Topic: Mafia XXXII: Day 3 (plus weekend)

[RABicle]

The evidence seems pretty clear: Vote Khush

Sorry I hadn't been playing guys. It's been a crazy week.

[NWR_DrewMG]

Wha?! Dude(ette) I'm just following the rules. I think you are mafia. I am not sure where DrewMG is going with his choices thus far, but it certainly is interesting who he chose!

My choices came from the random number generator at random.org

I listed all of the roles sequentially from 1-23, and picked a number at random.  The role that corresponded to that number went to the player next in the list, in order of signups.

[NWR_DrewMG]

We're looking at about 12 hours left in the vote for Day 3. 

Current tally:

Khushrenada - 7
nickmitch - 1
SirSniffy - 1

[SirSniffy]

My choices came from the random number generator at random.orgI listed all of the roles sequentially from 1-23, and picked a number at random.  The role that corresponded to that number went to the player next in the list, in order of signups.

Aaaah, thanks for clearing this up. Still interesting the way a lot of things have played out thus far...so unpredictable! Last time I sort of watched the game, and I could at least guess about a few things. This time though...

[Khushrenada]

So, it seems like people are finally wising up and realizing that I've been telling the truth all along. My townie alliance is ThePerm, Stogi and Shyguy. At least it was. I gave out my reason on why we should take out BFS on Day 2. My biggest error was probably promising too much and saying that no townie would die. Like I said in the message, BFS could be innocent. It could be a trick by Maxi. But I went with the best case scenario. And it wasn't a total loss. We still did lose the Hammer Bros.

As for Vudu, I've suspected him to be mafia for awhile. You'll notice in the message I sent him about who I suspected the mafia was, I included Stogi. I know Stogi is innocent. I included his name to see if Vudu would take the bait and agree with me that he thought he was mafia. I also included other suspects like GP and Nickmitch in the hopes that I was right about them being mafia and hopefully worrying the mafia that I was uncovering them. SirSniffy was a guess at the time but with him voting Nickmitch I no longer believe him to be mafia and that's why I didn't include him on my list of suspects that I posted.

I find it curious that Vudu made a big show about how I could not be mafia but then came up with another reason why I still am. That way tomorrow, he can claim that he made a mistake with some kind of evidence and should have stuck with his deduction of me being innocent.

Just want to give you some false hope in trying to get unvoted to crush later or I'm preparing to bandwagon another member mafia tomorrow with the true townie alliance....

Yes because to prepare another bandwagon, one clearly can not vote with the current bandwagon. And the true townie alliance is.... just yourself? Wow.

[RABicle]

While Khush's post above is pretty stupid (naming the townie alliance???) there's one lingering thing in my mind; the hammer bros.

To me, if I were a hammer brother or even a Koopa, I'd be dead set keen on getting them on board. With the second hammer brother, they're essentially a 6 strong, double hitting Mafia, and then late in the game the hammer brothers can sell out Mafias in the vote and look like superheroes and take the win. Khush is the kinda devious player that would orchestrate such a situation. The thing is, the mafia hit the hammer bros, killing both. Not only that they hit Maxi, their own guy (check the player list). It wasn't a blind strike in the dark. So if Khush was part of the mafia, he's pretty stupid. And Khush isn't stupid.
Then again, maybe all that was part of a larger, grander plan.

In a situation like this, I'd remove my vote because I wouldn't want to take the blame for hitting a townie / could still claim credit for original having voted mafia if he does turn out to be evil. But I have to vote or die and since I don't see either other bandwagon having wheels, I'll keep my vote for Khushrenada and let ShyGuy take the blame for pushing the wagon down the road.

Maybe I'll be awake in time to check things before the close.

[Khushrenada]

You're right. I have been stupid. Vudu is not mafia. It's been staring me in the face for three days and I haven't clued in. Take Vudu off the list of suspects. Ever make a deduction and all you do is look for evidence to support that deduction while ignoring contrary evidence? That's what I've done. I apologize Vudu.

[vudu]

Apology accepted.

[stevey]

While Khush's post above is pretty stupid (naming the townie alliance???) there's one lingering thing in my mind; the hammer bros.

To me, if I were a hammer brother or even a Koopa, I'd be dead set keen on getting them on board. With the second hammer brother, they're essentially a 6 strong, double hitting Mafia, and then late in the game the hammer brothers can sell out Mafias in the vote and look like superheroes and take the win. Khush is the kinda devious player that would orchestrate such a situation. The thing is, the mafia hit the hammer bros, killing both. Not only that they hit Maxi, their own guy (check the player list). It wasn't a blind strike in the dark. So if Khush was part of the mafia, he's pretty stupid. And Khush isn't stupid.
Then again, maybe all that was part of a larger, grander plan.

In a situation like this, I'd remove my vote because I wouldn't want to take the blame for hitting a townie / could still claim credit for original having voted mafia if he does turn out to be evil. But I have to vote or die and since I don't see either other bandwagon having wheels, I'll keep my vote for Khushrenada and let ShyGuy take the blame for pushing the wagon down the road.

True, but selling out a possible future traitor and making it seem like it was done by a so called townie alliance that you're in charge would cause the townies with roles to out themselves to you while using the power of a godfather to hide your mafia role is nearly as good. Especially stince you with them be able to control the vote and kill all threats to the mafia.

Not to mention that Maxi has biggest mouth out of all the players and with very little prodding he will sing like a canary. That would make him a very temping hit for any smart godfather even without the traitorous powers....

[ShyGuy]

!!!!?!!?!

[Khushrenada]

Well, I guess I'll change my mind after all. I was going to go the martyr route but with the advances I've made today, I'm going to try and stick it out. I've had many messages from people saying the support me. I'm also getting many name people suspect as mafia. The one that seems to be getting the most attention is Insanolord. Therefore, I will

unVote Insanolord

and see whether this show of support is real or not.


EDIT: Vote Nickmitch

[ShyGuy]

(holds up rewritten sign) VOTE NICKMITCH

[NWR_DrewMG]

QnD tally:

Khush - 7
Nickmitch - 2
Insanolord - 1
SirSniffy - 1

[DAaaMan64]

vote insano

[ThePerm]

poor khush, i'm not even sure if he is guilty, but he just put himself in a bad position. However, if he was the bomb he did a genius thing and will take out 7  people. I would vote for him, but do not want to be blown apart, i hope he takes  out the mafia lol!

[Khushrenada]

C'mon Perm. Vote Nickmitch. Force stevey to vote for me.

damn i wish i knew who luigi was!

Why? If Khush is mafia, he's going to kill me tonight since I completely nailed him in PMs....

If I was mafia, I wouldn't waste the hit. And I know who Luigi is.

[NWR_DrewMG]

Six minutes until voting closes for Day 3.

[NWR_DrewMG]

And this long day comes to a close.  Results tomorrow in the AM.

[NWR_DrewMG]

Final results:

Khushrenada - 7
nickmitch - 3
insanolord - 1
SirSniffy - 1

[Khushrenada]

What?!!!! I demand a recount. I made sure to remove all those votes against me! How did they get reposted?

[NWR_DrewMG]

Final Tally

nickmitch - 10
insanolord - 1
SirSniffy - 1

Funny, my first count was really off!

just kidding.