I ended up getting Mist to 5 hearts early in the game cuz I didn't know any better, then I realized I'm wasting crops on her.
Diana got to about 3 since I kept giving her turnips, and Mist didn't like that (so funny), which kept Mist's number under control.
Selphy's around 2 cuz of all the damn books I bought.
Melody's nearing 4 cuz I use the bath often. She's probably peeping.
Cinnamon's a whopping 10 happy faces and 3 hearts, and I totally figured out my fishing routine. I fish, I make sushi to have massive RP reserves, and I'll give her the weak lvl.1 fish, and she'll eventually give up THE CLAM.
I give her one turnip ever other harvest, the rest of the time i just make sure to talk to her as often as possible and till my feilds whenever i clear up some of the stumps. Appearantly she you get bonus LP when you till a certain amount of your feild.. guess she likes to watch how you put your cheap hoe's to work (she must be submissive)
I dont even know who diana is.. guess she hasn't moved to town yet?
Selphy is easy to get LP with because not only do you get some off her (hehe..) for buying the books, but even READING the books. Whenever you go read a new shelf, she swoons that you're reading a new book.
Melody has 1 happy face but until recently had no love for me, until i realized i can use all those damn colored grass for something other than potion making. She'll have 1 heart for me soon, and it'll be easy to get her points up because i obviously bathe every day and can afford to give her some grass each visit. Oh and must totally be peeping.
Cinnamon is definately in the friend zone with 1 happy face, but she's closing to getting 1 heart too. Gotta make sure to get her a fish on her birthday! She's one of the few girls i make sure to talk to on a daily basis, because she tells you about the constellations. If you see one, and tell her about it she likes you more. Seeing one and figuring out who its associated with leads to even more LP for the other girls, so Cinnamon is basically the way to EVERY girls heart in the game. Mighty important role for someone who lacks social skills.
Laura/Lara (whatever th Nun/Nurse's name is) will probably hate me cuz i've blacked out a few times since she's gotten there. I dont think i should even bother with her.