I don't have it but my friend does and I played it at his house. Eh, it's a sequel to Wii Sports. If you liked Wii Sports you'll like this game. If you're not into the Wii Series, this won't convert you.
To me these Wii Series games are like if Super Mario 64 was JUST the castle and you could run around it and that's it. Make fun from that. Or if they let you do all the sword fighting and bomb throwing in Skyward Sword but didn't put a quest around it. Like you just get some obstacle course to do all this stuff but no "game" to make use of it. I need them to take that next step where I actually DO something with the gameplay mechanic.
I think it's simply that these games are for a certain level of player and I passed that level at least 20 years ago, so I'm just BORED. I can get like a weekend out of this stuff at best. If Zelda is like a fantasy novel THIS is like reading an instruction manual. It's probably the best Wii Series game though and I imagine it would be like Super Mario Bros. 3 to anyone who was introduced to videogames by Wii Sports.
While I get what you're saying, Ian, I can't help but disagree with your overall point here.
Some people like to shoot baskets without playing a full match. Some people like to practice archery without realizing they're using weapons. I'm sure when you were younger you use to have hours of fun making up your own silly games with friends or family where rules didn't matter and it boiled down to you just running from point a to point b without a single purpose other than to entertain yourself.
I know two things about you Ian: You like music, and you like hockey. Right?
I promise you that any of your favorite musicians and any of your favorite players can enjoy the experience just the same if they were: jamming with buddies without producers, without worrying about recording, and not even playing in key - or having an informal match in the driveway at home with no gear, announcers, or fans.
You say you're BORED? What makes you think you're better than any of those professionals who can still have fun within their respective roles?
At the end of the day these are all GAMES, and whether your end result is completing a dungeon or beating your personal high score, it's just a form of entertainment to be enjoyed. If you can't see that than I honestly feel bad for you, because life must of hit you really hard. I say next time you feel the urge to spout negative nonsense about a video game that never did anything to hurt you, just leave the computer and pretend every other tile is hot lava and make your own unique path away from the desk. Or you go outside, take a deep breath, and jump in some leaves, splash in a puddle, or just dig up some worms from the dirt.
BUT.. that's your opinion, man. My opinion is that your opinion could of easily stopped at "this isn't really a game for me" because no matter how big your tv is, no matter what the resolution, the frame rate, the pixel count, etc.. you [and the rest of us here] are nothing more than overgrown children playing with toys. The difference is an adult can realize a game is a game and can enjoy it for whatever it may be, but a child is to obsessed trying to prove themselves as older/more mature that they make up a rules and structures that need to be upheld to their supposed standards and think that any thing but is beneath them.
pre-edit: I actually feel bad being so condescending, when I could of just stopped at my first sentence and gotten my point across and fits my general posting personality.. but the words just came to me.