Nintendo World Report Forums

NWR Interactive => NWR Feedback => Topic started by: StevePitman on July 18, 2003, 11:00:49 AM

Title: too many ads!
Post by: StevePitman on July 18, 2003, 11:00:49 AM
refresh...refresh...refresh... refresh...refresh...refresh... refresh...refresh...refresh... refresh...refresh...refresh...

wow! the main page is coming up!...   Nintendo is releasing a...  OOPS! where did the page go??   (it switches to an ad page)...

click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  click on "continue to planet gamecube"....  

wow! the main page is coming up!...

I know you guys want to make some money but congratulations on being more annoying than IGN.

It wouldn't happen if you didn't have your cookies turned off. - Mod
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: enigma487 on July 18, 2003, 11:50:41 AM
would you like some cheese with your wine??

just get a copy of Norton Internet Security.  it blocks most pop-ups, and pop-overs.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Gamefreak on July 18, 2003, 10:27:49 PM
Hey um PGC, unless you take up like a terabyte of bandwidth a month or something we could host you on the gamers-syndicate network....
But then again I'll wait for our network to launch and see the servers in action for myself before messing with a great site like PGC....

I still don't get how you can't find a server with at least a little less ads though....oh well, I don't care, the ads never really bothered me, I've become quite a 1337 ad destroying with my awesome mouse aiming and phat-speed clicking the little X to close it ability.....
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 19, 2003, 06:00:46 AM
lol... I can't believe that there are still people in this world complaining about popups.  Either you really love IE, or you really like to whine.  One or the other.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: PIAC on July 19, 2003, 07:12:04 AM
or both

im still using Internal Exploder, it hasn't really given me any greif so i haven't been assed to get moezilla or something

and enigma, sorry to be a bitch, but its 'would you like some cheese to go with that whine' unless you were genuinly offering cheese, and if so mines a wedge of havarti please
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: nitsu niflheim on July 19, 2003, 01:41:18 PM
The only ad I get on the forums in the one that randomly shows up between links, and maybe one pop up on the main page of PGC.  They aren't the bane of the world.
Title: too many ads!
Post by: BigJim on July 20, 2003, 06:12:02 AM
The server isn't making the ads, their ad network is. Pop up blockers. Look into them.

Now we need a FLASH ad blocker. Those flash ads on PGC that completely take over the entire screen with very small and hard to find "close" buttons, if they have any at all, should rot in hell.

PGC said a long time ago that that they transfer gigabytes per day. They're probably bigger now. Can your server handle that?
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Gamefreak on July 20, 2003, 07:02:55 AM
Well the reason they have an ad network is because of server costs...we got lucky though when we scored our server, totally free and No ads!  
Title: too many ads!
Post by: Hostile Creation on July 20, 2003, 05:29:38 PM
I need to reinstall my program.  Got new stuff, so it got uninstalled.
Title: too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on July 20, 2003, 05:35:28 PM
Quote

Either you really love IE, or you really like to whine.


::shudders:: I can't image the prospect of ANYONE liking Intenet Explorer.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: PIAC on July 20, 2003, 07:26:43 PM
i have it, i use it, only cause so far it hasn't annoyed me to the point of changeing it. i only visit like 3 sites regularly, so i dont spend an eternity searching the web
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: nitsu niflheim on July 21, 2003, 03:43:34 AM
I like IE.  And MSN Explorer, though both are basically the same.  I've never had a problem with IE itself, just pages that takeover with popups that refuse to close and I have to do ctrl+alt+delete and shut it down, which closes all IE windows.  Other than that I am happy with IE.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: StevePitman on July 21, 2003, 05:33:20 AM
How can you not want to use Internet Explorer?    It's better than Netscape and it's the most compatible browser around.   When I get my cheese I'll share it with you guys.   enigma487 is sending me some.


Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 21, 2003, 05:55:26 AM
I don't want to use IE because it constantly has security holes, it's pathetically slow, eats up my resources like mad, lacks important features, such as tabbed browsing and a built in popup killer, and isn't any more compatable than Mozilla Firebird.

Being better than Netscape doesn't really take much.

And it really doesn't take a lot of work to upgrade your browser.  It's a 6MB download, followed by an unzip, and double clicking an icon.  Whoopie.  That's a lot of work.  If you want a more detailed explanation of why you should switch from IE, read this

I once used IE because I didn't really see much benefit in switching, as the only other browser I had used was Netscape, which was horribly buggy, and horribly slow.  I switched because I had heard that Firebird (Phoenix at the time), was faster, and much less hassle than IE.  I tried it out for a few days.  On the 2nd day, I disabled IE, and made Firebird my default browser.  When I lost my internet access from home, and had to use School computers to access the internet, I was forced to use IE again.  I actually used up 6MBs of my 10MBs of personal space to use Firebird from school because I had grown to hate IE so much.  It was slow, buggy, and didn't have a lot of features I had grown accustomed to using.

Firebird does EVERYTHING that IE does, but does it faster, and adds features to what IE does.

If you are coming here complaining about your browsing experience, and immediately saying that IE is better than anything else without trying the "else", then you are seriously ignorant.  The simple remedy is to try new things.

PS:  forgot to mention that unlike IE, Firebird is updated several times a week, and you are free to use nightly binaries as you wish, to add more features, or to fix the occasional bug.
Title: too many ads!
Post by: Ms.Pikmin on July 21, 2003, 06:42:45 AM
Grey Ninja, I went to the link you provided for Firebird.  The only problem I can see is that I have a Mac and the site says that the Mac version is still not quite pulled together.  Do you have any idea if my switching to Firebird would be beneficial in this situation?  Just thought I'd ask since you really do seem to know alot about this stuff.    
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 21, 2003, 06:55:17 AM
Well, try it out and see.    I have personally only used the Linux and Windows versions, but both were excellent, even in the earlier life of the browser.

Firebird is by far the best browser I have ever used though.  I am not sure what other browsers are available on a Mac, but I doubt it's worse.    The Firebird programmers have been bitching about their code for the longest time on all platforms, but we love them all the same.  

At any rate, my official response to your question is to try it and see for yourself.  If you don't like it, it's a trivial exercise to remove it.    I am using the latest Windows build (July 20th), and it's working just fine for me, so try out the latest binary and see if you like it at all.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 21, 2003, 09:13:27 AM
Well, just to illustrate one of the features of Firebird, I have created a website that shows two screenshots of this very thread.  On the top is IE 6.0 under Windows XP.  On the bottom is Mozilla Firebird.  Take a careful look at the bottom screenshot, and you will see something you don't see in the top one.  I took care to log in in both browsers as well.  
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Caliban on July 21, 2003, 10:04:55 AM
 Grey Ninja could you tell me what were supposed to see because I can't see any difference other than that the bottom image has a cleaner set of toolbars.
Title: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on July 21, 2003, 10:09:20 AM
The bottom one has a "Quick Reply" option thingie which looks very useful.  That must be why Grey Ninja has such quick replies! HA HA AHA AHAAHA  
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 21, 2003, 10:10:56 AM
Heh.  look at the bottom of the page.    And the similarity of the IE and Firebird browsers in interface is one thing that I did want to highlight.  Firebird is completely customizable, so you can make it look like IE, if that's your thing.  (It isn't my thing).  I also have a cleaner Firebird browser, as I never use IE anymore, so there's really no point in customizing it to my liking.

EDIT:  KnowsNothing beat me to it... even without the quick reply tool...
Title: too many ads!
Post by: vudu on July 22, 2003, 06:08:21 AM
Quote

The bottom one has a "Quick Reply" option thingie which looks very useful.

does the quick reply option not work with ie?  i use opera, and it works just fine.  i didn't know i was special.  
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 22, 2003, 06:11:46 AM
Nope.  I think it uses some features that IE doesn't have.  IE isn't fully HTML compliant, so that's probably it.  I doubt anyone coded it specifically to NOT work with IE.  
Title: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on July 22, 2003, 08:04:40 AM
Yeah, i have IE and there's no "Quick Reply" option.  But I have broadband so i don't have to ait a long time for the Reply Screen to show up and anyway.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: RickPowers on July 22, 2003, 09:26:39 AM
I'm using IE, and I've got the Quick Reply. Maybe you guys just don't know what you're looking for?

It's at the TOP of the page, and looks like a red "return" arrow.  Click that, and a window will pop up with a Quick Reply box.  You can then "dock" that window at the bottom of the thread, so it's always there (but only when you're logged in).
Title: too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on July 22, 2003, 10:13:22 AM
I guess with Opera (which I'm using right now- tons better than IE but still has occasional problems) and Mozilla the Quick Reply is automatically docked while on IE you have to manually dock it. Just another reason Opera and Mozilla are better.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Pale on July 22, 2003, 11:59:52 AM
I just started using Opera myself, and I have to say it seems to be better on many things.  Pure speed against my interent explorer is interesting.  I can do a pgc load on each browser and Opera does it in about half the time.  It could just be that my ie has some issues somewhere.  I'm not sure....but I was still thinking pgc was having major server issues until I installed Opera and realized its apparently me...
Title: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on July 22, 2003, 01:15:24 PM
Ok, cool.  KnowsNothing now has quick reply!
Title: too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on July 22, 2003, 02:34:19 PM
What I really love about Opera (besides the built-in pop-up blocker) is if for some reason you accidently close Opera, or it closes itself down, or there's som other problem, when you open it again it can take you right back to where you were browsing. Pretty handy, if you ask me.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Pale on July 22, 2003, 07:28:00 PM
I think you can do that in interent explorer too...but it is handy.  
Title: too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on July 23, 2003, 01:37:46 PM
i understand the need for advertisements, but it would be nice if pgc had standards for ads.. intrusive ads that obstruct content i think are counterproductive.. you may be getting paid more for them, but you're also pissing off your readers (i would like to take that nike ad and pull it's pants down in a busy public place for example).. so which is more important to pgc? a few extra cents per impression* or your readers?

* i have no idea how you're getting paid for that nike ad
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on July 23, 2003, 01:41:06 PM
The ads seem to occur less now.  I see no problem.

"which is more important to pgc? a few extra cents per impression* or your readers?"

I vote a few cents.  No ads means no money, which could lead to no PGC.  What good would readers do then?



Title: too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on July 23, 2003, 03:48:03 PM
Yeah, but no readers would lead directly to PGC going down- it's a tight situation either way.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Pale on July 23, 2003, 08:23:39 PM
I really think pgc should do more merch...cool pgc t-shirts, e3 chotskis (sp?), dvds, i dunno, they prolly already had this, but if noa doesn't realize how integral a part pgc is to their marketing than they got some issues.  I know you could never get funding and be a somewhat "official" nintendo site, but what about seeing if they could give you some crap to sell....like i dunno, i guess it wouldn't really work.....but maybe they could give you some stuff to just give away...but that doesn't help the money situation...i dunno...if i was the head of marketing for nintendo, i would give great fansitse some free server space or something....
Title: too many ads!
Post by: thecubedcanuck on July 24, 2003, 02:27:46 AM
Its the ad's with BLARING SOUND that drive me nuts. I check PGC out fairly late some nights and ad's such as the new Nike one can easily wake up people in another room.
I honestly am considering stopping buying from companies that use intrusive advertising of any kind, be it pop ups or telemarketing, bother me once and I will tell you to kiss my azz for eternity.  
Title: too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on July 24, 2003, 11:12:55 AM
I never have sound on anyway, except when I'm listening to music on the computer, which isn't that often.
Title: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on July 24, 2003, 12:29:19 PM
I have experienced one actual popup in all my time with PGC.  The rest are the once-a-day between-the-links ads,  or the most common flash ad, which which don't happen in the forums (where i spend most of my time).  I am extremely happy with PGC, and I think the staff has done all they can do to stop annoying ads, and it really shows.

Kudos to a job well done!  (and if you didn't do anything...then...well...good job anyway )

=me!

As for you, thecubbedcanuck, turn your sound down or better yet, off.  There's nothing to listen to here unless you're at the PGC radio.

Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Molobert on July 25, 2003, 09:25:54 PM
Grey Ninja - Thanks for the link to Mozilla Firebird. I've always been using IE, and never realized how bad it was, even compared to lesser-known browsers such as Mozilla.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 26, 2003, 06:06:08 AM
Heh.  Don't thank me Molobert.  Thank yourself for having the brains to try it out for yourself.    Anyways, I'm glad you enjoy it as much as I.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: PIAC on July 26, 2003, 06:10:49 AM
oh yeah, i also made the switch, and aside from not being able to get flash based things to work, its alot better than internal exploder. tabbed browsers are alot easier and even ctrl tabbing can cycle through them im set!
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 26, 2003, 06:46:32 AM
Just get the netscape flash6 plugin.  It's about a 600k download.  After that, just select your plugin directory and go to town.  
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Caliban on July 26, 2003, 09:31:53 AM
 I've downloaded the mozilla firebird and i like its customizability. But there seems to be a problem. I can't find where to turn on the offline mode, as I'm used to use it alot with IE.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Caliban on July 27, 2003, 10:01:39 AM
 Nevermind the last message. I've deleted the Mozilla Browser from my computer and it made the situation worse when all JPEG, GIF,... image files now are using the firebird icon and it looks terrible.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 27, 2003, 11:12:47 AM
Your image files will use the icon of the default program to view them with.  In your case, you obviously don't have a better default, so it uses the Firebird icon.  If it bothers you, then change the icon in the folder options menu.

As for offline browsing, I have no idea how you would do that, as I have never used the function.  You could try the Firebird forums though.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Caliban on July 27, 2003, 05:47:34 PM
 Thanks for your help Grey Ninja. I've got everything resolved about the pics.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on July 28, 2003, 03:50:49 PM
Glad I could help.  

I think I should mention though, that I just installed Firebird 6.1 RC1, and it seems they have changed the icon... It's a lot snazzier.  It's like a whole lot of fire.  
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Molobert on July 29, 2003, 07:48:31 AM
I have one problem with Mozilla Firebird. Whenever I try to download movies and such, it just brings up a page with a lot of symbols and letters, and I can't figure out how to fix it. Any help is appreciated.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Fammy2000 on August 01, 2003, 06:45:54 AM
Molobert: Firebird isn't finished yet. I think that is a known issue that the team is working on. Try downloading the newest version.

I browse exclusively with Firebird, it's awesome.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on August 01, 2003, 07:11:26 AM
I normally right click and save them anyways, so it doesn't really bother me.  It also only happens with some types of movies, such as the WMV ones.  MPEG and QT movies should play without a hitch.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 17, 2003, 11:41:25 AM
call me a whiney bitch, but the ad situation has gotten out of hand on PGC.. there are now 3-4 banner ads and 2 popup ads for each page... now if PGC was offering special content to justify this sort of thing then i wouldn't mind. as it stands, there is nothing that appears on planet gamecube that doesn't appear on other sites... other sites that DON'T have 5 billion popup ads... other sites that have triple the coverage (multiplatform sites)!!!

i seem to recall the billy managed PGC to have done just fine without the absurd amount of ads and the site had way better content. now, it just feels like someone is trying to cash in on the site while providing the bare minimum of mediocre content for the site.

this isn't a threat.. i'm already done with this site and won't be visiting again for a very long time, if ever again. just thought you'd like to know WHY. i will probably still lurk in the forums once in awhile though... cheers.

Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: RickPowers on August 17, 2003, 01:45:03 PM
That's the most LUDICROUS thing I've ever heard.

First, the way our ads are handled has not changed one iota since Billy left.  We've been sticking with the status quo, so any increase in ads is all in your imagination.  (Save for the extra pop-up on the media download page, which offsets the costs for that server).

Second, every single dollar generated by our ads go towards the site.  No one is "cashing in", and to suggest otherwise is simply ignorant.

That said, a simple pop-up blocker gets rid of most of those ads.  All the in-line ads are unobtriusive enough where we've received very few complaints about them.

If you're not going to come back because you refuse to get a pop-up blocker or a browser that will do it, you're not going to get a lot of sympathy from me.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on August 17, 2003, 01:59:29 PM
Look at it this way, snorgasmo- the typical commercial break on television lasts around 5 minutes and you see quite a few commercials. Does this in ANY way degrade the quality of the program you happen to be watching? Not at all! So why should a few banner ads on Planet Gamecube somehow make it any less of a site? In my opinion, it's pretty admirable when a gaming website as reliable as PGC has remained completely and utterly free when other gaming websites, such as IGN and Gamespot, are moving towards making you pay for their content. If you get distraught over a few banner ads and the occasional take-over ad (I don't like them myself, but a simple click of the Back button on your browser eliminates it), you must not like most of the internet.

As for the pop-ups, don't even BEGIN whining until you get a pop-up blocker. I do not believe people should complain about things they are perfectly capable of fixing.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: Uglydot on August 17, 2003, 02:12:19 PM
I'm not trying to whine and moan, but a popup that has the words "the order will find you" keeps following me around to different articles.  After four or five times it seems to have dissapeared.  I thought we were supposed to see these once?  Just wondering if it is working properly.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 18, 2003, 12:45:46 PM
rick -- i was referring to the days WHEN billy was still managing the site. popups simply were not an issue... on top of that we got unique content like the tour through nintendo HQ and adventures in japan and louie the cat rumor mills etc, etc... i think it's fair to say that the site hasn't been nearly as great as it used to be, and the increase in advertisement only pounds that truth home even more. i'm not complaining about this stuff just to be an dick... i feel these are genuine complaints.

i think it's unfair to have this "install software on your computer or suffer the consequences" philosophy of site management. i shouldn't have to install a popup blocker just for this one site. especially not when, like i said, there are several other similar sites that can deliver me the exact same content without the large number of ads. besides, if you're encouraging your readers to install popup blockers, you're not going to be getting revenue from them anyway, so why don't you just get rid of them? popup blockers aren't perfect, they often require configuring and turning off and on as they sometimes block legitimate content. pain in the ass.

gamespot and ign offer rich media content. video reviews, video caputres, screen shots, and not to mention regular editorial content and articles, along with timely reviews. how can you even begin to compare what pgc offers to that of those 2 big sites? when pgc starts delivering content like those sites, i would gladly sit through the ads, or hell even pay for it.

basically what i'm getting at is that the content for this site isn't worth all the ads i get slammed in my face. i can deal with popups if the content is compelling enough for me to suffer through it... but come on, interstitial ads, 2 - 3 popups per page, 4 - 6 inline ads per page... it's all a little much... and taking a look at the string of updates for the past month, there's little to nothing that makes me want to go and install an additional piece of software for my computer.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on August 18, 2003, 01:14:37 PM
My browser has a built in pop-up blocker- know how long it took me to download and install it. About 3 minutes. A dedicated pop-up blocker would take less time. You have EVERY ability to eliminate the pop-ups on this website, but instead you don't take any action against them and opt rather to whine and moan to US. The pop-ups must be REALLY bad if you're not willing to spend a few minutes and get a small pop-up blocker (which would actually eliminate ALL pop-ups, not just PGC's). If you're too lazy to get a pop-up blocker, why are you so persistant in trying to persuade us you're right. Either GET A POP-UP BLOCKER or SHUT UP. If you don't like the pop-ups and don't want to get a pop-u blocker, leave and spare us the soliloquy. Like I said, there's absolutely NO reason to complain about something you are perfectly capable of fixing.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on August 18, 2003, 01:36:38 PM
And PGC supplies us with everything FREE.  E3 movies, OST on PGC radio, anything and everything, it's all free.

I want everyone who complains to SHUT UP or go away.  You don't have to come to this site, but I find it to be the best GC site on the net by a longshot.  So there.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: aoi tsuki on August 18, 2003, 04:14:22 PM
i can understand not wanting to install software for one site, but what sites are you going to that you don't need a popup blocker (or a browser with one built in) and a spyware removal tool? Along with firewall and antivirus software, i'd say those are some of the most essential pieces of software you can install. And judging by some of the ads you're getting, you may need to get something to remove spyware.

And PGC simply can't compete with IGN or Gamespot. Both of the latter are companies that hire and pay employees, which are often employed by professional (or at least more seasoned) writers. Both sites also have a bigger focus and of course bigger workforce. i'm not downing PGC at all, but if you're honestly expecting them to go toe-to-toe with the "big boys", that just won't happen.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on August 18, 2003, 04:19:34 PM
Only financially- as I understand it, PGC's income from ads just about pay for their servers, and nothing else. Still, they have some of the best videogame writers on the internet and a lot of exclusives you wouldn't see anywhere else. IGN is a huge site that actually makes money (they've even gone public now), and they have a lot of flashy features and such, but I don't think they have anything over PGC news wise.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: RickPowers on August 18, 2003, 05:33:06 PM
Have fun reading other sites, then.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on August 18, 2003, 06:08:03 PM
This is like bitching to other people about how bad you smell.

If you STINK, then TAKE A BATH

If you don't like POPUPS, then install a POPUP KILLER.

WTF is your problem?  Are you retarded?

I use the browser Mozilla Firebird.  It NEVER blocks popups that I request, and on the one occasion that it did, I can just unblock the site.  I have NEVER seen an advertisement popup since I have installed it.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: Hostile Creation on August 19, 2003, 10:41:59 AM
I have yet to reinstall my pop-up blocker, and the ads still don't bother me.  It's not that big a deal here.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 20, 2003, 12:59:18 PM
well since you all think it's outrageous that i visit sites that don't have popups, allow me to show you a few GREAT sites, that have no popups and little to no advertising, yet offer similar/more/better content than pgc.. then maybe all you adamant defenders of all things pgc will realize there actually are BETTER nintendo/videogame sites out there and stop insulting me for expressing my personal grievances with a website that i've watched spiral downward into crappiness.

http://www.nintendojo.com (nintendo)
http://www.n-philes.com (nintendo)
http://www.ultimategamez.com (nintendo)
http://www.nintendoinsider.com (nintendo)
http://www.n-gamer.com (nintendo)
http://www.gamerfeed.com (multi-platform)
http://www.polygonmag.com (multi-platform)
http://www.eurogamer.net (multi-platform)

i could go on and on... assuming the mods won't delete the list of links i just posted, or this post entirely, you will see that i get more than enough videogame coverage, without paying a penny, without having to install additional software, and without having to close popup ads..

mouseclicker, you obviously don't visit many sites if you think pgc has the best news and features on the net. gimme a break.

grey ninja, i'm glad you enjoy your popup killer.

honestly guys, listen to yourselves... your popup-killer arguements still baffle me.. if you're all using popup killers, pgc is NOT getting paid for them.. and since pgc seems to be actively ENCOURAGING it's users to use popup killers, why even bother having them in the first place??? it's the most idiotic thing ever.

and rick, it really says something about how much you care about your readers when you would rather tell them to piss off then to actually look at the situation and try to think of compromises or alternate methods of generating revenue... to that i give you the glorious one finger salute. try to remember that without readers your site is NOTHING. i may be the only one who has really spoke up about this, but i can guarantee you that i'm not the only one that feels this way. don't let a few asskissers fool you into believing that pgc is still as great and respected as it once was.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on August 20, 2003, 01:05:24 PM
I think PGC is the best on the net becuase
1) It's all free. ALL
2)  They have the best writers in the business, online, that is.
3)  They have much more personallity, and it's much more of a community than other site.  The staff posts right here in the forums and are very active.  They all have a likeable personalities and are great hard workers.  And they do this for free.
4)  POPUPS AREN'T A PROBLEM
5)  The modding on this forum is great.  They do away with useless junk and encourage intelectual (sp?) conversation.  Which is good, if you didn't know.

That is what I have to say and now I'm hungry.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: mouse_clicker on August 20, 2003, 01:16:58 PM
Seriosuly, if you think Nintendojo and N-Philes are better, you've got tha IQ of a travel soap dish. O_O All those sites are relatively unpopular, especially when compared to PGC. Once they start getting very popular you'll one of 3 things happen- they'll make you pay for content, they'll have pop-ups and ads everywhere, or they'll fold. It's as simple as that PGC just made that jump a long time ago.

You obviously don't understand the way advertising works. Companies pay PGC to advertise their produdcts on the site. It doesn't matter if we actually click on the ads and visit them- people don't do that even when they don't have pop-up killers. PGC doesn't get a cut of the profits or anything, so we could click a thousand times and you wouldn't see any less ads.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on August 20, 2003, 02:38:29 PM
I am familiar with that list that you posted.  I still like PGC the best, as they have the exclusive interviews, best editorials, and their staff isn't composed of idiots (ala IGN).  I really wouldn't know if the sites have popups or not, as I don't feel the need to brag to the world about how stupid I am, and I actually have a browser with a built in popup killer, as is common sense.

Popup killers don't prevent the ads from loading, they prevent them from displaying.  Whoever told you otherwise is outright lying, or describing a shoddy product.  I am not hurting PGC's revenue one bit by running a popup killer.

But I am just sick of trying to talk sense to you.  If someone is complaining that the sun is too bright, but doesn't have the brains to accept the sunglasses I am offering, then I will simply leave him to suffer, and tell him to STFU before I slap him.  This isn't much of a different case.

Go to the other sites, and STFU.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 20, 2003, 10:24:49 PM
if you weren't so blinded with your hatred for someone that actually has the balls to criticize pgc, you'd see that the popup issue is just a part of the point i'm making. i'll try it once more: the number of ads (popup and otherwise) on pgc do not justify the content on the site. i attempted to prove this with the list of links i provided which displayed sites with similar amounts or more content with a fraction of the ads or no ads at all. granted pgc probably has more visitors than those sites, but i doubt pgc gets more visits these days than it did in it's prime, so the actual increase in the number of ads since then baffles me. okay? if you can't accept this piece of criticism and opt instead to insult my intelligence, then so be it. nothing i can do about your ignorance and immaturity. my only intention was to bring this subject to light and see if there was something that could be done about it. pgc was the first nintendo-themed site i've ever bookmarked and visited daily. forgive me for showing concern over it's downward slide.

now, you can continue to call me names and attempt to belittle the opinions and concerns that i have, but that doesn't change the fact that pgc could use some improvements... in the ad department and otherwise.

i do have to address the following:

Quote
Popup killers don't prevent the ads from loading, they prevent them from displaying. Whoever told you otherwise is outright lying, or describing a shoddy product. I am not hurting PGC's revenue one bit by running a popup killer.


so grey ninja, you're trying to tell me popup killers don't prevent the ads from loading? really? where do you suppose these ads load then, when you instantaneously close the window these ads are supposed to appear in? do they load in some kind of magic popup heaven and then beam down transmissions to the webserver that tracks these ads? oh wait, you have one of those advanced popup killers that prevents the windows from even opening in the first place? where do you suppose those ads load? in a magical void in the internet that enables websites to generate ad revenue for not displaying their ads? where can i sign up for that? it sounds like free money! you'll have to forgive my sarcasm, but i'd really like to hear your explaination for that ridiculous comment you made.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: PIAC on August 20, 2003, 10:35:22 PM
now whos being immature and insulting peoples inteligence...

the way i see this little spat is we are customers, PGC is the service provider, as customers we can decide if their service warrents the amount of adds, you have decided that no, it doens't, yet we have decided yes it does. there is no need to flame each other, that wont solve anything. personally the adds dont annoy me, they didn't annoy me before i got firebird, and they sure as hell dont annoy me now i have firebird.

PGC needs the revenue generated from having the adds to pay their server costs, so obviously they arn't going anywhere, especially when they are so adamant in keeping it free (and rightly so, top work lads)
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: Grey Ninja on August 21, 2003, 06:21:37 AM
Quote

so grey ninja, you're trying to tell me popup killers don't prevent the ads from loading? really? where do you suppose these ads load then, when you instantaneously close the window these ads are supposed to appear in? do they load in some kind of magic popup heaven and then beam down transmissions to the webserver that tracks these ads? oh wait, you have one of those advanced popup killers that prevents the windows from even opening in the first place? where do you suppose those ads load? in a magical void in the internet that enables websites to generate ad revenue for not displaying their ads? where can i sign up for that? it sounds like free money! you'll have to forgive my sarcasm, but i'd really like to hear your explaination for that ridiculous comment you made.


Your computer downloads the ad, puts in the cache, and then doesn't display it on your screen.  What's so bloody hard to figure out?  It works the same way that IE works, except it doesn't display the ad on the screen as a final step.

I don't even know why I am continuing to talk to you.  You have already proven to me that you are one of the biggest morons that I know, and every word you say afterward just seals the deal.
Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 21, 2003, 09:49:52 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: PIAC

the way i see this little spat is we are customers, PGC is the service provider, as customers we can decide if their service warrents the amount of adds, you have decided that no, it doens't, yet we have decided yes it does. there is no need to flame each other, that wont solve anything. personally the adds dont annoy me, they didn't annoy me before i got firebird, and they sure as hell dont annoy me now i have firebird.

PGC needs the revenue generated from having the adds to pay their server costs, so obviously they arn't going anywhere, especially when they are so adamant in keeping it free (and rightly so, top work lads)


sure, and as a "customer" i think i should be able to express my concerns to see if anything can be done about them. i was certainly hoping for a better response than "go somewhere else then" .. whatever..

Title: RE:too many ads!
Post by: snorgasmo on August 21, 2003, 10:04:31 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Grey Ninja


Your computer downloads the ad, puts in the cache, and then doesn't display it on your screen.  What's so bloody hard to figure out?  It works the same way that IE works, except it doesn't display the ad on the screen as a final step.

I don't even know why I am continuing to talk to you.  You have already proven to me that you are one of the biggest morons that I know, and every word you say afterward just seals the deal.


lies... everyone knows that the files in your cache aren't active on their own. assuming that you are right and that you download these ads regardless of whether their windows are allowed to load or not (which i still fail to believe).. the ad files would just be sitting there in your cache until they are called by the browser. the html in the ad won't be sending data back to the ad tracker. it would just be dead weight. you know what it means to cache a website? it means to save the files so that they're ready to go when you actually USE it instead of downloading it again. since you will never load this particular cached item, it will never send data to the ad tracker, and pgc will never get paid for your particular impression.

the whole point of a popup killer is not only to kill the popup, but also to prevent the impressions from "landing".. the idea is to show these ad servers that popups aren't delivering impressions and to stop using this method of advertising entirely.

notice how i'm capable of constructing a response without name calling? there are no girls to impress here.. stop trying to act so macho.
Title: RE: too many ads!
Post by: KnowsNothing on August 21, 2003, 10:29:36 AM
snorgasmo,  he's not trying to impress anyone.  he's just trying to get an iota of reasoning through that thick skull of yours, which obviously isn't working.

I suggest to everybody annoyed with snorgasmo, stop posting.  If you ever convince him to use common sense and get a popup blocker, he will just stay here in the forums and continue to bother people.  Let him leave, I say, and let this thread rest in peace.