So I'm bumping because I just started playing the retail copy of this game.
Overall I think it's really interesting. Now, I've never played Gears of War, but I feel like the shooting (which is what everyone in this thread claims is the rip off portion) is not the primary part of the game. It feels closer to PoP to me than that.
The amazing part of the game is the pacing. I've never played a game that is paced so much like a movie. It's quite strange. I can't decide if I prefer it or not, but the story is moving extremely quickly.
I'm definitely gonna finish this thing off quickly, as I'm craving to play it, so I'll keep putting my opinions in here. =P Has anyone else played the retail?