Topic: Mafia 84: RE: CV Neighbor Day 2- Wesker?!

[BeautifulShy]

That eliminates the majority, right?  Meaning the rest of the day goes on?

Yes day goes on until 8am AZ time so about 8 hours and 20 minutes to go till the end of the day.

[pokepal148]

Insanolord usually just lays low. It's a pretty standard play strategy for him iirc.

[Khushrenada]

There's different ways of laying low. ShyGuy's been laying low. He's posted less this game than Insanolord. But at least he's voted each day. Letting players slide without voting is one of the biggest detriments to the townie side. If he is a townie, he should at least be more active in voting even if that is the only post he makes.

[Khushrenada]

But ThePerm didn't respond to my PM either which seems pretty odd.

Interesting theory: ThePerm is Ashford. He attempted to get people who claimed to be townies to PM him so he can decide who to use his indoctrination thing on. Either he is targeting players who contacted him, assuming they're lying, or he is assuming they're telling the truth and targeting players who do not draw attention to themselves that way.

Or maybe he is mafia and felt the townie roles probably wouldn't contact him whereas townies might and that would give him a better pool of who to target with his hits. Or maybe he said it as a joke and didn't expect responses or trust those who responded. There's a lot of possibilities. However, since no one wants to pursue Insanolord and, looking over my breakdown, I am 50/50 on Perm but from other players I'm considering as possibly innocent, it still puts him in the group of more possible suspects. Still, he voted for GK on Day 1. Why do that and have the mafia hit GK that night anyways? But why didn't he respond to the messages he asked for? Moreover, when he's been a townie, I've seen him try to be more investigative / logical than he has been with his votes so far in this game. In Mafia 75, he was the Moblin and he got voted out Day 2 for being too aggressive in his line of reasoning but he was trying to vote in the best way he could in those early days. I don't see that in his game right now. I hate voting for someone I'm 50/50 on but I'd like to get to another day and if my choices are Bungle, TOPHATANT123 or ThePerm then I guess he's the best choice of those slim pickings.

Vote ThePerm

[NWR_insanolord]

I guess I'll Vote ThePerm since people are making a halfway decent case for that, but I reserve the right to attack Khush in other ways.

[pokepal148]

I'll finish the others in a moment but wanted to post what I've done so far because I think it really shows I'm not mafia. How many other players are going to post a breakdown of everyone in the game? And you really think a mafia member is going to do that? This alone should probably prove I'm a townie.

This is true.  It's a very high-risk maneuver from the mafia role because you have to project innocence on your team members while making a valid case for things you know aren't true and may lack evidence for.  Shaky analysis can get you killed.

Oh really? Let's have some fun than.

Insanolord did not cast a single vote during Mafia 81, during which he was the doctor, nor did he cast a vote during 82, which literally killed him, and he was a townie.

Also Stevey voted for you during 81 even though he was Mafia, although it was to break a tie.

I wanted to buy some time to find holes in your analysis so I could be sure. Looks like I found some. vote Khushrenada On second thought, vote thePerm, I'm kind of on the fence about this but thePerm is more suspicious.

[BeautifulShy]

New vote tally


Khushrenada-4
ThePerm-4
Mr. Bungle-3

[Luigi Dude]

After seeing some of the new evidence I'll change my vote.

Vote ThePerm

[BeautifulShy]

Well we have a tie now.

ThePerm-4
Khushrenada-4
Mr. Bungle-3

So if this sticks till the end of the day there will be a 30 minute period to change votes/unvote and whoever is the leading vote getter will be voted out.   If there is still a tie after that 30 minute period then I will lock the thread and randomly kill someone from the alive players.


New vote tally edit: 
ThePerm-5
Khushrenada-4
Mr. Bungle-3

[nickmitch]

I'll vote ThePerm for reasons stated above.

[BeautifulShy]

So there is a hour and a half left in Day 2.

Vote Tally

ThePerm-5
Khushrenada-4
Mr. Bungle-3

[BeautifulShy]

That wraps up the 2nd day of play for today.

Final vote total for today.

ThePerm-5
Khushrenada-4
Mr. Bungle-3

ThePerm with five votes is out of the game.

For those that have night actions you can send them in. You have 24 hours to do so from this post.