) they live in a pretty dodgy little house in a small town. her mum works her arse off applying for at least 5 jobs every week. She was ounce the local member of state parliment for the areafor the labour (left wing) party. Conservatives voted her out.
Let's see if it wasn't for the unemployment benefit introduced by her political party decades ago then she would've been forced into a life of crime to feed and dress herself and my friend because of a decision made by one of the partys ministers that caused voters to vote her out. Does that sound fair?
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 28, 2003, 07:29:31 PM
i want to see someone in america that starved to death last year. i never said that people werent hungery or that poverty doesnt exist. i said people arent starving to death(meaning everyone has what it takes to survive in the us). i have gone out to feed the homeless several times. i personally love helping people that are less fortunate than i. the thing is, if it comes down to it, you can get the basic essentials in america in a legit way without help from anyone. funny how millions of illegal immigrants can get on their own two feet with a little elbow greese. they risk death, imprisonment, and deportation by coming here and putting it all on the line. most illegals dont resort to crime because they dont want to be sent back to where they came from. like i said its not a lack of jobs, its a lack of desire. i cant speak for any country but america, but if you have it bad enough that you cant take care of yourself, either you messed up, or you are in the very small minority that have no control over a long list of things that happened in their life. for instance....maybe a girl gets raped and has a baby, and her parents throw her out of the house cuz they thing she is a whore. that is sad and not selfinflicted. or maybe you are insane because you served in vietnam. again not your fault. maybe you were born with a diablity and your parents are too poor too support you. again, sad and something that should be addressed. however, maybe you are a fat pos that lives in a trailer and has babies all day and collects on social security and medicare. that my friend is strait robbery. thats why i said...health care for the poor and elderly...although IDEALY not the best thing, may be ok. but social security and just handing money over to poor people. absolutely rediculous. i live in phoenix, and there are tons of illegals here that make a decent honest living. i am a prime example of someone who needs a job, but isnt willing to go and mow lawns or do yard work, or whatever else it is that needs to be done. however if i was is dire need of supporting myself, i wouldnt go the the government to get money, i would quit school and get myself a job. and let me tell you, you never see illegals begging for money, they are begging for jobs, and they obviously usually get them because they keep coming. if you want a job and the ability to suport yourself that bad, in america, you can do it. you may not live like a king, and you may need to share a room with someone...you may have to use public transit or a bike...hell you may even have to wear the same clothes a few days in a row, but you can survive. again its not that i dont feel bad for people in worse shape then i, its just that i dont htink that BIG BROTHER should force you to pay for someone elses stuff. in america there are plenty of opertunities for everyone. and the reason i feel so strongly about this is because medicare, medicaid and social secuity are our 3 biggest things on the budget. we pay too many taxes. simple as that. you want to make money. do it the way everyone else does it WORK FOR IT!
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on September 29, 2003, 04:22:01 PM
If you starve to death in America, you are an idiot. We practically have food sitting on the street, waiting to be eaten. 99 cent hamburgers is enough to keep anyone alive, and they're easy to get. . . and you can steal stuff if you can't afford it. . .
And yeah, I'm cruel and heartless, but most people that are actively living, literally, on the street, are gutless cowards that got there by their own ignorance. They could work at a frickin McDonalds, or a factory or something, the ones that don't are just drunken fools.
No, our poverty is like paradise compared to most place. . . and I don't care much about those places either, so there is little point in me talking any more. Time to take your hits out on me. Have fun.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Bill Aurion on September 29, 2003, 05:14:02 PM
I see that this has become a real hardcore government debate...Though I can't stand the subject of government, I just have to step in. I consider myself a libertarian(that is, I am more conservative when it comes to economic issues, and more liberal when it comes to social issues). I believe welfare is important, but there has to be a cutoff point. By the next generation it's a known fact that the social security budget will run out...What's to do then? I'm sick of lazy asses not doing work and getting social security when there are those that actually need and deserve it. You hear about the story about the guy who got social security for a cut pinky finger? It's absolutely ridiculous what the percentage of those who get social security payments are actually disabled, or have not. Our system of government is scaring me more and more as the debt gets higher and higher, and sooner or later it's just gonna end, and lots of people are going to suffer. Someone has to set up a way of limiting SS and Welfare to those that actually need it if there is to be a decrease in "absolute poverty."
Just my two cents...
(Though I'll be of age to vote early next year, I WILL NOT vote...Bush has just gotten incompetent, and every single one of the Democratic candidates is a complete moron...Where are the good candidates!?)
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on September 29, 2003, 06:07:30 PM
this next presidential election will be my first one to vote in....and unfortunately i am not excited about any of the canidates either. i will probably vote for bush because i rather die then have another democrat in the white house. this Wesley Clark isnt looking too bad. i still have to see who stands for what. but yea...you are a moron or lost in the wilderness if you starve to death in america.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: RABicle on September 29, 2003, 11:18:20 PM
Voting is compulsary in Australia, thats proper democracy or do you guys have the 'freedom' to not vote or something?
I think thats pretty godman useless of Hostile Creations for not caring about other countries.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on September 30, 2003, 05:50:18 PM
Useless, eh? You come tell me that when you're doing something for those countries, okay RABicle?
And even when you do, if you do, I'll still live my middle to upper class, comfortable life, and just wish them the best of my luck. Because really, that's all I can give them that'll do any good. I wouldn't mind if everyone is happy, but no one seems to want to be happy. And that's their decision to make, not mine. . . and I can't help change that, and really, you shouldn't try either. But I'm not going to even try to change you, because that's not the way I work, and I would doubtlessly fail anyway. Anyway, I wish you, at least, the best of luck.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KnowsNothing on October 04, 2003, 06:01:53 AM
"(Though I'll be of age to vote early next year, I WILL NOT vote...Bush has just gotten incompetent, and every single one of the Democratic candidates is a complete moron...Where are the good candidates!?)"
Dave Barry for president. That is all. If you don't know who Dave Barry is, go here..
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 04, 2003, 06:48:58 AM
Either of you saying people don't starve to death, go out and look in the corners of the streets. In winter if you don't see someone who has froze to death or is starving to death you are blind.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 04, 2003, 01:01:11 PM
Not saying that they don't, just saying that the ones that do are complete idiots. And no, actually, there are not that many. Especially not speaking relative to certain other countries. Any other country, in fact. Besides, starving to death and freezing to death are two very, very different things.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on October 05, 2003, 12:47:56 AM
I have NEVER seen or heard of anyone strarving or freezing to death in my country, unless they are trapped in the bush. And I don't live in an upper-class section of my country of it either.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KnowsNothing on October 06, 2003, 10:27:03 AM
Nor have I. It would totally make me sick to see a dead person, especially one who has starved or frozen to death, just sitting there in a corner of some alley. I suspect it'd be pretty rare to see that, becuase people who would starve to death would probably go begging in a busy place, and if he died he'd be taken care of rather quickly. I doubt I'd find a person who has starved to death in a "bad neighborhood" becuase what would the chances be of getting food or money?
I would most expect to find a dead person in one of those "bad neighborhoods" that has been murdered or something to that extent.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 07, 2003, 11:30:26 PM
Yes, and the crime and starvation rates are two totally different things.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: CardBoardBox on October 08, 2003, 04:22:21 PM
Dead people are scary.....id probably barf or something if i saw one...or quickly throw something at it and hope it lands on the dead guys face -.- Yes it would be wicked nasty. WICKED WICKED WICKED WICKED WICKED WIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIIICKEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEED Yes crime and starvation are umm...totally different...hahah australia..hehehe.... *mumble grumbles*
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 08, 2003, 04:55:38 PM
If you haven't ever seen a dead person on the streets and live remotely near a big city, take my word for it, you are very sheltered.
Whether you see it or not it happens.
The fact that it happens less here doesn't make it any worse. 72 people starve to death every two minutes, is that not bad enough?
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on October 08, 2003, 07:15:34 PM
No, I am not. Not every country has as harsh a winter as the USA, and not every country has as many poor people living in the USA. But you're right, it doesn't matter whether I see it or not, it happens. My reply was meant only as small correction, nothing more.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: RABicle on October 09, 2003, 05:52:02 AM
It wouldn't be hard for someone to freeze to death in the USA. What is someguy got drunk at the pub and passed out while walking home? And it was snwoing? It'll tell ya what, DEAD! But the media would rather tell you about the murder victim than the fool so you wouldn't hear about it
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Bill Aurion on October 09, 2003, 07:17:22 AM
"If our knowledge of the world is controlled by the media then we live in a mediocrity." -Anonymous
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on October 09, 2003, 12:46:28 PM
ok i dunno if maybe some of you people joined the convo late, but we are talking about america. 72 people do not starve to death every 2 minutes in america. that adds up to over 18 million a year, and that is simply not true. actually i have no idea where you go that number from, because i was under the impression that way more people then that die from starvation each year world wide....maybe not, but there is no doubt that tons of people starve to death. the point was that under normal circumstances, no one starves to death in the us. the poor people are fat here, and the rich are fit. thats the way it works. i spend a lot of time in the inner parts of L.A. they probably have the most homeless people because of their good weather. i can tell you this....none of them are on the brink of starvation. cali is a very liberal place, and those "homeless" people makes tons of money begging. you may not believe it, but they make more then enough to survive. and the funny thing is....i dont see any homeless illegals....do you know why...because a great portion of the really poor or "homeless" are drug addicts, veterans, or mentally ill. i think that probably more people die of heat each year then of freezing to death. freezing to death and starvation are not problems in the us. the problem is crime and drugs if anything. we dont have a food shortage thats for sure. 2/3 of america is overweight. and trust me a lot of those 2/3 are uneducated trailor trash that dont understand health and live off welfare. and please...tell we where all the dead americans are that are starving to death....there are none. simple as that.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 10, 2003, 10:50:36 AM
Quote It wouldn't be hard for someone to freeze to death in the USA. What is someguy got drunk at the pub and passed out while walking home? And it was snwoing?
Yeah, a drunk. But no person that has an actual will to live is going to die of starvation, and, in most circumstances, freezing, in America. Sure, people freeze in Amercia, but I'd venture to say that those numbers are extremely low.
And I maintain that if anyone starves in America, that person is a moron.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 10, 2003, 12:46:49 PM
That is the world number, and take it back its 72 every minute.
Another 500 million will die in the next 15 years.
Humane aren't we, lets cut back taxes and give it back to the people who earned it, not the people who need it.
Oh give me a break, if you consider a few bucks a day as more than enough you really need to count how much you spend every day.
Just on food alone you spend more than they make in 3 or 4 days.
And the veterans comment, do I need to make my point even more clear. Lets see here, veterans, ah yes, the people who served actively in the militairy and we now decide we can screw over because we dont want to give them enough money to live off.
You want to find dead starving people, go down to the city hopsital and look in the morgue. I take it you haven't ever looked down a few of the not so nice streets and seen people lying there motionless. You keep on saying 'they dont exist, so maybe if I say it enough people will agree' because frankly I know for a fact it is true. Even if people have drug problems or what not, why do you think they got into it? Was it because they had this vast wealth lying around and they decided not to use it.
Look, just because there are success stories of people who fought through opression and staved off death and hatred, doesn't mean everyone or even many of us can do that. There is a reason why crime rates are higher in poor areas, and let me tell you, cutting off wellfare is not going to do jack to stop it. Without it, you have a bunch of poor people, and the only place around them that makes money is *gasp* gangs and drugs. Why do you think schools and sherriff departments spend so much on getting people off of drugs, yet only reach so far? Is it because the people they are trying to get out if it are just horrible people? I'm sure there are a few that are just rotten from the start, but habbit is learned. You can't just say, well maybe if one or two of them mess up, and it is bitched about by some politicians, but in reality is one of the things we spend the least on, it should go away.
You want to worry about something that costs a lot of money, worry about the military or research for it. Hell the black budget is larger than the military budget, worry about that.
I'm just saying though, you act like our country is the best thing in the world because that is what you see, but there are spots and there are people whom have never seen 1/1000th the privledges we have. If you are going to insinuate they don't exist or it's their fault, look at the people sometime, don't throw around hear say.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on October 10, 2003, 02:54:28 PM
that is simply not true. 1/1000th of the privledges have??? thats saying a lot...you know there are tons of people that reach out to inner city schools and tell them what htey need to do to succeed. they simply dont listen...do i feel bad for someone who doesnt listen...no i dont. do you realize that you can join the armed forces at 18 no matter what financial state you are in, get free room and board, and get paid?? its a great thing for people who want to serve their country or people who are less fortuneate. there are tons of ways to get out of you bad situation. and to me there is no excuse to
1. not have a place to live 2. not have a job 3. selling drugs to "get by"
like i said there seem to be jobs for millions of illegal immigrants, but no jobs for the poor people on welfare..awww too bad for them. also you cn find cheap housing for something like 500 a month if you were desperate....do the math.....get a roommate plus minimum wage....like i said....i dont feel sorry for (most) anyone. and lastly, selling drugs kills our society on so many levels, and anyone who resorts to that life style deserves to be locked away.
and like i said before, i really do think that people should help others in other countries, and our own as well. and the liberals like to talk about it like they are so holy, but when the thought of giving iraq 87 billion dollars comes up, they really change their tune. hmmmmm interesting. when it comes down to it, the us has nonprofit organizations for a reason....to not profit and help others. the governement is always less efficient then a well run organization. all i know is that if liberals were allowed to tax the crap out of the rich like they say they want to america wouldnt be what it is today. liberals lack economic logic. think about it quickly...who pays the low end guys....thats right, the rich! amazing, simply facinating. so that means that if taxes are raised for the rich, they wont have as much money to pay their employers... WHAT A CONCEPT! one that liberals refuse to understand to gain the poor vote! it sounds great trust me. i am just a poor college studet and my family is just normal middle class. i am not rich by american standards, and at first hearing the dems stance on taxes, i imediately agreed. however, if you know anything about anything you realize that is not hte answer....also raising the minimum wage....say you are a business owner and the minimum wage is raised...you have two options to maintain your current pofits.....raise prices, or cut down on employment....hmmmm and we blame bush for our bad economy.
whats the point of all this??? less taxes means a more efficient government, use of money, and economy. if people want to give to the poor it should be their choice, and i think that we as the richest country in the world should definitely take charge in that, and we already do. americans give away tons of money to charitable organizations each year. and like i said, government should be their for the extreme cases, but none of the 500 billion on free health care for the poor and elderly crap that we have today. if you smoked for 30 years, you were asking to die, that was your descion and not mine, why should i pay for it....the answer is...i shouldnt.
people dont starve to death in america, and thoes that go to sleep hungery are better off then they think...there is an obiesity epidemic in the country and they dont have to worry about that
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on October 10, 2003, 03:36:40 PM
Employers do not pay their employees from their own incomes; they pay it from their profits. Even if they did, the money from the rich people simply doesn't just disappear; it is redistributed to the poor, who in turn spend it, which helps accelerate your spending cycle.
The minimum wage may not raise the number of people who are employed, but it helps those that are employed. If the minimum wage is too low, then those who are employed at that wage will not be able to live at a level the government (and therefore the people who voted it to power) feel is acceptable. A low minimum wage may help production, and employment levels, but it does not have a positive impact on the actual standard of living, look at Bolivia for evidence of this.
Free health care once again doesn't aid your economy, but it aids the general standard of living in your country (when I say standard of living, I'm not referring to GDP, BTW). Health insurance is expensive, and not everyone can afford it. Your government is obligated to ensure that health care, protection against unemployment, reasonable employment standards and protection for those in circumstances beyond their control (such as old age and poverty) are accessible under article 25 of the United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
EDIT: Grammar
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on October 10, 2003, 04:21:12 PM
hey.....well said argument that i cant disagree with. just a difference in opinion. and i understnad that people dont pay their employees out of their own pocket, but a lot of businesses are controlled by rich people who will alter production out puts and what not in order to maintain profits. amd i do think the government should help people that have no control over their situation like i said before....handicap, people injured on the job, ect., but these people who dont even have jobs and just collect and collect need to not get any money. they shoudl be thrown in prison for fraud in my opinion.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: Ocarina Blue on October 10, 2003, 05:00:45 PM
I see what you’re saying, and I respect your argument, but not all that are unemployed are unemployed because they are lazy or because they have some sort of disability. Earlier this year, manufactures in the USA shed jobs because of low demand and full inventories. Is a person who is laid off because more than 250 000 000 other people have come to the end of their spending cycles in control of their employment situation? I do not live in the USA, but I was under the impression that people who are unemployed there only because there is a shortage of jobs must actively be searching for work if they wish to receive an unemployment benefit, is that not enough?
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: nolimit19 on October 10, 2003, 05:40:53 PM
i am under the same impression, but i know that there are plenty of jobs avalible, its just that they are jobs that no one wants. mowing lawns, construction, fast food restraunts and things of that sort that people dont want to "stoop" to. well it may suck to work at one of those places, but its better then collecting a check. i think that if people really want money, they should go out and earn it. and i believe that the only reason people dont is because they can survive off the governements money(taxes that everyone pays) until they find a "good job". and i think that is just one more tax burden that we dont need.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 10, 2003, 06:23:20 PM
There are so many jobs out there in fact, that we have one of the highest unemployment rates since the depression.
You don't think you are by atleast a thousand times off better than a lot of those kids? Do your parents care about you? If that is worth a lot to you, think about how much it is to someone whose parents who don't.
If you want to get into jobs, guess what is happening now and in the future. A major outsourcing of jobs from the US. Straight onto cheaper countries, so yes, there is going to be a even larger number of unemployed people in the US within the next few decades. Like it or not, it will happen, if you don't believe it yet, look at the tech sector. Next year the rate of jobs exported will grow 128% from this past year, by the end of the decade, it is expected to be around 5000%.
Obviously though, you have it that you know this subject from head to toe, so whatever you think must be right.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 10, 2003, 08:03:29 PM
I like how you insult people, manunited, and say stuff like this: "you have it that you know this subject from head to toe, so whatever you think must be right." Really helps support your argument, too.
I must confess that I do not go down to the morgue in my free time to check and see how many people starved to death. Sorry that I have not experienced dead people sitting there rotting on the road, but I doubt it would influence my opinion or make me any more or less knowledgeable about what's going on. Yes, extreme drug addicts and drunkards probably do starve to death on occassion, but they probably OD or wreck much more often. And who's fault is that? Their fault. And you don't have to take drugs to sell them. . . that's no excuse.
I'd probably say more, but I'm bored and this argument has gotten repetitive, not to mention that it may very well be locked soon. Unless something that I have to comment on comes up, this will probably be my last post in this thread.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 11, 2003, 07:42:41 AM
This was never an arguement, and if I get a tad pissed off because someone says 'well seeing death wont change my mind, I know because I don't''
Go down to the morgue, your arguement that seeing death won't change your mind is just kind of out there. I mean look at the holocaust. It's one thing to say ya 5 million people dying is bad, then to see just exactly what 5 million horrendous deaths look.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 11, 2003, 07:49:32 AM
Okay, I lied. But you say that a corpse is going to change my opinion? Not hardly.
I've seen dead people, you know, funerals and stuff. My grandfather, for instance, I touched his face after he had died of lung cancer, while he was in the coffin. He was someone that I knew, and liked. Why should some emaciated corpse in a morgue changed my opinion more than that, some drugged up fool that I never knew or cared about remotely? It won't. I'm not the type of person to change my opinion over a little spilled blood. . . or anything, for that matter.
Title: RE: Patriotism
Post by: KnowsNothing on October 11, 2003, 08:01:04 AM
You...you ...touched it?
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: manunited4eva22 on October 11, 2003, 08:42:52 AM
You make my point for me, you don't know because you haven't.
Title: RE:Patriotism
Post by: Hostile Creation on October 11, 2003, 06:46:30 PM
Barely, but yes. Forget why, exactly.
You obviously missed my point, manunited. I clearly stated that it would not change me. Do you doubt what I'm saying? I know what I'm talking about. All the corpses in the world wouldn't make me change my mind, and if you don't understand it, just let it go.
Okay, now I'm really gonna stop posting in this thread. Honestly