Topic: Eternal Mafi Day III

[Stratos]

Story will come later. Sorry. Life.

What Happened:

JR Librarian, the Greater Guardian, got voted out.

Jr - 7
Sundoulos, Thatguy, Maxi - 1 each

Shaymin, the townie, hit by mafia

[that Baby guy]

No killer hit?

Really?  Weird.

[BeautifulShy]

Hmm very interesting results.
jrlibrarian got voted out and as I said was the greater guardian. Shamin turning up townie might help narrow down who the killer or mafia are.

I wonder if the killer tried to kill someone but was blocked or that person didn't send in a kill.

Can you tell us if the killer was blocked Stratos?

Edit:Looking over the votes of day 2 and the results today show that anybody that voted in day 2 didn't have the bonethief in them.Since the results are the same as what happened in the day 2 vote.
On day 1 there was 3 votes for thatguy however in the results in day 2 show that there was only 2 votes for him.Using Day 2 as a judge of possible bone thief victims that means that anybody that voted do not have the bone thief in them.I'm going to complile a list of possible bone thief victims in a little while.
Oh defender contact me we need to talk.

[NWR_insanolord]

Well, you were right, Maxi. Got any more inside information?

[Toruresu]

Awesomely played Maxi! Who's next?


Edit: Eternal "Mafi" Day III could be "Eternal Maxi" I bet! lol

[BeautifulShy]

I need to look over the past few days for some things.I'll throw out a vote in a little while.

[Sundoulos]

Edit:Looking over the votes of day 2 and the results today show that anybody that voted in day 2 didn't have the bonethief in them.Since the results are the same as what happened in the day 2 vote.
On day 1 there was 3 votes for thatguy however in the results in day 2 show that there was only 2 votes for him.Using Day 2 as a judge of possible bone thief victims that means that anybody that voted do not have the bone thief in them.I'm going to complile a list of possible bone thief victims in a little while.

 
Unless the bone thief chose not to subvert the vote...do they have to choose a different person, or can they do it just when it suits their purpose?

[BeautifulShy]

Edit:Looking over the votes of day 2 and the results today show that anybody that voted in day 2 didn't have the bonethief in them.Since the results are the same as what happened in the day 2 vote.
On day 1 there was 3 votes for thatguy however in the results in day 2 show that there was only 2 votes for him.Using Day 2 as a judge of possible bone thief victims that means that anybody that voted do not have the bone thief in them.I'm going to complile a list of possible bone thief victims in a little while.

 
Unless the bone thief chose not to subvert the vote...do they have to choose a different person, or can they do it just when it suits their purpose?

Well the bonethief can't bust out of someone. The bonethief  have to be inside the person until the defender use their ability on whoever has been infected. So if the bonethief is in somebody they can only control that person as far as votes go.

[Sundoulos]

Edit:Looking over the votes of day 2 and the results today show that anybody that voted in day 2 didn't have the bonethief in them.Since the results are the same as what happened in the day 2 vote.
On day 1 there was 3 votes for thatguy however in the results in day 2 show that there was only 2 votes for him.Using Day 2 as a judge of possible bone thief victims that means that anybody that voted do not have the bone thief in them.I'm going to complile a list of possible bone thief victims in a little while.

 
Unless the bone thief chose not to subvert the vote...do they have to choose a different person, or can they do it just when it suits their purpose?

Well the bonethief can't bust out of someone. The bonethief  have to be inside the person until the defender use their ability on whoever has been infected. So if the bonethief is in somebody they can only control that person as far as votes go.

I'm sorry; I think I stated my question poorly.  To clarify, does the bonethief necessarily have to vote for a different person that the person it's infected?  It could have chosen not to vote differently in order to throw people off, right?  Or am I wrong in that assumption?

[BeautifulShy]

Edit:Looking over the votes of day 2 and the results today show that anybody that voted in day 2 didn't have the bonethief in them.Since the results are the same as what happened in the day 2 vote.
On day 1 there was 3 votes for thatguy however in the results in day 2 show that there was only 2 votes for him.Using Day 2 as a judge of possible bone thief victims that means that anybody that voted do not have the bone thief in them.I'm going to complile a list of possible bone thief victims in a little while.

 
Unless the bone thief chose not to subvert the vote...do they have to choose a different person, or can they do it just when it suits their purpose?

Well the bonethief can't bust out of someone. The bonethief  have to be inside the person until the defender use their ability on whoever has been infected. So if the bonethief is in somebody they can only control that person as far as votes go.

I'm sorry; I think I stated my question poorly.  To clarify, does the bonethief necessarily have to vote for a different person that the person it's infected?  It could have chosen not to vote differently in order to throw people off, right?  Or am I wrong in that assumption?

Oh I see now. That is a good question. I am guessing that the bonethief can choose the way they want to vote even if it is the same as the infected person.

I'm not entirely sure so whenever Stratos gets back it would be best to ask him.

[BeautifulShy]

Okay for now I am going to vote Nickmitch
He has been active on the forum but not much in the main mafia forums. Also PMed him earlier today and he hasn't gotten back to me dispite being online since I sent it.Also he has been hidden.

[that Baby guy]

Actually, I'm going to go along with that vote.  Nickmitch came in on day one, supported me, often an influential player, at least, and then went and disappeared.  It's like it was almost a manufactured appearance to make it look like he wasn't doing his traditional mafia style of play, in a sense.

When he was on Maxi's suspicious list, that added to my suspicion. His lack of appearance yesterday added a little more. vote nickmitch

[nickmitch]

Sorry, guys. My Internet has been really bad lately, so I haven't really been online. Whenever Maxi saw me online, it was probably because I had the forums up when I opened my computer to do some homework.
I promise I'm not mafia. Last time Maxi did this, I was innocent. He's making a mistake again.

[NWR_insanolord]

Nickmitch is always quiet in Mafia. Like, every single time. Do we have anything more than that to go on?

[BeautifulShy]

Nickmitch check your PMs!

Normally Nickmitch doesn't even show up for day 1 yet he has been posting since day 1. Something forced him to change his behavior.

[vudu]

Normally Nickmitch doesn't even show up for day 1 yet he has been posting since day 1. Something forced him to change his behavior.

Something like ... BEING THE KILLER!  DUN-DUN-DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN!!!!!! 

[apdude]

Normally Nickmitch doesn't even show up for day 1 yet he has been posting since day 1. Something forced him to change his behavior.

Something like ... BEING THE KILLER!  DUN-DUN-DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN!!!!!! 

If he is the killer he was so quite he forgot to kill.

[BeautifulShy]

Normally Nickmitch doesn't even show up for day 1 yet he has been posting since day 1. Something forced him to change his behavior.

Something like ... BEING THE KILLER!  DUN-DUN-DUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUUN!!!!!! 

If he is the killer he was so quite he forgot to kill.

There is the possiblity that the killer was blocked.2 roles in the game can prevent kills.

[apdude]

There is the possiblity that the killer was blocked.2 roles in the game can prevent kills.

Did we ever get confirmation that the killer was blocked?  Will we? It would be nice to know if he/she went into hidding.

Edit:  Sorry for the double post I guess Maxi already asked this earlier.

If the killer was blocked I'm going to vote Mop It Up

[nickmitch]

Nickmitch check your PMs!

Normally Nickmitch doesn't even show up for day 1 yet he has been posting since day 1. Something forced him to change his behavior.

Gee, I wonder what could've prompted me to change my behavior? Maybe the fact that no matter what I do I'm being suspicious? Because if I don't post day 1, I'm mafia. But if I do, I'm still mafia! You need to find some better clues to work on than that because it's steered to wrong many times before.

Also, I read your PM, and I'm telling you now, I'm a townie.

[Stratos]

I was planning to not say anything about it and let people guess. It could have been blocked like some are saying. He could have chosen to not hit again. Lots of things could have happened.

[BeautifulShy]

That wasn't what I asked Nickmitch in the PM.

[vudu]

VOTE PLUGABUGZ

He's too quiet.  He may be hiding something.

[Sundoulos]

Stevey has been pretty quiet, too.
For now, I'll vote Plugabugz.  I may change this.

[apdude]

I was planning to not say anything about it and let people guess. It could have been blocked like some are saying. He could have chosen to not hit again. Lots of things could have happened.

So your saying it's a "He"?!
 

[that Baby guy]

So it's tied now, which means the bonethief could easily control the outcome.  We need two more votes in either direction before the end of the day.

[apdude]

Since were not getting the killer information I guess I'll have to vote for another...
 
I'll follow Maxi's lead
 
Vote thatguy
 
...hope your right

[that Baby guy]

Hey guys, I just wanted to give a heads up.  I'm next on the voting queue.  If you're voting strictly with Maxi, vote for me tomorrow, unless he changes his mind.

[BeautifulShy]

Have a nice afterlife thatguy.

unvote thatguy

God so indecive this game.

Here is my reasoning.I believe the save on day 1 of thatguy was because of the Mafia saving him.I also believe that he would vote for jrlibrarian to look like a townie.I emplore you to vote for thatguy.

[that Baby guy]

You do know it's not the next day, right?

And, like I said, Khush explicitly said he was going to save me on Day 1.  If anything the evidence should point that I directly killed Khush as a result of that action.

I voted for jrlibrarian because it was pretty clear you knew he was mafia.  There was no reason to vote for anyone else.

Not that I'm saying I've done anything that hasn't made me look like a townie.  I don't know who has, aside from you and Toruresu, who voted for jrlibrarian even before you did yesterday.  But that's because your townie alliance hasn't exactly been able to motivate voters as much as you might like, isn't it?

[BeautifulShy]

I changed my mind.

Check earlier post.

[that Baby guy]

If the mafia were smart, though, they'd leave their votes as they are right now, then move a vote towards me after the end of the day, making it look like they tried to get me killed.  That's just a recommendation, of course.

[vudu]

Well, we don't want that to happen because I still haven't bothered to read the rules of this game and I'm not about to start now.

VOTE THATGUY

[Sundoulos]

I don't like how personal the threads have been the last couple of days. 

But, in this case, I think I will  VOTE THATGUY.

[that Baby guy]

Funny, the two fellows who wouldn't go along with the nickmitch vote are now jumping away from voting plugabugz for no reason, and are now, both simultaneously, just like yesterday, voting for me.  Weird.

Not that it matters.  If there's not enough people voting today to vote out an actual mafia member, then the numbers game gets even worse tomorrow, unless the killer kills a mafia member, or something.

[Plugabugz]

I have to go to sleep in 20 minutes but vote thatguy.

[NWR_insanolord]

I'm confused. When does this day end and why is everyone voting for thatguy?

[vudu]

I'm confused.

Aren't we all?

When does this day end

Nobody knows except for Stratos.

and why is everyone voting for thatguy?

Because Maxi told us to.

[BeautifulShy]

Stratos never posted it in the first post but if we go by what it says in the signup thread it is suppose to be Noon since today is a weekday. The votes before noon were 3 for Nickmitch and 2 for Plugabugz.


Now I am telling everybody to change to Nickmitch.

[apdude]

I'm going based on Maxi's "called shot" yesterday, though I'm hesitant since he was saved the firstday, but I still don't know all the nuances just yet.  I just figure whatever we do it should be decisive so that the Mafia can't influence it to favor themselves.

[NWR_insanolord]

Mafia's not really that fun if everyone's just going to vote for whoever Maxi tells them to vote for.

[that Baby guy]

To be fair, I told Maxi to vote for nickmitch.

[BeautifulShy]

Mafia's not really that fun if everyone's just going to vote for whoever Maxi tells them to vote for.

I don't see anybody else making suggestions.

[vudu]

Mafia's not really that fun if everyone's just going to vote for whoever Maxi tells them to vote for.

On one hand, Maxi's the only "confirmed" townie.  On the other hand, based on what he told us, he doesn't have any solid information besides what he already told us about jrlibrarian so whatever he says is pure speculation.

Regardless, like Maxi already said, I don't see anyone else coming up with a better plan.

I trust thatguy about as far as I can throw him.

[NWR_insanolord]

Also PMed him earlier today and he hasn't gotten back to me dispite being online since I sent it.Also he has been hidden.

Okay, this is getting really annoying. I propose we all set ourselves to hidden next game to take away Maxi's ability to stalk the Who's Online page.

Mafia's not really that fun if everyone's just going to vote for whoever Maxi tells them to vote for.l

On one hand, Maxi's the only "confirmed" townie.  On the other hand, based on what he told us, he doesn't have any solid information besides what he already told us about jrlibrarian so whatever he says is pure speculation.

Regardless, like Maxi already said, I don't see anyone else coming up with a better plan.

I trust thatguy about as far as I can throw him.

I guess, but I think that's the problem. If no one except Maxi is thinking about this, then we're screwed; it'll be easy for the mafia to pick us apart.

[that Baby guy]

Hey, look!  Vudu and I are score opposites!

[BeautifulShy]

Also PMed him earlier today and he hasn't gotten back to me dispite being online since I sent it.Also he has been hidden.

Okay, this is getting really annoying. I propose we all set ourselves to hidden next game to take away Maxi's ability to stalk the Who's Online page.

It was stalking the whos online page that got me to go after jrlibrarian.The results were good.

[that Baby guy]

Hey, look!  Vudu and I are score opposites!

Nevermind.

[Sundoulos]

Fine.  Last Time.  I VOTE NICKMITCH.

[NWR_insanolord]

Also PMed him earlier today and he hasn't gotten back to me dispite being online since I sent it.Also he has been hidden.

Okay, this is getting really annoying. I propose we all set ourselves to hidden next game to take away Maxi's ability to stalk the Who's Online page.

It was stalking the whos online page that got me to go after jrlibrarian.The results were good.

The end cannot justify the means.

[apdude]

Since were not getting the killer information I guess I'll have to vote for another...
 
I'll follow Maxi's lead
 
Vote thatguy

...hope your right

Just realized I'm undecided now.
 
Vote Nickmitch
 
Still undecided...

[Mop it up]

Vote Nickmitch

Just dropping this here real fast in case the thread closes soon. I'll read over the recent posts and see what's been going on.

[vudu]

I guess, but I think that's the problem. If no one except Maxi is thinking about this, then we're screwed; it'll be easy for the mafia to pick us apart.

I fully admit to not paying enough attention to this game.  I'm been busy with other things so I haven't even read the rules yet (although I think I've pieced most of them together just from people talking in the threads).  I hope to have some time tomorrow to try to figure things out.

You have to admit it's hard to get excited about them game when the host doesn't even seem to care.

[Toruresu]

VOTE NICKMITCH

In before the closing of thread.

[Sundoulos]

Vote Nickmitch

Just dropping this here real fast in case the thread closes soon. I'll read over the recent posts and see what's been going on.

Good luck.    It's sort of frustrating.

[apdude]

I trust thatguy about as far as I can throw him.

We need a picture of vudu's avatar holding a gamecube above his head!

[Mop it up]

lol I can only imagine what must be going through your head since this is your first game.

Anyways, after reading the thread I think the Nickmitch vote could be a mistake. But with Stratos online now, there's no time to switch my vote and explain to everyone the reason. Things are looking grim now, but there's nothing I can do.

[Stratos]

I'm sorry. It seems that all things that could go wrong in real life did once this game started and I am constantly getting pulled away from it.

Work issues, relationship issues, family issues, car issues, sleep issues. It's like once I started the game an assault on my sanity occurred. I'm doing my best in light of it but it is taking it's toll on the game. A thousand apologies to all players.

Also, if I have not locked the thread then it is fair game to keep playing and change votes and such unless one of the other mods jump in and locks it for me (not opposed to that either).

Though I am just going to pretend the sporadic locks are a 'gameplay element' to mimic sanity effects on the players.

Tally:
Nickmitch-6
Thatguy-2