Nintendo World Report Forums

NWR Interactive => TalkBack => Topic started by: WindyMan on January 29, 2004, 09:03:22 AM

Title: Latest DS Details
Post by: WindyMan on January 29, 2004, 09:03:22 AM
E3 secrets, GBA interchangeabilty, LCDs, and Miyamoto!

Link: http://gameonline.jp/news/2004/01/29025.html (Japanese)
Source: Famitsu


The cloud of mystery surrounding the new Nintendo DS product won't be fully lifted until E3, so every scrap of information that comes out about it before then will be jumped on in a hurry.  This time is no exception.

The LCD displays on the DS, though reported to be similar in appearance and size to the Sharp TCT LCD displays on GBA, will not be the same ones found on Game Boy Advance systems.  In addition, since LCDs in general are in very high demand thanks to cellular phones and other products, Nintendo might not be able to announce a definite price (or even solid release date) at E3, instead waiting until the summer to do so.  The system will also use a bulit-in rechargeable battery, though it's unknown whether or not it will be the same as the one found in the GBA SP.

Speaking of E3, we all know that the system's form will likely be shown there, as well as specific details being announced for it.  More detailed information about the wireless connectivity will be divulged, and the full story on third-party development will be spilled as well.

As originally reported, the DS will use what Nintendo calls a "semiconductor memory."  While it is cartridge-based, it will definitely not be like current GBA cartridges.  It's a thin card which presumbably slips into the unit somehow.  There are many benefits to this type of media, the most important of which is that manufacturing costs are similar to that of optical discs, and have a very fast turnaround time if more of a game needs to be made.

As you might expect, it has been confirmed that Nintendo already has games in development for the new system, and as you also might have guessed, Shigeru Miyamoto is involved.  No further details were given about game software.

Finally, an interesting piece of information was uncovered.  Apparently, Nintendo is still thinking about whether or not they should make the system "interchangeable" with the GBA.  This could mean anything from the software or hardware for either system.  The discussion over this is most likely over the similar processors the GBA and DS share (the ARM7), and the fact that they use different types of cartridge media.

That's all we have for now.  As we find more information about the Nintendo DS, we'll be sure to let you guys know about it straight away.      
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: nolimit19 on January 29, 2004, 10:13:48 AM
i think they should make the gba and ds as "interchangeable" as possible.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Chode2234 on January 29, 2004, 10:15:12 AM
Will I still be able to buy flash carts for the DS?  I hope so...
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Bill Aurion on January 29, 2004, 10:17:11 AM
to rechargability...
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: RyanGassxx on January 29, 2004, 10:24:51 AM
I just had an idea... what if this system is nintendo's way of going online with games?? Maybe this systems whole purpose is for multiplayer online games via some sort of mobile wireless internet, and would double as a phone also... ala the Ngage.. Obviously Nokia flubbed it up, but it in essence was a great concept...  And Nintendo would make it actually work.... Maybe it would have some sort of online service like Xbox live but wireless... It really makes scence if you think about it.... Nintendo didnt want to spend a whole lot of money doing it for gamecube since it didnt have a large enough REGULAR user base let alone an online one. And it was already too late for the GBA since it was already completed and on the market without being equipped with any wireless networking hardware.. so the logical thing to do is to just make a new machine altogether whos architechture is based around this idea. And they probably figured since they've had the most success in the handheld market as of late, that it was the direction they would have the most success in.. They probably observed the ngage closlely from day one taking note from start to finish and learned from someone elses mistakes instead of thier own for a change... So now at least they will know what NOT to do, and that alone might give them the edge they need to make this a huge success... If it just gets off the ground there will be no stopping it... just imagine how cool it would be to play multiplayer online games like we all did with dreamcast and xbox but being 100% mobile... Then again this could all be one huge mental fantasy ive created within my own brain and we could just be looking forward to a gameboy with 2 screens... But does nintendo really think that a handheld with 2 screens is the future of handheld gaming?? They obviously cannot be this dense... If not the whole online thing, surly there is at least one more gimmick that this hardware features tha will make it innovative... we'll just have to wait and see i guess...
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: nolimit19 on January 29, 2004, 10:34:02 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: RyanGassxx
... But does nintendo really think that a handheld with 2 screens is the future of handheld gaming?? They obviously cannot be this dense... If not the whole online thing, surly there is at least one more gimmick that this hardware features tha will make it innovative... we'll just have to wait and see i guess...


lol unfortunately they are that dense.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: nemo_83 on January 29, 2004, 10:51:08 AM
Doesn't really sound exciting or innovative to me.  Sounds more like a GB with two gimmicked screens than a new innovative product that will offer new ways to play games.  I'll still keep my fingers crossed for this being 3d glasses to replace Nintendo's original idea for a single LCD for Cube.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: GaimeGuy on January 29, 2004, 11:10:07 AM
the storage medium sounds a lot like what's used in the iQue player.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Ian Sane on January 29, 2004, 11:21:11 AM
"But does nintendo really think that a handheld with 2 screens is the future of handheld gaming??"

I think they do and I don't think it's such a dumb idea.  A dual screen design is more flexible because it can have both dual and single screen games.  It expands the options for designers without forcing them to a new standard.  All this needs is a killer app that could not be done without two screens.

Interchangability between the GBA and DS would suggest a GB/GBC style system where most of the games are playable on both but with some extra features or graphic enhancements on the DS and all two screen games are DS exclusive.  If they go this route however over time the GBA will be phased out in favour of the DS.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Fluke Worm on January 29, 2004, 11:30:26 AM
Quote

If they go this route however over time the GBA will be phased out in favour of the DS.

Yes, my thoughts exactly. I see Ns dilemma, the DS being totally GB compatible would be a good selling point but it would threaten the GB's place in gaming.  I do hope it's somewhat compatible with the gameboy, not like it would play the games(that would be a problem cus the cartridge slot) but could still link up to it to play multiplayer games(for games that only need one cart.) and all that jazz.

ps: lets try to keep all the DS rants for the right thread and stay on topic

EDIT:spelling
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: nolimit19 on January 29, 2004, 11:36:05 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Ian Sane
If they go this route however over time the GBA will be phased out in favour of the DS.


i PERSONALLY think that would be the best way to do it.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Fluke Worm on January 29, 2004, 11:57:07 AM
Quote

i PERSONALLY think that would be the best way to do it

Then the DS wouldn't be a "third pillar" though I get that that's just your opinion.  The GB could just become the more economical version of the two but I hope that that doesn't EVER turn out to be the case, intentional or not.

______________________

Quote

to rechargability...

I think that the chances of that not happening were quite slim with the GBA SP havin a rechargable and N saying this would be a higher end handheld, unless of course they wanted to shoot themselves in the foot
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Don'tHate742 on January 29, 2004, 11:59:55 AM
why do they need more GBA sales? I mean didn't they report that they sold their 20th million unit in the USA alone?

If nintendo was smart they would push the DS as a successor to the GBA, try to move everyone who bought the GBA to buy the DS. If they make it high tech looking and actually have some feature and games that are worth while, then I see no trouble for them. Just look how people bought the GBA SP and that wasn't even a completely new system. Nintendo should abandone the gba and hail the DS as the true successor. Backwards compatability is a must, it won't work without that. If they don't provide backwards compatibility then the ds is a gimmick.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Davideo on January 29, 2004, 12:15:50 PM
no... if they don't provide backwards compatibility then the DS is a third pillar.  Because you would still want to have all three.    Why would they want the DS to play GBA games, unless they are looking to replace the GBA.  Which they aren't.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Djunknown on January 29, 2004, 03:37:21 PM
It seems people are focusing on this backwards compatibility. I'd rather focus on Miyamoto on this post.

If there's anyone who can make a killer app for the DS, it's gotta be him. 2 screens; now what can a genius do with it? C'mon Shiggy, don't let us down!

Imagine some remixed classics like Donkey Kong, Mario Bros, etc.  Zelda would get some attention too.

Pretty much, just think of your favorite franchise. What can you do with 2 screens?  
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Bill Aurion on January 29, 2004, 03:41:29 PM
I read someone's idea for Four Swords, and I had been thinking the same thing...Just like Four Swords +, except your TV is replaced by one of the DS screens...
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: NWR_Lindy on January 29, 2004, 05:23:22 PM
Nintendo isn't going to abandon the GBA.  It's the best-selling system EVER, why would they try to abandon it?  It's their cash cow.

They're going to sell the DS as a totally new experience, which it may very well be.  Hey, at least you can say that Nintendo isn't following the crowd.  What I'm really curious about is which market they plan to satisfy with this product.  I can't think of one off-hand...younger gamers may not be able to afford this thing, and older gamers that want portable games all have the GBA SP and love it (I know I love mine).  I can't see why they'd want another portable.

There has to be some other draw...maybe they have a wireless portable MMORPG in the works.

silks
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Dryden on January 29, 2004, 07:03:52 PM
Two Screens.
Wow.
Sarcasm.

Except for the fact that (from what I've read elsewhere) the two screens are side-by-side, allowing a full screen view instead of two screens.  So that's double the GBA size already.  And the processor is more advanced, the media cheaper to produce, and the new technology will let developers do things that handheld games have never done before.

I don't see the DS becoming a "replacement" because it won't be compatible with the Gamecube.  It's too late in development.  But remember - the Game Boy Advance preceeded the Gamecube by only 6 months, and they started pushing connectivity with Animal Crossing, six months later.

I would not be surprised at all to see the DS have a release date matching the PSP, and the N5 having a release date to match the PS3.  And more connectivity - hopefully wireless and without extra purchases like the GBA-Gamecube cord.  Hopefully wireless.  Hopefully.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Urlan on January 29, 2004, 08:18:30 PM
So, what could be done with the DS?  Well, how about a game where you're a guardian angel assigned to protect an important person, and you have to manipulate objects in heaven while you watch the results and your "client" on the second screen?  Or you're a warlord in a fantasy universe, and you have to balance commanding your army on one screen with personally fighting to keep yourself alive on the other?  Maybe just an action game where, like in XIII, you have a sixth sense, letting you see upcoming dangers on the second screen?  
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: KDR_11k on January 30, 2004, 03:55:37 AM
Silks: If that no-money/already have GBASP was true the PSP wouldn't sell, either. However, we don't know how the PSP will sell, so...

Two screens don't make the device worse, it has as much processing power as the GP32 plus the GBA. That's some nice power. If you don't like the two screen concept you will probably find more than enough games that use them as one screen.

I'm still saying it was more or less announced just to counter the PSP, while it was announced as a third pillar to avoid shortcycling and looking too much like late Sega.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Olpus on January 30, 2004, 05:47:34 AM
Sadly, Nintendo DS is going to be a Vitrual Boy if the software isn't going to be none but a must have...
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Ian Sane on January 30, 2004, 06:54:44 AM
"I don't see the DS becoming a 'replacement' because it won't be compatible with the Gamecube. It's too late in development. But remember - the Game Boy Advance preceeded the Gamecube by only 6 months, and they started pushing connectivity with Animal Crossing, six months later."

Like anyone cares.  Seriously the GC/GBA connectivity stuff is a non-factor.  If the DS was backwards compatible but for some reason didn't connect with the GC the amount of people who wouldn't buy a DS because of that is ridiculously insignificant.  Besides if the DS is backwards compatible with the GBA I don't see any reason why it wouldn't connect with the Cube.  It would just be in "GBA mode" when connected.

A lot of you who are against the idea of the DS replacing the GBA are using arguements from Nintendo's point of view.  The connectivity issue, the third pillar talk, etc.  Think of it from a consumer point of view.  This "third pillar" stuff doesn't mean sh!t to the average consumer.  If they see a new portable from Nintendo they are going to think it's a GBA successor.  Therefore Nintendo might as well treat it as such or else risk pissing off all of those consumers who think it's a GBA successor and are pissed off that it's not backwards compatible and the game selection is small with little third party support.  That sort of misinterpretation among consumers could give Sony the portable market on a platter.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: matthewwithanm on January 30, 2004, 08:28:53 AM
what could be done with two screens that couldnt be done with one big screen?  i mean, the developer can easily split the screen into two with code.  i really dont see the point of this at all.  just make the next gb have a bigger screen and let the developers do whatever they want with the extra screen space.

people act as though the effect of having two screens cant be accomplished now.  but look at multiplayer games with split screens.  if the ds simply gives us two screens, all its really giving developers is more screen space.    in that case, it really is not that innovative.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: PaLaDiN on January 30, 2004, 10:31:43 AM
2 screens and 2 processors.

Big difference.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Koji on January 30, 2004, 11:47:59 AM
Everyone is off calling gimic... Many of you people seem to have forgotten what people have thought were gimics at one time but have since been huge success.

Stereo speakers used to be thought of as a gimic...
TV's were thought of as a gimic...
later, COLOR TVs were thought of as a gimic...

YES lots of things have been gimics... but unless you actually see the thing and how it works, you may never realize what truly is and isn't a gimic.

*clears throat* *begins to sing* All we are saying... is give DS a chaaaaaaaance!

*bows*
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Bill Aurion on January 30, 2004, 11:53:14 AM
Ugh!  That, by far, is my most hated John Lennon song ever!

*beats Koji to a pulp*
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Ian Sane on January 30, 2004, 12:07:10 PM
"later, COLOR TVs were thought of as a gimic..."

REALLY?  That seems like something that everyone would want.  Movies were in colour when TV was still black & white so it seems pretty natural to have colour for TV as well.  My dad sure didn't think it has a gimmick when he first saw colour TV.  He thought "it's about f*cking time."

Anyway this whole "what can you do with two screens that you can't do with one" question has a very simple answer.  A huge screen makes for a huge portable which is inconvenient.  Two screens allows one to fold the unit in half thus increasing portability.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: curt_fehr on January 30, 2004, 03:20:30 PM
 

nolimit19 says:
lol unfortunately they are that dense



I think the term your looking for is genius.  You must not have the whole picture of what Nintendo is doing.  20 years ago, critics were bashing Nintendo for not only investing so terribly much into game developement, but also just releasing the NES in the US.  So if you look at the whole picture, there best decisions have always been bashed and criticized before any results or conclusions come forth. After the results come in, then the critics praise Nintendo for the same thing they were bashing them for a few months back.  Geez, where's the faith nowadays?
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: odifiend on January 30, 2004, 04:10:58 PM
Most of the faith just evaporated.  That phenomenon is what people in the gaming business like to call the Playstation- which I guess you could argue was a nintendo.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Edisim on January 30, 2004, 04:19:38 PM
I think KDR is basically right about nintendo's marketing of the ds, and that Iansane is right about their rumored consideration for the replacing of the gba with the ds. But I think that there could be more to it. Maybe it started out as "project: screw sony" rather than "the next gba", but grew into something much more. They probably weren't too serious/realistic about what the new system could/would/should do, and one day (after smoking some funky stuff), they said, "let's throw in two processors, two screens, and a bunch of other sh1t." Though they probably were less coherent... Then everybody's favorite god of gaming, shiggy, saw the crazy specs, and came up with some seriously brilliant ideas.. Then of course, Nintendo realized what Iansane realized, and now are not sure what to do with this and the gba.

There's also the possibility that maybe the system has somehow evolved into an "intermediary" system. That is, maybe it can function as a portable gaming device, but can also function as some sort of "at home" device. I know I played the gba as much at home as on the road. (Well, I used to... haven't touched the thing in a while.) Perhaps the wireless connectivity could, at least as one of its functions, serve to communicate game data between the gcn/n5 and the nds for easier syncing/moving of game data/characters/virtual-pets.

Just had another thought about the two supposedly vertical screens while thinking back to the idea of using the lower panel (if it's a touch screen--as unlikely as that is.) as a 'virtual control panel'... What if the top screen could be flipped all the way over (past 180 degrees. way past) such that your opponent could see it, and indeed that he/she was intended to see it? I can't really think off-hand of any great gaming possibilites but... Actually, I guess it wouldn't necessarily even have to flip all the way over; it could just flip up, then be rotated--like that pda-thing whose name I can't remember.. heck, if the top screen could be flipped and turned/rotated, it could even just sit flat on the system so the thing would look like a normal one-screened device if the game doesn't make use of the second screen.

And before anyone asks what I've been smoking--it's nothing. I don't smoke anything, personally. (It's all second-hand.)  
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Uncle Rich AiAi on January 30, 2004, 04:52:51 PM
I'm wondering if the DS will piss people off that there's another Nintendo hardware. *cough*Sega*cough*

The SP came out almost a year ago, and I'm sure there were gamers who were pissed that Nintendo didn't released that as the original GBA (even I refuse to buy a SP, choosing to stick with the original GBA).  There will be gamers who may think the DS is the next GBA, and may be pissed there will be a new handheld to buy.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: KnowsNothing on January 30, 2004, 05:06:01 PM
=O  AIA!?!

Love the sig!  I haven't been able to catch up on my news lately, so I'm not sure if I know the whole story on the DS or the latest details, but from what I have gathered I'm one of those people that doesn't want to see it. :\
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: RABicle on February 01, 2004, 04:58:49 AM
Quote

Ugh! That, by far, is my most hated John Lennon song ever!

I believe it was through the pure crapness of that song that Bob Dylan got his start. We needed a better protest song.

Ok about the DS, I hope they think up a better name for it than simply DS. I mean Advance was a pretty bad add on to GameBoy, SP was worse even GameCube is questionable. Nintendo 64 had a crap sound to it too. How about the Nintendo Wasmatron? Much better.
Honestly I'm pretty much just wasting space with this post, I dont know what to think of the DS yet, it's far to confusing, I haven't made up my mind. Mabye E3 will help.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: KDR_11k on February 01, 2004, 06:22:11 AM
Of course DS will not be the final name. After all, there's no Nintendo Dolphin to be seen on retail shelves, eh?
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: rogue_gamecube on February 01, 2004, 09:00:37 AM
Now, someone mentioned before that the screens were mounted side by side. That, in fact, according to the recent info, is wrong. They are mounted one on top of the other, or "vertically", which is what Ninty announced originally anyways. Ok, about the GBA compatibility: no more third pillar then. I currently am 60% on the side of yes, this is likely going to be the GBA2 the way things are going now. Afterall, I'm pretty sure that they mentioned "Nintendo DS" was a codename, not a real name. Could be wrong, I probably am. I have never for one second, though, thought this was a gimmick. They took a look at what was wrong with the GBA/GC connectivity, and corrected the problem with a new console. This is why they think of it as a third pillar, an inbetween for the GBA and GC. Figuring the PSP will have a smaller screen than one screen from the DS, no matter how powerful and how good the graphics are, how the hell do you play with something that small? My portable DVD player is barely big enough to make the subtitles on it legible, and its screen is 4.2". Here's hoping the DS lives on, it's a great idea that would really see criticle acclaim without simultaneous competition.
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Fluke Worm on February 01, 2004, 09:56:12 PM
Quote

My portable DVD player is barely big enough to make the subtitles on it legible

There's another use for dual screens, when the DS movie player comes out(will probably happen if DS's sucsessfull) one screen shows subs and other plays movie, this would work well if screens are indeed vertically mounted.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: vudu on February 02, 2004, 10:17:33 AM
here's a thought that i haven't seen anywhere else...

what if the flash memory cards the ds will use are the same as the memory cards the n5 will use?  would it be possible plug a ds game into the n5's memory card slot and play a ds game on your tv (split screen, of course).  i have no idea if this is even technically possible, but it might be a reason for nintendo to poor a lot of money into game development for the ds if they don't expect a lot of people to purchase the system.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Pale on February 03, 2004, 08:32:15 AM
Well reports around the internet is we may get an unveiling in about 10 days.  Does PGC have any confirmation on this?
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: Fluke Worm on February 03, 2004, 02:39:31 PM
Great idea kingvudu but I don't know anything about the techs either.?
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Bill Aurion on February 03, 2004, 03:27:25 PM
I think Ninty confirmed it to one of the Japanese gaming mags, but I'm not entirely sure...
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: Mario on February 03, 2004, 03:45:37 PM
I doubt Nintendo will unveil the DS so far before E3, it's probably just a little bit more info, i'm not getting my hopes up yet, but you never know..
Title: RE:Latest DS Details
Post by: odifiend on February 03, 2004, 05:39:37 PM
Bingo, Mario.  Have you guys seen IGN cube's interview with VP of corporate affairs, P. Kaplan?  Her lips are sealed and I had to smile at how good she was at clamming up and not missing a beat.  But she has been doing it for a while.
Title: RE: Latest DS Details
Post by: NinGurl69 *huggles on February 03, 2004, 10:06:07 PM
...stupid fat hobbit...