Community Forums > NWR Mafia Games
Mafia 74: The NWR Gameshow Day 7: Cancelled/ Endgame
Khushrenada:
--- Quote from: Mop it up on June 11, 2017, 03:07:42 AM ---Trust me, my only goal was to make sure Khushrenada didn't win.
FFFFFFOOOOOCCCCUUUSSS BBBLLLAAAAAASSSSTTTTT!!!!!!!
--- End quote ---
Back to BeautifulShy for a moment: "I will keep that in mind Mop_it_up for next time."
--- Quote from: Mop it up on June 11, 2017, 03:14:56 AM ---Yeah, because he had an invincible role that nobody knew about.
--- End quote ---
Not quite invincible. Here's what Lucario told me in a pm when he sent me news of the role:
HEYO
Yore gonig to be playing acting as Bshy.
Your role is the "hostess" aka u can save one person once. you wont be told who though, so you'll have to use your own wit. and if you pick wrong? too bad.
I later asked him if that person could be me since he didn't say otherwise and he said sure. So, it was a one-time protection. At first I thought it was great because I had this secret protection for myself that no one knew about it since Lucario forgot to list it in the Day 1 thread. I thought I might need it to save myself from a hit early on. But then I made a deal with BS to reveal roles since I had a feeling she had one and learned she was the killer. Thatguy just sort of came along and told me he was the detective so I was thinking things were going to go along pretty smoothly in this mafia game and we'd be rolling.
Unfortunately, the partnership came undone in Day 4. There was frustration at not finding any mafia members (although I had been recommending a Stratos vote or killer hit of him Day 3) and when Thatguy asked Lucario if there was a hostess role, he said no or something along those lines so Thatguy and BS thought I was messing with them and was mafia. I couldn't get them to listen to reason and that this was Lucario hosting. So, as a last ditch effort, I sent a pm asking Lucario if I could use my ability to save myself in the vote since the role message was unclear how the power worked (and for added appeal, I mentioned that I was in this situation because he told people I didn't have this role). If that didn't work, I was seriously thinking about protecting Stratos in an effort to get revenge on Thatguy and BS for kind of ditching me but decided to protect BS because she'd probably take a betrayal at that point pretty seriously and not work with me again in a future game.
As it was, Lucario did save me but then I kind of regretted it as the game limped on to this messed up ending. With thatguy's compromised investigation results, it really buggered things up in figuring out who the mafia was. I didn't try and elaborate on my ability to make people wary of voting or hitting me after that but I was vulnerable after that. The only person who knew was BeShy because she was running scenarios of how to vote or hit and some involved me blocking a hit. Most abilities in this game only had 1 use but I wanted to let people think I was a sort of doctor with unlimited protections. Shame since it seems that bluff cost me the game. Thanks Mop.
that Baby guy:
So, day 1, I messaged a few people saying I was investigator, seeing what I could find. I investigate TOPHATANT, who is this townie. Day 2, stevey. No luck there, as he was killed.
I'm at work, so I'm not going to go through the logs, but I believe it was day 3 where things went sour. I sent a message to Lucario to investigate BeautifulShy, and don't hear anything back for a bit. I take things into my own hand, and message her. Eventually, she confesses she's the killer and has been working with Khushrenada.
I changed my investigation, since I still didn't have an answer back, to Mop it up. I got a one word response of "townie" after this.
I start putting pieces together in my mind. Khushrenada has claimed a role that's not in the rules thread, BShy and Khush are working together, a missed hit on Day 2, and a large number of townie results in investigations. In my mind, it's likely that TOPHATANT is the godfather, as he was absent on Day 2 and there was no mafia hit. Khushrenada is likely working as a liason to the killer from the mafia, and I encourage BShy to make a hit that isn't disclosed to Khush up front. We kill TOPHATANT, and though he's a townie, it looks like Mop it up was suspicious. But due to the dual hit on nickmitch, I had more evidence of mafia/killer collusion via Khush, as my interference appeared to have an effect.
I asked Lucario if there were any hidden roles or if there was a hostess role, to which he says "No."
And so it's time to vote out Khush. At the same time, I'm confident Mop it up must be the godfather, and so I spread around various messages.
The last day I'm alive, I sent out messages to a few players left saying I've investigated everyone else, and that these players left had to have roles by process of elimination. This was a small trick. There was room for one more townie. One of these players had to be a goon, and one had to be the double voter. The goal was for one of those players to confront me and say I was mistaken because they had no role. If someone would do that, it would have narrowed the goon hunt down. It didn't work.
Anyway, I sent out a lot of information to the lot of players this game. I just assumed at the end of each day, I'd be hit, and so I didn't sit on the information I had. Some of the information I provided to some players wasn't entirely true, for example, I told Khush Mop it up claimed to be the double voter, and that never happened, to play off reactions, but it didn't pan out.
For the record, I really believed that BeautifulShy and Khush were going to keep their end of the deal. It's too bad they didn't. I would have liked to see how that would work.
Silenced:
I forgot this game existed and didn't really care in the end
BeautifulShy:
Okay so a few things. There wasn't a kill the first night because lucario didn't get back to me on how much time was left before starting day 2. I was a little miffed about that. So I had the idea of sending my kills in advance on the second day going forward. I basically put everyone on my hit list in a certain order with instructions to kill the next one in line if they were voted out but I was planning on staying online unlike Khush that fast food game. Silenced was 2nd on my list and I was going to ask lucario if I could do something like this and never got word. So with Khush and thatguy in my ears I was going back and forth which I admit was not their fault but mine on my choice of hits. So I told Khush a list of 4 different players who I might kill and stevey was one of them. So I sent in a kill of stevey. I don't think I heard from thatguy that day on who he was going to search so it was just bad luck that thatguy searched stevey and I killed him. So the next day I am getting irritated and I was going to start to do my own hits and so we get the nickmitch double kill. Thatguy says since I killed someone without Khush or thatguy in instruction that meant that the days previous that my kills were being guided so I think we voted out Khush the next day because of leading my kill and a unknown role not listed in the day 1 thread. So we got out Khush and I guess Khush. told lucario to either protect me or if was possible to revive Khush from being voted out and Khush revives. Next day I think we. Voted out stratos and I killed pokepal think him
a goon but no was a townie. So silenced had to be the goon. So yesterday was a day of mind games, roleplaying and endless confusion because the host was trolling us.
BeautifulShy:
This is the kill list that I had after I didn't send in a kill the 1st night.
--- Quote ---Quote from: BeautifulShy on June 06, 2017, 03:24:36 AM
Okay Lucario I figure I should send in my hits in advance.
Okay so for my hits I want you to do the hits in this order.
Tophat, silenced, stevey, Nickmitch, Insanolord, Stratos, Stevey, lolmonade, mop it up, thatguy and then finally Khushrenada.
So basically I want you to go down the line and kill that person in that order. If someone is killed and they are next on my list then I want you to go to the next one. Same with vote outs. If say tophat is voted out today you go and kill silenced. Understand?
--- End quote ---
This was my original hit list that I had before I decided to just send in kills each night. I guess I had stevey in there twice for some reason and left out pokepal. Looks like just going by the days and how they unfolded I would of killed Silenced and Stratos by the end of the 3rd day. Mop it up would of come later.