Show Posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.


Messages - broodwars

Pages: 1 ... 407 408 [409] 410 411 ... 454
10201
NWR Feedback / Forum vs. site discussion
« on: October 06, 2009, 02:14:55 PM »
Man, some of you guys are real ingrates.  Yeah, it is kind of amusing how late these stories can get posted on the front page, but man some of you act like because you were posting on it before that you own the story.

10202
NWR Feedback / Forum vs. site discussion
« on: October 06, 2009, 04:14:02 AM »
As I noted in the original forum thread, I'm not a fan of the Mouse.  I'm more a fan of the Duck and the Goof, and Mickey has worked better in an advisory role (see: Kingdom Hearts and Disney's Philarmagic at Disney World) than as the hero of his own story lately.  I'm going to miss this artwork not being in HD, but it's nice to see a potentially-good game on Wii from Disney.  Here's hoping they don't screw it up.

10203
Nintendo Gaming / Re: Epic Mickey - Wii Exclusive
« on: October 06, 2009, 03:45:56 AM »
Hmm...I'm cautiously optimistic for this game.  I'm a longtime Disney nut, as Walt Disney himself has been a personal idol of mine since childhood (guy who came from nothing and built an empire through sheer determination, blood, and sweat).  The artwork also looks pretty awesome, though I get the feeling I'm going to miss this stuff not being in HD.  Where I am a little miffed about the game (and I know I'm going to be in a minority on this one) is that you play as Mickey Mouse, on of the most thoroughly bland characters ever created.  Yeah, I'm a Donald Duck person (I even own all his Disney Treasures tins).   ;)

And yes, Oswald the Lucky Rabbit being the main villain would be awesome.  You guys do know that Mickey was created in a moment of desperation after Universal bought Walt's animators in secret and took the Oswald characters away from him, right?

10204
General Gaming / Re: 3D Dot Game Heroes = Legend of Zelda?
« on: October 05, 2009, 07:53:45 PM »
I don't understand where people are getting the "parody" from. Perhaps "tribute" is a better word here...

Apparently this game is supposed to be about a 2D world where its king just decided one day would be 3D, so the world is composed of characters and objects made up of blocks to make them look 3D 8-bit.  Apparently the game takes more than a few shots at Dragon Quest and Zelda, and that's where the "parody" aspect is supposed to come in.  When you see a gun running around dodging Tectites; hookshot-ing round poles to cross familiar-looking mountain landscapes; etc. I think the game crosses a line between "homage" and outright plagiarism, though.

10205
General Gaming / Re: Journalism Reform is here!!! Bloggers beware!!
« on: October 05, 2009, 07:37:38 PM »
So, let's say I'm a blogger who lives in Mexico but posts on a site based in the US... do I have to disclose anything?

Now, let's say I'm a blogger who lives in California but posts on a site based in France... do I have to disclose anything?

Or to use a more immediate example, does Greg have to disclose anything when he reviews for this site?  If he doesn't, is the FTC planning on somehow fining him despite him being a UK citizen?  What a laughable concept, like the the FTC has some sort of jurisdiction on the internet.

10206
Podcast Discussion / Re: Radio Free Nintendo: Episode 164
« on: October 05, 2009, 07:04:59 PM »
Wow, that discussion about dreams is just...

wow.

Great show this week, guys.  As far as games permeating your thoughts after hours upon hours of gameplay, I seem to recall this happening back in 99-00 with Snood.  Ugh.  Stupid, stupid snood.

I hope you never have nightmares about the dope fish or playing Mega Man and falling down a deep water level where a freakishly huge octopus pops out of nowhere and attacks you.

That's not a real Mega Man nightmare.  My Mega Man nightmare would be having to climb an endless flight of those fracking vanishing blocks.

10207
I think 10/10 is justified in only the rarest of circumstances, but based on the fact that both the single-player AND multiplayer are supposedly amazing, I can see it with Uncharted 2.  The first game is easily 9/10 for me, and that's with a few flaws and no multiplayer component.

*shrugs*

I played the multiplayer "beta" a few months ago, and honestly I didn't find the multiplayer anything special.  Still, that could be because everyone was voting for the frickin' deathmatch rules instead of the "capture the flag" or "king of the hill"-type rules I prefer.  I'm much more looking forward to the singleplayer experience, especially if they've truly fixed the incredibly poor pacing the first game had where you had to dive behind cover and blast away at a seemingly-endless stream of goons every 5 steps so you never got to take in the atmosphere.

10208
General Gaming / Re: Journalism Reform is here!!! Bloggers beware!!
« on: October 05, 2009, 07:00:03 PM »
I'm curious if these same rules will also apply to "professional journalists", so we get to see what swag reviewers at say IGN or Game Informer received when they reviewed a product.  I'm completely in favor of full disclosure, but if they're going after bloggers on this it had better apply to everyone regardless of "professional" status.

10209
Podcast Discussion / Re: Radio Free Nintendo: Episode 164
« on: October 05, 2009, 02:34:08 PM »
Man, that whole routine of getting stuck on a puzzle/challenge and not being able to sleep until you've solved it (and then you just continue to keep on playing) happens to me all the time, most recently with Batman: Arkham Asylum's Combat Challenge Rooms.

10210
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: October 04, 2009, 05:29:35 AM »
The argument will never be over because there's no way to satisfactorily prove either side's argument.

Regardless of what you come up with, the counter argument to it is to point out that only 5 third-party Wii games (not counting World of Goo, which I'm treating as something different) achieved a Metacritic score of 90 or better, and all of them are either rhythm games or last-gen ports. That means that no third parties have actually put forth enough effort on the Wii to be able to tell whether good Wii games sell or not. (By the way, of those 5 games, and throw in number 6, Tiger Woods 10 with an 88, only one hasn't sold well, Okami, which didn't do any better on the PS2)

As you wish.  Just watching the way D_Average debates irritates me.

10211
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: October 04, 2009, 04:42:01 AM »
Zack and Wiki, The Conduit, and Madworld

None of those games would have done any better saleswise on the 360; Zack & Wiki and Madworld were very niche and The Conduit was solid but nothing special compared to other games in the genre. Your argument doesn't work without examples of high quality games on the Wii that didn't sell well and would have sold well on the 360.

Der gott this never-ending argument was kind of funny early on, but now it's just annoying.  I think there's a very simple way (though research-intensive) to determine whether the hypothesis that "3rd party developers don't release quality 3rd party titles on Wii because they don't sell' is true or not.  I note this hypothesis because that seems to be the crux of the argument: why 3rd parties don't put their best efforts on Wii.  Those numbers posted above proved something, though at the moment I'm not quite sure if it actually proved an argument.  Let's assume for a moment the conceit that Metacritic is actually a reliable source for aggregate reviews (and that game reviewers rate all games fairly according to their merit), because honestly what other measurable source is there on that matter?  Ditto for VGChartz or whatever the hell you call that site.  I propose we take the top 10 highest-rated 3rd party software on Wii and then grab their sales figures and compare.  Remove ports or remakes if you please for more "pure" results.  If those 10 games show high sales, then 3rd party developers just don't care on Wii and there is a bias.  If those 10 games show low sales, then 3rd party developers don't see a reason to put high-quality games on Wii because they don't sell.  Is that a satisfactory way to settle this matter, everyone?  Hell, I'll even do the research myself if it'll settle this for the time being.

10212
General Gaming / Re: Who is going to buy a PS3 Slim?
« on: October 03, 2009, 07:48:47 PM »
I've just finished playing the original Uncharted, and it's a true gem (it's the real successor to RE4, I think; has much of the same vibe, and way better than RE5).

By all reports Uncharted 2 is significantly better, and that's really saying something...

I wouldn't call Uncharted a successor to RE4, as it's a very different kind of game mostly based on taking cover and killing hoards of armed opponents boasting supernatural aim.  A much better example of an RE4 successor is Dead Space, which is a very similar game but with the addition of being able to move while aiming.

As for the original Uncharted, I thought it was alright but nothing special outside of the dialogue and music.  I have a lot of problems with the monotony of spending 20 minutes behind a stone column fighting off endless waves of goons, and from the looks of it the only thing Uncharted 2 does different in that respect is that instead of spending 20 minutes behind one column it's broken up into 5-10 minute chunks behind multiple columns.  It doesn't fix the underlying problem that having to go behind cover and fight off wave after wave of goons isn't interesting when you have to stop and do it every 5 frickin' steps.  Still, the reviews of the second game have me definitely looking towards picking it up sooner rather than later.

10213
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: October 03, 2009, 01:08:50 PM »
Quote
Provide a list of the Top 10 3rd party games on all 3 consoles.
The only PS3 third party games I know that sell well is Street Fighter 4, GTA4, RE5 and MGS4 (lookee all the fours!). Batman: AA is selling well from what I hear, and isn't over-rated trash from what I've heard.

X360: Street Fighter 4, some FPS games, GTA4, Batman: AA, RE5.

That's all I know of right now. Sales figures would be great.

On the PS3 side, Infamous sold pretty well though not as well as Prototype.  Prototype sold well across both 360 and PS3.

10214
TalkBack / Re: Issues Reported with Wii System Update 4.2
« on: October 02, 2009, 11:48:31 PM »
Considering I'm not planning on playing anything on my Wii till Silent Hill comes out, I'm kind of tempted to do the update just so that if it does brick I can force Nintendo to shell out the cash to fix it.  But that's a lot of hassle just to be mean to Nintendo.

10215
TalkBack / Re: Oregon Trail Remake Coming to DSiWare According to ESRB
« on: October 02, 2009, 04:04:22 AM »
I was a big fan of the original game, which like many others I played a good deal in Elementary School.  I never got very far, though...my people always died of dysentery within the first few months, and every time I tried to improve on that I'd pass their grave stones and then soon after...die of dysentery.   :-[  I swear, that has to be the most pessimistic game I've ever played.  Hopefully this new version improves a great deal on the original.

10216
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: October 01, 2009, 11:02:45 PM »
I think that would mean more hardcore RPG-playing type peoples exist on the Wii there, yes?

Or has DQ succumb to the TAINT of casual?

Maybe it's always been casual, to the horror of traditional game proponents.  Like a cultural favorite, like the Disney brand or Bugs Bunny or Georgio Lucaski's Star Milk Francise Wars.

Actually, in Japan that's entirely correct.  I was just listening over the past few days to the TGS episodes of 1up's ListenUp podcast, and their Japanese correspondents pretty much stated as such: in Japan, the "hardcore" play FPS games and the "casuals" play RPGs.

10217
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: October 01, 2009, 06:25:10 PM »
And the business angle is retarded, because even WITH their haphazard, awful support, some third parties still manage to do better on the Wii, despite all the sabotage.  The highest selling game Sega's ever made is a Wii game, Mario and Sonic @ Olympics.  Capcom's highest selling game in Japan, despite it being their ONLY real Wii game this generation, outsold everything they've published on other consoles.  I believe that DQX will outsell FFXIII there too.

Setting the bar rather low, don't you think?  The Japanese are famously-fanatical about the Dragon Quest series, regardless of mediocrity.  I'd be shocked if any Final Fantasy game not named 7 managed to out-sell a numbered DQ game.

10218
General Gaming / Re: 3D Dot Game Heroes = Legend of Zelda?
« on: October 01, 2009, 05:45:10 PM »
eh...looks like fun to me
don't we already have a thread for this?

http://www.nintendoworldreport.com/forums/index.php?topic=18120.0

memory like an elephant :)

Is that supposed to be your parody of an average anal forum-goer?  Seriously, we're supposed to remember a topic memorably called "More"?

10219
General Gaming / Re: 3D Dot Game Heroes = Legend of Zelda?
« on: October 01, 2009, 05:17:08 PM »
Wow, that's a pretty frickin' blatant knock-off and honestly...it looks like a pretty poor one.  What, they couldn't knock-off Koji Kondo's Zelda theme while they were cloning everything else?

EDIT: Supposedly, this game is supposed to be a send-up of old 8-bit games, a parody of sorts.  Because none of the dialogue I've seen in other trailers has been translated, I can't comment on that but I don't see much parody in the gameplay videos outside of the humongous size of the hero's sword.

10220
Podcast Discussion / Re: Radio Free Nintendo: Episode 163
« on: September 30, 2009, 03:48:02 AM »
I feel like every week I listen Adolf Vega gets a question answered.  On top of that, when you consider the fact that he also gets a question answered every week on GameScoop, its really unfair to the rest of us.  Liiiike.  Really unfair.    :-[

That makes it all the more depressing. Thanks a lot for bringing that up.

Oh you are one to talk, GP.  You're probably the second most-answered person in the listener mail section, second only to Adolf.   ;)

As for Adolf, geez it really does remind me of the occasional time when I'll tune in Shawn Hannity on the radio, and every single episode "Marty" always calls in without fail.  They even have a little theme song that plays for him in the background during his call.  Maybe we need one for Adolf.   ;)

I'm not too bothered by the frequency of repeat-members in listener mail, as I've only written in 3 times and got read twice so it's been pretty fair enough to me so far.  I just find the whole thing funny.

10221
TalkBack / Re: NWR Round-Table 1: The Future of Gaming Retail
« on: September 29, 2009, 11:59:57 PM »
It'd be great to have these roundtables in audio format, similar to the discussions on Radio Free Nintendo.  Or better yet, they could be a segment on Radio Free Nintendo...*hint* *hint*.

But if that can't be managed, yeah something visual like Miis for the various panelists and maybe screenshots of any games that are part of the discussion would do wonders to improve the presentation.

10222
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: September 29, 2009, 07:52:14 PM »
My point relies on a large body of shovelware crap, only 3 of which I specfiically named (and for the record, I don't care if people only bought Wii Play for the remote.  They still bought it).  If you want more, go look at Metacritic or something.  There's certainly been no shortage of it.
But how many of the games sold well?

Dunno.  Still, I can't imagine many people needing to buy...say...Ninjabread Man for that game to earn a profit.  These games don't have to sell well, just enough to overcome their development costs.  That companies keep putting these games out is enough proof for me to see that it's true.  If they weren't making a profit somehow, they wouldn't be putting the games out to begin with.

10223
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: September 29, 2009, 07:37:48 PM »
Wii Play being placed in the list of "garbage' is silly at best, most people bought it for the extra controller. The game is a fun, though shallow experience that is well worth the $10. Also Carnival Games is far from being garbage either, it may not be amazing but it is a solid casual game.

You may disagree with my list of games, but do you disagree with my point?
Your point relies on the games being garbage, and three of the four aren't. Ubisoft's games didn't sell nearly as well of the other three because they really aren't any good.

My point relies on a large body of shovelware crap, only 3 of which I specfiically named (and for the record, I don't care if people only bought Wii Play for the remote.  They still bought it).  If you want more, go look at Metacritic or something.  There's certainly been no shortage of it.

10224
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: September 29, 2009, 05:03:01 PM »
Wii Play being placed in the list of "garbage' is silly at best, most people bought it for the extra controller. The game is a fun, though shallow experience that is well worth the $10. Also Carnival Games is far from being garbage either, it may not be amazing but it is a solid casual game.

You may disagree with my list of games, but do you disagree with my point?

10225
TalkBack / Re: Square Enix's CEO Expects New Wii by 2011
« on: September 29, 2009, 04:55:05 PM »
To jump up and touch the bar with their fingers is worthy of high-fives for them.  They've figured out this whole blue ocean revenue bizniss.

The problem is that although we know the casuals won't buy every piece of garbage on the market, we know they will buy garbage (Wii Play, Wii Music, Carnival Games, the Ubisoft -z games, etc.).  The 3rd parties know that as well, and the cost of making those garbage games is probably so low they figure they can just spin the wheel with every release and the law of averages will dictate somewhere along the line they'll make money.  This is also known as "Ubisoft's Wii Strategy".  It's things like this that make me think sometimes that Nintendo made a mistake putting out a system so cheap to make games on.  It's a double-edged sword.

Pages: 1 ... 407 408 [409] 410 411 ... 454