So, day 1, I messaged a few people saying I was investigator, seeing what I could find. I investigate TOPHATANT, who is this townie. Day 2, stevey. No luck there, as he was killed.
I'm at work, so I'm not going to go through the logs, but I believe it was day 3 where things went sour. I sent a message to Lucario to investigate BeautifulShy, and don't hear anything back for a bit. I take things into my own hand, and message her. Eventually, she confesses she's the killer and has been working with Khushrenada.
I changed my investigation, since I still didn't have an answer back, to Mop it up. I got a one word response of "townie" after this.
I start putting pieces together in my mind. Khushrenada has claimed a role that's not in the rules thread, BShy and Khush are working together, a missed hit on Day 2, and a large number of townie results in investigations. In my mind, it's likely that TOPHATANT is the godfather, as he was absent on Day 2 and there was no mafia hit. Khushrenada is likely working as a liason to the killer from the mafia, and I encourage BShy to make a hit that isn't disclosed to Khush up front. We kill TOPHATANT, and though he's a townie, it looks like Mop it up was suspicious. But due to the dual hit on nickmitch, I had more evidence of mafia/killer collusion via Khush, as my interference appeared to have an effect.
I asked Lucario if there were any hidden roles or if there was a hostess role, to which he says "No."
And so it's time to vote out Khush. At the same time, I'm confident Mop it up must be the godfather, and so I spread around various messages.
The last day I'm alive, I sent out messages to a few players left saying I've investigated everyone else, and that these players left had to have roles by process of elimination. This was a small trick. There was room for one more townie. One of these players had to be a goon, and one had to be the double voter. The goal was for one of those players to confront me and say I was mistaken because they had no role. If someone would do that, it would have narrowed the goon hunt down. It didn't work.
Anyway, I sent out a lot of information to the lot of players this game. I just assumed at the end of each day, I'd be hit, and so I didn't sit on the information I had. Some of the information I provided to some players wasn't entirely true, for example, I told Khush Mop it up claimed to be the double voter, and that never happened, to play off reactions, but it didn't pan out.
For the record, I really believed that BeautifulShy and Khush were going to keep their end of the deal. It's too bad they didn't. I would have liked to see how that would work.