Community Forums > NWR Forums Discord
MAFIA III: Operation Revolucion! (Ninjas vs Pirates)
<< < (8/10) > >>
Infernal Monkey:
Everyone will walk the plank, while being shot at.
Toruresu:

Quote
Originally posted by: UncleBob
Well, damn, there's a Ninja Pirate.  We're all screwed now.

Seriously, a few questions...

The Attoney/Judge positions - these could possibly go to a Mafia member or whomever?  This seems... icky to me - giving the Mafias more potential for power.  But it could be interesting.
--- End quote ---


Definately, but, if I understood correctly, the roles aren't public, so we could end up voting the Judge/Attorney by mistake, right? Wouldn't this affect the game balance? Unless townies knew who the judge/attorney are at all times, that way if a pirate king of ninja master gets to be the judge, we could vote him out (we would need to find out first). <-- Am I making sense?
Pryopizm:

Quote
Originally posted by: Toruresu

Quote
Originally posted by: UncleBob
Well, damn, there's a Ninja Pirate.  We're all screwed now.

Seriously, a few questions...

The Attoney/Judge positions - these could possibly go to a Mafia member or whomever?  This seems... icky to me - giving the Mafias more potential for power.  But it could be interesting.
--- End quote ---


Definately, but, if I understood correctly, the roles aren't public, so we could end up voting the Judge/Attorney by mistake, right? Wouldn't this affect the game balance? Unless townies knew who the judge/attorney are at all times, that way if a pirate king of ninja master gets to be the judge, we could vote him out (we would need to find out first). <-- Am I making sense?
--- End quote ---



Alright, here's the balance.  And I've added this to the official rules.  Anyone who is voted is protected by any kind of hit.  In the unlikely event that a Pirate or Ninja should get both Phoenix and Judge roles, that is their reward.  But, they are only protected when the townsfolk vote for them.  There are three other people trying to kill him.  On any given night that he is not on the docket, he is not protected.  

The Judge and Phoenix roles MUST be kept confidential.  Pirates and Ninjas would literally kill for that role.

Keep in mind, when there are FIVE or Fewer players left, the Court will be dissolved.
UncleBob:
Does the Judge/Attoney know who each other is?
ShyGuy:
hmm interesting. If you had the judge in your pocket, you could actually protect yourself from being murdered that night by getting everyone to vote for you.
Navigation
Message Index
Next page
Previous page

Go to full version