Topic: Day 5: PONG Mafia XXXVIII

[NWR_DrewMG]

The fourth night, as GoldenPhoenix, the sheriff was snooping around her nightly investigation target, she saw the authorities dragging away oohhboy, the recently voted out mafia godfather.  She'd suspected he'd been godfather all along, but what she could never have expected was that he had one more trick up his sleeve.  He escaped from his captors just long enough to reflect an incoming square white ball directly at her.  She was shocked, she didn't have time to move.  Oohhboy got one last target in before being locked up away forever.

Results from Day 4:
Death by Vote: oohhboy ("Godfather" Black Paddle)
Death by Hit: GoldenPhoenix ("Sheriff" Blue Paddle)

PONGERS
Mop_It_Up
UncleBob
stevey
nickmitch
Decoyman
vudu
Kashogi Y. Stogi
DAaaMan64
NuclearSpeed
Stratos

Voting for Day 5 ends this evening at 11 PM CST. 

No players are at risk of being eliminated for inactivity today.

[Stogi]

**** YES!

VOTE STEVEY

[nickmitch]

Stevey was throwing suspecion on thatguy before we voted him out, so did UB.  With oohhboy dead, that only leaves one person who voted yesterday against the godfather: nuclearspeed.  I'll give him a chance to defend himself.

[Stogi]

Let's recap.

There are two mafia players left. Four people voted for Stratos. There's a damn good chance that both mafia players voted for Stratos. That leaves these people as potential mafia:

UB
Stevey
OoohBoy
NuclearSpeed

We already know Ooohboy is mafia. So again, anyone that votes with him is most likely mafia as well.

Now day 3, Stevey and Nuclearspeed voted for Vude with Oohboy. UB voted for stratos. Because of that subtle difference, UB is most likely a townie. This leaves both Stevey and Nuclearspeed with the most potential of being mafia players.

I don't care who we end up voting for, but let's make sure to do it in unison.

[vudu]

Why is GP dead?  When the godfather is voted out during the day they typically lose their hit that night.

Also, **** you stevey--don't ever question me again. 

[Stogi]

That's true. DrewMG, can we get a little explanation of the rules?

[NWR_DrewMG]

That's true. DrewMG, can we get a little explanation of the rules?

Fair enough.  I actually wasn't aware that this was a standard rule.  I'll keep that in mind for future games that I run, but given that I've already written the rules, and they don't explicitly state that the mafia loses their hit when the godfather is voted out, I'm going to have to keep her as dead for now. 

Sorry, if I had known that was a pretty standard rule then I would have made a call on it BEFORE it mattered.  Chalk it up to the fact that this is only the second game I've run.

Also, I've already revealed GP's role, so I couldn't let her back into the game even if I wanted to.  It would be an unfair advantage to the mafia to identify who the sheriff is. 

But as I indicated earlier, I will eat crow here and say that I was wrong, I should have thought about this earlier.  I hope it doesn't end up being the difference-maker in this game.

[Stratos]

Doctor, I am kinda torqued that you didn't defend GP. Just want to say that.

I agree with the thoughts so far about suspects. Hopefully, UncleBob now believes that I am townie since I led the charge against Oohhboy. It turned out better than I thought as we caught the godfather. But, UncleBob, I PM'd you on Friday putting forward my defense and  younever even responded to me. If you don't say something now, I'm going to accuse you of being mafia.

But right now, I am voting for Stevey since I agreed to do that yesterday with some other players if they agreed to join the Oohhboy vote.

I need to clarify something with Drew before I say it here but I will comment on the other suspect you mentioned later today.

[vudu]

I also am going to VOTE STEVEY although I'm not as sure about this vote as I was about the previous two.

Stevey has fought us on both votes.  He could very well be mafia or he could just be difficult.  It's really hard to say.

[NuclearSpeed]

Well going with what I said yesterday with my vote, stevey, at least to me, was proven wrong in the vote against oohhboy, and since I can't vote for oohhboy today than I must go with my other choice and vote stevey

[Mop it up]

Lots of confusion today it looks like.

I'm going to Vote Stevey just so no other bandwagons can start up.

[stevey]

The mafia and townies suck, You think they would try to save their own especially on a tight vote this late...

I'm  a townie but I know when I'm fucked, vote stevey

I hope orange wins, he the only one who deserves it....

[UncleBob]

On one hand, I agree with Stratos, the Doctor should have voted to save GP.  On the other hand, GP's story did look like it could be slightly concocted.

Roled members need to be doing a better job reaching out

I still think there's a good chance Stratos is mafia - but I also like Strogi's Nuclearspeed theory...

[stevey]

Also, **** you stevey--don't ever question me again. 

screw it, I don't want to die yet.

[vote]vudu[/vote]

**** YES!

VOTE STEVEY

Just cause I'm proven dead wrong again you instantly start a bandwagon. Do I smell panic?

Also, I've already revealed GP's role, so I couldn't let her back into the game even if I wanted to.  It would be an unfair advantage to the mafia to identify who the sheriff is. 

But as I indicated earlier, I will eat crow here and say that I was wrong, I should have thought about this earlier.  I hope it doesn't end up being the difference-maker in this game.

How about saving the life of the next townie voted out to make up for it?

[NWR_DrewMG]

How about saving the life of the next townie voted out to make up for it?

That's a bit extreme.  I've already made a ruling on the questionable call.

[stevey]

How about saving the life of the next townie voted out to make up for it?

That's a bit extreme.  I've already made a ruling on the questionable call.

It just one tiny unroled townie. Nothing for the big bad mafia to fear...

Let's recap.

There are two mafia players left. Four people voted for Stratos. There's a damn good chance that both mafia players voted for Stratos. That leaves these people as potential mafia:

UB
Stevey
OoohBoy
NuclearSpeed

We already know Ooohboy is mafia. So again, anyone that votes with him is most likely mafia as well.

Now day 3, Stevey and Nuclearspeed voted for Vude with Oohboy. UB voted for stratos. Because of that subtle difference, UB is most likely a townie. This leaves both Stevey and Nuclearspeed with the most potential of being mafia players.

I don't care who we end up voting for, but let's make sure to do it in unison.

Horrible 20/20 logic, how was I supposed to know that; I lead the bandwagon to kill Thatguy. I outed him as red on DAY ONE and kept at it!
The mafia clearly is using hasty logic to sweep the townie to destruction.

[Stogi]

Your voting record tells all.

[stevey]

What? Khush is always mafia! It's stupid to vote for a townie who you are going to kill that night. Maxi was too quite. Vudu is and still will be evil. ThatGuy was red.

[Stogi]

You have motivation to NOT change. Even after a townie alliance was formed, you ignored it. Your either an outcast or mafia. It'll be decided tonight.

[stevey]

Ashley's broom can't possible be evil. All it ever did was send some kids to hell, once...

Even after a townie alliance was formed

Hmm.... If I remember it right, it was run by Thatguy; who killed off his first pathetically worthless followers, maxi and khush, so everyone think he is townie who the mafia is after. Which cause green and blue to fall into the mafia trap leading to their early deaths. God I such an idiot. I should have never point out how suspicious that was and got Thatguy voted. And I should have help you in tell everyone else with a role to pm you and thatguy, oh so trust-able ones.

[Stogi]

You keep referencing that your the one to start the domino effect. The fact remains, you DIDN'T VOTE FOR THEM.

I'm done arguing.

[stevey]

You keep referencing that your the one to start the domino effect. The fact remains, you DIDN'T VOTE FOR THEM.

I'm done arguing.

History says otherwise

Stevey and UB both thatguy on their lists. so vote thatguy.

I voted for thatguy on day 1. I called out thatguy as red on day one and I can still be right about vudu being clear.

You on the other hand waited to the last hour to vote thatguy....

[stevey]

Last words:

My Gut is telling me that vudu and stratos are mafia
Brain is saying UB and stogi are mafia

Let see who is right....

[NWR_DrewMG]

Voting is over.  Seeya tomorrow morning.

Here's the voting as I see it:

Stevey - 5
Vudu - 1