I wont start a technical debate. There can really be no debate in the face of hardware fact: the XBOX has the highest graphical potential ofthis console generation.
However, you guys make a good point about some of the Cube's games being absolutely beauiful....Metroid 2, Zelda and especially Resident Evil 4 spring to mind. These fabulous results are the fruits of development know-how and programming sweat. These guys absolutely know the Cube's hardware through and through and the results speak for themselves. So when Itagaki says "this game could not be possible on another system" I think hes right in a way and wrong in a way.
On one hand the sharp visuals of Ninja Gaiden or the textures in Halo 2 just dont seem feasible on the Cube's hardware, strong as it is. For example, a good looking Riddick may be possible, but again could not match the integrity of the XBox version (which of course doesnt bode well at all for the PS2 version...).
HOWEVER, many technical "limitations" usually seem to be worked around by the most talented developers. So in this sense when Itagaki says "not possible", I take it in some cases as "we really dont want to bother learning the hardware", as with DOA3. I have to admit tho, I just want DOA in some form for Cube.
...
....
Uh, at any rate, people are subject to their own opinions about Itagaki and what he says. However, I hope this quote:
Quote
They also don't bother themselves with details like "this game is exactly like something else on the market", or "this game is so frustratingly difficult I'm not having any fun at all". It's good to see Team Ninja isn't worrying themselves with the details.
Quote
isn't alluding to Ninja Gaiden on the XBOX. Its an awfully subjective opinion if it is, of a game that many people enjoy exactly for its refinement of the genre (I think a good number of people wouldn't hesitate to rate it over the likes of Shinobi and even Devil May Cry 1) and its no-frills difficulty. No game of course is ever really for everyone tho, even if they are fans of its genre.
For the record, Devil May Cry made me do just do that, sooooo....
-Blackknight131