Gaming Forums => General Gaming => Topic started by: MaryJane on September 16, 2006, 10:11:32 AM
Title: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: MaryJane on September 16, 2006, 10:11:32 AM
So I can sell it on Ebay for $2,000 - $3,000 and make $1,400 - $2,500 on it.
Thanks Sony!
If any of you have access to a friend who works at a game store and can make sure you actually get your PS3 on launch day I would recommend you do the same.
If the PS3 doesn't flop I'm going to own one because it not flopping means not all the games planned for it won't be made into Wii games with fewer polygon counts. And for some reason Sony gets floods and floods of RPG's which are my favorite.
At the same time, I'm not gonna pass up this opportunity. I did the same with XBOX360 except I went halves with someone, but on 3 systems. I made out with $1,700 after paying like ebay costs and all that other nonsense. I'm hoping to make at least that much on 1 PS3. Then maybe I'll buy my mom her own Wii so she won't play with mine.
i might be used to the name but that still sounds awkward
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: WuTangTurtle on September 16, 2006, 10:42:14 AM
I really hope your mom doesn't play with your wii.....
Joking aside, I too am hoping to do the same. The profit will go straight to my Wii purchases and the rest will go to pay off some credit card debt. Thank u Sony, ur losses on hardware go to my purchases on a Wii a credit debt!
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 16, 2006, 10:48:06 AM
I am hoping to get 3 PS3s (I hope I can get 1 preordered), 2 of which will come from staying in line with a friend or family member (I'll give them cash). With Wii I plan on getting 2 or 3 as well, 1 for me and 2 to sell.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: KDR_11k on September 16, 2006, 11:50:26 AM
Remember that profit of that magnitude has to be reported to the IRS as income.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BigJim on September 16, 2006, 12:24:48 PM
According to the interwebs, it seems like about half of those 500,000 will probably show up on eBay. lol.
Poor first-day buyers. All those systems being taken out of circulation at normal price.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: stevey on September 16, 2006, 12:41:21 PM
Quote If any of you have access to a friend who works at a game store and can make sure you actually get your PS3 on launch day I would recommend you do the same.
I would, but I cant since game stop is evil... link
Quote GameStop will start accepting pre-orders for the PS3/Wii on MONDAY SEPTEMBER 18. This will last for ONE WEEK only. Any store can and will stop taking pre-orders at any time (most likely when their limit is reached). I have been advised (and I advise you) to go to the store on Monday and get your pre-order in.
GameStop is NOT ACCEPTING cash, or store credit for your down payment on a pre-order. You HAVE to trade in games or accessories when you pre-order. It must total $50 or more, and it will all go towards your system pre-order. Any money you put down after $50 can be credit, cash, or whatever else GameStop/EB accepts. This applies for both the Wii and the PS3. ............ You are GUARANTEED to get a Wii, but the date you get it IS NOT GUARANTEED (he specifically told me that you are not guaranteed to get your system on launch or anytime during the Christmas season).
Stores are going to give out launch systems based on chronological pre-order order. That means if you are the first one to pre-order/reserve your Wii, you will be the first one to get a Wii on launch day.
Reservations are limited to 1 per household.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: wandering on September 16, 2006, 12:45:37 PM
Okay MaryJane, but don't spend it all on.......you know....
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: MaryJane on September 16, 2006, 01:38:39 PM
well some of it is definitely going to support the habit, but a lot more will go to support the new habit.
i feel the itch already.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: nitsu niflheim on September 16, 2006, 02:13:51 PM
Quote Originally posted by: KDR_11k Remember that profit of that magnitude has to be reported to the IRS as income.
In the US, you are required to report any money you make, period. For example, if you have a yard sale, that money you make is required to be stated on your tax return. But I doubt that a lot of people actually do that.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 16, 2006, 03:35:37 PM
well... with a yard sale you're selling things you bought in the past, so unless you're selling them for more than you paid, that's not technically income.
Legally though, you're also required to report every penny you find laying on the ground, and every time you go to a friend's house for a free meal. Oh, and if you play an MMO, any loot you get is also taxable.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Artimus on September 16, 2006, 04:07:37 PM
I'm really giving serious thought to this as well. I'd order it online and sell it as soon as they sell out. Awesome thought.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 16, 2006, 04:22:51 PM
I'm skeptical of the idea, as it seems to me the number of people sold on the idea of buying a launch PS3 (to play with) is pretty low at the retail price. I'm sure it'll sell out because of all the people intending on putting them on eBay, but unless there are a lot of people willing to pay thousands to get one a few months earlier it seems possible the post-retail market on eBay might get saturated and the price might not be near so appealing.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: wandering on September 16, 2006, 05:24:57 PM
Quote well... with a yard sale you're selling things you bought in the past, so unless you're selling them for more than you paid, that's not technically income.
Legally though, you're also required to report every penny you find laying on the ground, and every time you go to a friend's house for a free meal. Oh, and if you play an MMO, any loot you get is also taxable.
My understanding is, (and if I'm wrong, someone correct me) anytime something of worth transfers from one hand to another, the government is entileted to a piece of that pie...UNLESS it falls below a certain value. So, if you give someone a GameCube, no reporting takes place, but you give someone a car, it does. Free meals and stuff would fall below that threshold.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Arbok on September 16, 2006, 05:25:04 PM
Quote Originally posted by: jasonditz I'm skeptical of the idea, as it seems to me the number of people sold on the idea of buying a launch PS3 (to play with) is pretty low at the retail price. I'm sure it'll sell out because of all the people intending on putting them on eBay, but unless there are a lot of people willing to pay thousands to get one a few months earlier it seems possible the post-retail market on eBay might get saturated and the price might not be near so appealing.
The thing is, the supply out there is so limited (since eBay is a worldwide market place, you also have to consider some interested European buyers and those from other regions) that it would be hard for the price not to sky rocket and still find interested bidders.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Donutt007 on September 16, 2006, 05:46:06 PM
I personally hate that idea. Yes I have thought of doing it in the past, but sometimes, when I try to go to a concert and the tickets are sold out and I try to find one, it's a 100% markup or more. I hate that!!
There are some people that want to own a PS3 at launch (who knows why) and yes they will pay a high price, but why do people have to take such advantage of them. I am a firm believer in what goes around comes around. If you have enough money to buy three PS3's good for you, some people only have enough to buy 1 with no games, so you are screwing them over.
The thought of selling a PS3 for a much higher price did cross my mind, but I won't do it. I just think it's wrong to do so, so I won't be taking a part in it. The thought of owning every launch game for the Wii, plus all controllers made off of my PS3 profit does sound real tempting, but I think it's just wrong.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BranDonk Kong on September 16, 2006, 07:33:11 PM
You know, the whole PS3 on eBay idea might not work, due to the low demand for the console. And who gives 2 shits what the IRS wants to steal from you. It's bad enough that none of us here will ever receive Social Security benefits. Any penny you can keep the feds from robbing you of is a penny earned.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Artimus on September 16, 2006, 07:45:12 PM
The 360 had low demand and it was going for 2X easily.
In my opinion, if you want to pay $600 for a console, let alone more, I'll be even more than happy to take it from you.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: blackfootsteps on September 16, 2006, 08:26:07 PM
I'm with Donut. I see why people do it (ticket scalping, console scalping etc) but I've never thought of screwing a fellow music fan and/or console gamer to better my own position. That being said market bartering is a favourite past-time of mine so to each his own.
Then again people that are willing to pay 2 grand for a 360 are crazy. I wonder how many of those people still have working consoles?
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: KDR_11k on September 16, 2006, 08:37:31 PM
You are GUARANTEED to get a Wii, but the date you get it IS NOT GUARANTEED (he specifically told me that you are not guaranteed to get your system on launch or anytime during the Christmas season).
So preordering is the same as not preordering except you only get it when one specific store has stock instead of any store in your vincinity? Sounds like a bad deal. From what I've seen from the 360 launch the preorders will be massed at thegame stores and the general stores have surplus stock because noone remembers to go there.
Stores are going to give out launch systems based on chronological pre-order order. That means if you are the first one to pre-order/reserve your Wii, you will be the first one to get a Wii on launch day.
...or at least so they say, we all remember the 360 "the more accessories you have the higher you're on the list" desaster.
Oh, and if you play an MMO, any loot you get is also taxable.
No because you don't own the loot. It can be sold by declaring the process of getting and transferring the loot as a service rendered but the loot itself cannot be sold (unless you want to go to jail for selling stolen goods or maybe defrauding people, depending on what the judge considers that to be).
There are some people that want to own a PS3 at launch (who knows why) and yes they will pay a high price, but why do people have to take such advantage of them.
They're just correcting the price, after all Kutaragi said the PS3 is way too cheap.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 16, 2006, 08:41:49 PM
Quote Originally posted by: Arbok
Quote Originally posted by: jasonditz I'm skeptical of the idea, as it seems to me the number of people sold on the idea of buying a launch PS3 (to play with) is pretty low at the retail price. I'm sure it'll sell out because of all the people intending on putting them on eBay, but unless there are a lot of people willing to pay thousands to get one a few months earlier it seems possible the post-retail market on eBay might get saturated and the price might not be near so appealing.
The thing is, the supply out there is so limited (since eBay is a worldwide market place, you also have to consider some interested European buyers and those from other regions) that it would be hard for the price not to sky rocket and still find interested bidders.
I'm not convinced, from what I've seen that there are 500,000 people interested in buying PS3's to play at $600, let alone enough of a surplus of demand to support people paying thousands for it.
Most of the interest in pre-orders seems to be from people assuming they can get a lot of money for one on ebay, and if that's the case, the strategy most likely while not work.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 16, 2006, 08:51:47 PM
Quote Originally posted by: KDR_11k Oh, and if you play an MMO, any loot you get is also taxable.
No because you don't own the loot. It can be sold by declaring the process of getting and transferring the loot as a service rendered but the loot itself cannot be sold (unless you want to go to jail for selling stolen goods or maybe defrauding people, depending on what the judge considers that to be).
Not true of every MMO, some of them specifically do grant you ownership of your items and allow you to sell them. In that case the tax would not be owed simply if you sold the loot, but would be owed when you get it in the first place (at a fair market value), and taxed as "winnings".
But even in the case of ones that don't "allow it", income made from fraud or sale of stolen goods is taxable.
And I'm not sure looting the corpse of the Froglok you just slayed counts as "theft" in a legal sense, anymore than it counts as murder.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 16, 2006, 10:15:44 PM
Bartering on ebay with consoles, tickets etc is capitalism at its finest. If people don't pay those high prices, well you won't see high prices on ebay, so really it is the consumer that is causing the price to inflate, simple economics. If these people who want a PS3 refused to pay those high prices you would no longer see people (like me) hording them, so both sides are at fault. Hey, if one of those people want a console maybe they should sit out in 10-20 degree weather for 16 hrs and get it, that is what I did for XBox 360 which I sold on ebay and I felt I deserved every penny from it for doing that!
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Kairon on September 16, 2006, 10:40:47 PM
There is a risk factor here, albeit one I'm in the minority of considering. The PS3 is scehduled to have 1.2 million consoles shipped to the US in 2006 (IF you believe them), and it IS launching with 400,000 units on launch day. That's already more than MS was able to do.
*shrug* But business always involves risk of some sort.
~Carmine M. Red Kairon@aol.com
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 16, 2006, 10:42:39 PM
I really doubt they will get 1.2 million out (call me a pessimist, but their track record so far isn't great) and besides it isn't that much of a risk to sell for profit. Heck I believe historically about every new system in the last 3 generations has sold out and had marked up prices. If it turns out to not be the case I can just return it to the store ROFL.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: blackfootsteps on September 16, 2006, 10:45:06 PM
Oh yeah I understand the economics (go go finance major), its just something that I wouldn't personally do. Still you'll have like ten launch games and I'll probably have 3. Many people would say I'm stupid.
That being said the PS3 doesnt release here till March and by then supply probably wont be much of an issue.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 16, 2006, 11:08:18 PM
Quote Originally posted by: blackfootsteps Oh yeah I understand the economics (go go finance major), its just something that I wouldn't personally do. Still you'll have like ten launch games and I'll probably have 3. Many people would say I'm stupid.
That being said the PS3 doesnt release here till March and by then supply probably wont be much of an issue.
Ah my response was more directed at Donutt, I personally don't find it wrong. I figure if people are willing to camp out for hours upon hours to get ahold of something they should be able to do what they want with it. If some really wanted the system they would do the same thing (Heck I did it for Nintendo DS), personally I never have felt cheated if a system I wanted gets sold out and the price is marked up. I remember with PS2 I had that problem but frankly I blamed myself, not the people who were selling it on ebay, if I really wanted it I should have suffered the same as them to get it.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: WuTangTurtle on September 17, 2006, 01:16:02 AM
What about the fact that ebayers are servicing the b!tch slapped Europe and any small town folk in the US that may not even get a shipment. We've all heard about how only the stores selling the most Sony Video Game products will be getting the most PS3's, what chance do you think low populated places are going to get any at all.
After making $100 off of a Limited Edition Nintendog DS and seeing how much ppl were making off of the 360 I am really thinking about doing the same for the PS3 but i really think it is a risk. However I am thinking it is a lot less of a risk for ebaying a Wii, i just see more demand for it come launch.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 17, 2006, 01:22:28 AM
Shaolin I don't believe it is that big of a risk, most places will accept a return of unopened consoles. So if shortly after launch it turns out that demand is not there to profit on it, then just return it to the store you bought it at. That is what I did with the PSP, in fact I bought two, and ended up returning both of them after seeing it wasn't going to sell.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: MaryJane on September 17, 2006, 04:21:45 AM
I'm doing it for my general disdain of the stupidity of people.
I don't know what you guys are talking about with the low demand of PS3 because everyone I talk to still wants the bloody system.
I hate scalpers too. I paid $150 for $45 tickets to see Tool play. Worth it? every penny.
The people who are going ridiculously priced PS3's are going to feel the same way.
If I were going to scalp tickets, it would never be to a Tool concert, it would be like Coldplay or one of those other immensely popular bands who spew out a carbon copy album every year.
I'd also never "scalp" a Wii I would sell it at price, which is why I'm not buying any extra ones to begin with.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: wandering on September 17, 2006, 08:08:40 AM
Quote If I were going to scalp tickets, it would never be to a Tool concert, it would be like Coldplay or one of those other immensely popular bands who spew out a carbon copy album every year.
I'd also never "scalp" a Wii I would sell it at price, which is why I'm not buying any extra ones to begin with.
This about mirrors my feelings. I don't want to scre over fellow gamers, true...but if someone is willing to pay $1000 or whatever for a ps3... *shrug*
It's win-win. Or rather, lose-lose, because I believe I can achieve happiness through money and he believes he can achieve happiness through the PS3 - when neither of us are correct and both of us are, in fact, unwittingly shackling ourselves with misery.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 17, 2006, 03:56:35 PM
If you don't like scalpers, don't buy from them. They're providing a useful service in raising the price to bring demand into line with supply. The alternative is not paying regular price, the alternative is not being able to get them at all.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BranDonk Kong on September 17, 2006, 07:06:00 PM
Sorry to bring up a reply from earlier, but the Xbox 360 had a whole crapload of hype and demand for its launch, which is why it was sold out just as soon as stock was received for a good 5-6 months. PS3 on the other hand, is going to be crushed by the Wii. The system is already selling for $600, there won't be that many people willing to shell out much more than that so their bratty kids will be happy on Christmas.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BranDonk Kong on September 17, 2006, 07:11:08 PM
The ticket scalping argument isn't quite the same. It is in a way, but I hate the idea of it, and I'm ashamed that it was just legalized here in Florida, even though people were still doing it anyway (I even recently bought tickets for 3x the value before it was legalized). Say an event goes on sale, and you don't have enough money to buy tickets, a couple weeks later you do - but some ass holes, who never had any intention on going to the event, bought all the extra tickets, and now you have to pay an exhoborant price for them. It just sucks, and people get rich and the working class gets screwed. It should be illegal everywhere.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 17, 2006, 07:55:39 PM
Why should it be illegal? What would that solve? It's a service people want (even yourself in some cases), and they're willing to pay for it. And ultimately, even when it was illegal, people were still doing it. Other than throwing some people in jail, what benefit would making it illegal create?
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: couchmonkey on September 18, 2006, 06:47:08 AM
The best reason to buy a PS3 is for its top-notch graphics.
But I'm still going to try to sell one or two on Ebay. The whole question of capitalism is an interesting one. Capitalism can be immoral. That being said, I wouldn't compare the PS3 launch to, say, scalping Rolling Stones tickets. The Rolling Stones may die next year and never come to your city again. Even if the Stones don't die next year you may only get one chance to see them in your own city unless you live somewhere like L..A. or New York. PS3s, on the other hand, will be bountiful within a year.
As for the risk, yeah, I think there's a slight risk factor in PS3 due to the high price, but looking at the Xbox 360 and PS2 launches, people seem to be willing to pay a lot more than $600 for a hot console. Is it hot, though? I don't know yet.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 18, 2006, 07:55:26 AM
Even with concert tickets, it's not as though scalping reduces the number of people able to see the concert, they don't generally just let tickets remain unsold when the concert is about to start. 50,000 or however many people will still see the concert, it's just that somebody besides the original ticket vendor got to make a little money on the side providing the service of waiting in line for people who were unable to do so.
Is making sure concerts are attending only by those with flexible enough schedules to wait in line an issue so pressing that we must throw professional line-waiters in prison? Is the notion of the guy who had to work that morning getting to see the concert so repulsive that we can condemn the entire capitalist system for it?
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Hocotate on September 18, 2006, 08:26:19 AM
Quote Originally posted by: MaryJane I'm doing it for my general disdain of the stupidity of people.... I paid $150 for $45 tickets to see Tool play.
lol.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 18, 2006, 11:56:15 AM
Quote Originally posted by: couchmonkey The best reason to buy a PS3 is for its top-notch graphics.
But I'm still going to try to sell one or two on Ebay. The whole question of capitalism is an interesting one. Capitalism can be immoral. That being said, I wouldn't compare the PS3 launch to, say, scalping Rolling Stones tickets. The Rolling Stones may die next year and never come to your city again. Even if the Stones don't die next year you may only get one chance to see them in your own city unless you live somewhere like L..A. or New York. PS3s, on the other hand, will be bountiful within a year.
As for the risk, yeah, I think there's a slight risk factor in PS3 due to the high price, but looking at the Xbox 360 and PS2 launches, people seem to be willing to pay a lot more than $600 for a hot console. Is it hot, though? I don't know yet.
But the Xbox 360 has equitable graphical abilities (different innards but they are comparable) to the PS3 so I'm not sure that will be a selling point for PS3. BTW in response to shortages and high prices, all I need to say is "Tickle Me Elmo", people don't care when it comes out all they know is they NEED it now especially for Christmas.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: vudu on September 18, 2006, 12:23:00 PM
Anyone know what happens to you if you buy a bum-PS3 on eBay? What with Sony's pretty shabby quality control, it doesn't seem too unlikely that at least a few systems will putter out after a few dozen hours. If you happened to buy it on eBay, you're no longer the original owner, and might not be covered by the warranty. If that was the case, would you be completely screwed?
Anyone know what happened to people who bought bad 360s on eBay or PSPs with dead pixels?
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 18, 2006, 12:35:30 PM
Quote Originally posted by: vudu Anyone know what happens to you if you buy a bum-PS3 on eBay? What with Sony's pretty shabby quality control, it doesn't seem too unlikely that at least a few systems will putter out after a few dozen hours. If you happened to buy it on eBay, you're no longer the original owner, and might not be covered by the warranty. If that was the case, would you be completely screwed?
Anyone know what happened to people who bought bad 360s on eBay or PSPs with dead pixels?
I'm not sure what happens, but I have a feeling you can return them if you have the receipt (which smart sellers include).
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: MaryJane on September 18, 2006, 01:33:07 PM
the only problem with scalping is that other people are making money off of something they didn't put any work into except saying tickets!
Artists of every nature make most of their money doing concerts, as much as they tell you that the concert is for the fans, it also fills their pockets, although i don't doubt they enjoy watching thousands of people enjoy their music so they make their money already charging a lot then the fans who could have bought tickets on sale day but couldn't because some jerk-wad bought them all get screwed, and that jerk-wad makes money on sometimes years of hard work the band put into making their latest album which they make almost no money off of. on the other hand it does provide a service, so yes i don't see too much of a problem with it myself, the only problem i really have is when they have insane mark-ups, some guys are nice enough to only mark it up $50 or "only" double the amount of the ticket.
but like i said if it's crap and people are willing to buy it, SELL IT!
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 18, 2006, 03:04:49 PM
of course Ticketmaster is also making money off the band's hard work.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Kairon on September 18, 2006, 03:05:24 PM
It's much easier to do ethically wrong things against people or things you don't respect and/or don't consider worth respect. See: Nazi Germany.
Don't ban me! I do it too, I have a long dormant policy that I will overlook piracy of Sony products, but am a little more zealous with Nintendo products.
Oh, and with regards to the artists who perform at concerts... I buy CDs, I don't fileshare! So I'm ethically safe in at least that regard.
~Carmine M. Red Kairon@aol.com
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: wandering on September 18, 2006, 03:18:31 PM
You're comparing a sale that all parties involved voluntarily agree to... to Nazi Germany?
I didn't think you could do any worse than comparing Halo to Grave of the Fireflies, but it appears I was mistaken...
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 18, 2006, 03:40:20 PM
Quote Originally posted by: wandering You're comparing a sale that all parties involved voluntarily agree to... to Nazi Germany?
I thought he was comparing the persecution of the parties in the sale to the persecution of Jews and Gypsies under Nazi Germany.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: wandering on September 18, 2006, 03:46:09 PM
In what way is someone who chooses to pay $2000 for a PS3 on eBay being persecuted?
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Kairon on September 18, 2006, 06:24:20 PM
Stop tearing apart my analogies! /cry
It's NOT about persecuting people, it's about doing unethical acts. If my unethical act hurts someone, then it's so much easier to do that act if the person I'm hurting is someone who I've stripped humanity of. If I emotionally discredit my victim, (i.e. It's nobody I know, or he's an idiot anyways if he wants to pay 2000 bucks) then it's infinitely easier for me to be brutally ruthless and capitalistically callow.
HOWEVER, if my victim is somebody who I can develop empathy with instead of snide contempt, (i.e. people I see everyday, or Nintendo, the company I believe in) then it's much more difficult for me to compromise my own ethical code because my conscience, triggered by my empathy and no longer held in check by my anger/contempt for others, comes into play.
For instance: There is zero difference between selling a $2000 PS3 to a stranger and selling a $2000 PS3 to your uncle so he can give it to little timmy, your cousin. So why is profitting off of some stranger so much more preferable to profitting off of a family member?
~Carmine M. Red Kairon@aol.com
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 18, 2006, 06:43:06 PM
I'd profit off a family member if one would buy it ROFL.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Kairon on September 18, 2006, 06:54:49 PM
Ok...ummm... if you had a little cousin who got the Charizard foil pokemon card... would you cheat it off him through a shady trade when he doesn't know it's value? If not, would you do it if it was just a kid off the street you bumped into instead of your little cousin?
~Carmine M. Red Kairon@aol.com
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 18, 2006, 07:17:32 PM
But the person paying $2000 for a PS3 is not being cheated. He's not "an idiot". Well, he may be, but that's not the reason why.
If he wants a PS3 and can't get one for any cheaper than $2000... he is probably quite glad that the option is available to him. Again, the alternative isn't unlimited $600 PS3s for all, it's unavailability. He may well value the PS3 enough that to him, the PS3 is worth $2000... in fact it's fairly clear that he does, or he wouldn't be willing to pay that much.
He's not being swindled, he's going into the transaction with both eyes open. He knows he has the option of waiting a few months and getting one for less, but he'd rather pay more and have it now. Why shouldn't he be able to?
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 18, 2006, 07:24:41 PM
I wouldn't cheat a little kid, that is well, just wrong relative or not a relatives. When it comes to adults or even teens, they know the risks (or should know them) and I am giving them something they want whether they be family or not while I get something in return for the long hours I spent getting it.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 18, 2006, 07:33:51 PM
mweheheh... little do they know I've got stock in eBay
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: Kairon on September 18, 2006, 08:45:47 PM
Quote Originally posted by: jasonditz But the person paying $2000 for a PS3 is not being cheated. He's not "an idiot". Well, he may be, but that's not the reason why.
If he wants a PS3 and can't get one for any cheaper than $2000... he is probably quite glad that the option is available to him. Again, the alternative isn't unlimited $600 PS3s for all, it's unavailability. He may well value the PS3 enough that to him, the PS3 is worth $2000... in fact it's fairly clear that he does, or he wouldn't be willing to pay that much.
He's not being swindled, he's going into the transaction with both eyes open. He knows he has the option of waiting a few months and getting one for less, but he'd rather pay more and have it now. Why shouldn't he be able to?
Oh. Well, yeah, there's no problem with scalping and jacking the price up for stuff if you're merely a part of regular everyday market forces and there are no victims, only happy responsible customers. Viewed this way, anything is ethically scalpable from concert tickets to Wiis.
~Carmine M. Red Kairon@aol.com
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: MaryJane on September 19, 2006, 04:15:15 AM
True, I think though that it becomes unethical if you're going to screw someone over.
It reaches a point where a person is getting screwed. Not on ebay because, the person buying says they are willing to pay this much, they could always not have said $2,000. When you scalp a ticket, sure you can haggle (depending on the situation) but for the most part the price is being dictated to you. And thus, you can get screwed, I've never been to a concert I didn't travel at least half an hour to. what am i supposed to do when the only scalper i see says $150? go back? nope, bend over and take it.
slight difference, but it's there.
Also i'd say someone is being a real d!ck head if there going to screw someone over on something that they also love, or are passionate about.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 19, 2006, 05:44:57 AM
you might want to start looking for aftermarket tickets before the day of the event. It's like going to the airport two hours before your flight to buy tickets, it puts you in a really bad bargaining position.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 19, 2006, 09:35:59 AM
Quote Originally posted by: jasonditz you might want to start looking for aftermarket tickets before the day of the event. It's like going to the airport two hours before your flight to buy tickets, it puts you in a really bad bargaining position.
As long as your service or goods is not necessary such as medication or food, then I think it is fair game. Even with concert tickets no one is telling you to buy it, it still is your choice no one is screwing you but yourself, you are willing to pay even if you are aware of the high mark up value. That is why I never have complained if I wanted to purchase something whether it be a ticket or some other good for a higher price, because the responsibiity is mine and I screwed up by not getting that product when it was first on sale.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BranDonk Kong on September 19, 2006, 07:33:01 PM
It's not capitalism, it's more like price gouging. It's bad enough that you're getting raped by ticketmaster - $15 for a service charge? Where's the service? I'm not saying people should be thrown in jail - there should be fines or something like that. Oh well, I'm not going to change anyone's mind, and no one's going to change mine...PS3 sucks.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: jasonditz on September 19, 2006, 08:52:47 PM
Rising price as a response to scarcity doesn't seem like the sort of thing you can just wish away with fines.
Title: RE:Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: GoldenPhoenix on September 19, 2006, 10:26:52 PM
Again I say, price gouging would not happen if people didn't pay the prices for it (besides that term is very subjective, it is more of a personal preference of when something is not worth what is being asked, which could mean about anything). People are in effect gouging themselves if they spend alot of money for something who's sole pupose is for entertainment, if you want to end it, well you and others should stop buying it, it isn't like you need to go the concernt or NEED a PS3 or Wii like other goods.
Title: RE: Why I'm going to buy a PS3 on launch day.
Post by: BranDonk Kong on September 20, 2006, 05:51:40 PM
If you have kids that want to keep up with the Joneses, you do.