I never really paid much attention to the VGchartz comment section.
I am talking about the forums, but yeah the comments are just as bad.
See, the VGhcartz forums is a perfect representation is why the console wars are stupid. No one is talking about games there. All they do is compare sales numbers (which are unofficial BTW), bash each system and try to proclaim why they hate a system (whether through a thread or through a signatures). There's no discussion, there's no love of gaming, there's no HEART. Its all one big popularity contest where it goes down to "My console can beat up YOUR console" debates.
We may have acted like this on ocassion (myself included), but at the very least games ARE discussed, analyzed and recommended. We may be dysfunctional but we work better as a gaming community that some of the other forums.