Wow, fire in the forums!
People might disagree with their opinions, but it impresses me is that people are passionate enough to argue over the game. That's gotta be a good sign, right?
Personally I liked
Rage of the Gladiator much more than Neal seems to. It isn't the best game ever and didn't exactly fit my expectations going in, but surprised me by being tremendous fun. Is it better than
Punch-Out!! on Wii? No, I don't think so. But it's cheaper and easier to buy, has some great modifications like the skill tree advancements, and definitely isn't lacking in challenge or entertainment value. In fact,
Rage of the Gladiator is clearly my second favorite WiiWare release this year, only outdone by
Cave Story. (Others are more than welcome to disagree with that opinion.)
Also, I want to defend Neal for reviewing the game without finishing it. I have never finished any game in the
Punch-Out!! series because the difficulty and reflexes required to beat high-level bosses simply are too much for me. But I don't think that invalidates my opinions about the games. Of course, it's hard to fairly rate "lastability" when the game hasn't even been finished once... but only if you define that word to mean how long it takes to finish the game instead of how long it takes to lose interest.
Anyway... my point. Did I have one? Oh right! I think that
Rage of the Gladiator is awesome, and was the best 1000 Wii Points I've spent in a long time. Hopefully people interested in a game that takes heavy inspiration from a long-standing classic are willing to give this game a shot. It really deserves to be played.