Mafia II: Dead Like Me

Community Forums > NWR Forums Discord

<< < (23/28) > >>

Mario:
Alright... I was going to do a huge Wandering style post but my MSN chat logs are all screwed up and only half of them were saved, and the ones that are saved are HUGE and have too much crap in them. I'll try and make it brief based on what I remember

Actually.. screw it, this is WAY too long. Next time i'll put short notes down as I play to make it easier.

Also I thought Wandering was the Vigilante until just before Degs death.

animecyberrat:
Well I will say this, I read the first PM I got saying who mafia were and the only name I recognized was IceCold so I purposfully chose not to say anything about him. A few days go byu we start the game and I see wandering acting funny so I vote for him just to be different because NOBODY in my mafia tells me anything. They had been communicating alot before they ever get to me and since I noticed NOONE Pmd me AT ALL and VUDU kepts complaining about that I chose rigth away to start voting them out, because THEY betrayed me and I betrayed them. I told them I didnt knwo what wa goign on at tehs ame tiem I was telling someone else ,he can confess if he wants, that I was going to make adeal with him if he got Wanderig killed.

I made my plan after day 1 and I realized noboy was communicating with me OR even responding to my posts, so I CHOSE to start namiung peoplel uin mymafia, except ICe COld, and then I picked names like Stevey cuz he votes for me, and Mario because I was suspicious of him. to try and make it look like I wasnt targeting anybody. I only "voice emailed" vudu in the game because I didnt liek his tone in our Pms and was trying to get him to back off.

At first I had peopel asking me what role I was and Id idnt respond with anything except quotes from Star Wars, which the first couple ones I actauly got response back as if they didnt recognise the quotes that was good for a laugh.

Then ____emaild me saying he didnt want to PM anymore for fear of getting found out and we sealed our deal. I told him who all our mafia were and he agreed to vote wandering.

vudu:

Quote
Originally posted by: Mario
Wow, I just noticed how hilarious vudus posts in the first thread are. He makes the first vote, because being the rat he knows what side everyone is on, then he jokingly says in another post "I know everything.". He then complains about being out of the loop. LOL
--- End quote ---
If you go back and read Wandering's and my arguments in the day 3 and 4 threads they're pretty amusing.

And yeah, I pretty much knew who everyone was at the start. I was 99% sure TVman was either the cop or the Vigilante because he survived the first round (as did Pale and IceCold). One Ty was revealed to be a ???????--which I assumed to be the Captain--(later turning out to be a Freemason) I figured Deg was the vigilante. Once I found out Ty wasn't the Captain I figured it was either Deg or Mario; the other being the Vigilante.

Next time we play Pryo needs to assign roles at random. I realize that the game would kind of be screwed up if you gave the part of the Rat to Kirby or anything important to AnimeCyberRat (sorry, but I call it as I see it), but it made it real easy for me to figure out who was who.

Also, I'd like to take this opportunity to state that the Captain breaks the game, not the Rat. If the Captain lost his power to bring a person back after he died it would be one thing. But since he can use it at any time, it screws over the mafia big time, especially the Rat. If one Mafia completely dies and the other loses a single member the Captain can bring back that member and win the game. If one Mafia loses all its members except the Rat and the other mafia loses a single member the Captain can bring back that member and win the game. If the Rat dies the Captain can bring back the Rat and win the game. It makes it nearly impossible for the Mafia to win unless the Captain is a sadist and brings back someone as a Mafia member.

If we ever play with the Captain again, he should be forced to use his powers before he dies. This way he has to blance out bringing someone back now with waiting until later but risk dying first. This is the same problem the cop faces as far as spilling the beans as to what he knows or risk dying and taking the info he knows to the grave.

The biggest reason I lost was (A) I couldn't get rid of Wandering and (B) for some reason no one ever voted for BlackNMild or MysticGohan. I couldn't kill them myself so I needed someone to vote one of them off. Once that happened, I'd be able to kill off the second one as a Godfather once the Captain brought back someone.

Also--and I'm not blaming Pryo (although it is his fault)--but I could have won the game if he closed the polls when he said he would. He was over an hour late. If the polls closed on time Wandering would have been voted off, and I would have been able to kill BlackNMild or MysticGohan that night (hopefully getting ShyGuy to kill the other).

Bill Aurion:
But since he can use it at any time, it screws over the mafia big time, especially the Rat. If one Mafia completely dies and the other loses a single member the Captain can bring back that member and win the game

That's completely up to the Captain...He could just as easily bring a Mafia back to screw over the townies...

MysticGohan:
I have to agree with Vudu there, Lavender had too much power, it was pointless that he was killed, the only thing was he couldn't vote, but still send someone in his place. so it really didn't matter. Now if he was to be killed and lost that ability, that would be something. Kinda like getting protection from the doc or hooker, but if either dies, someone is screwed and nothing can be done once their dead.

Navigation

 Message Index

Go to full version