Nintendo World Report Forums

Gaming Forums => Nintendo Gaming => Topic started by: theaveng on March 08, 2003, 03:18:51 AM

Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: theaveng on March 08, 2003, 03:18:51 AM: Number of games rated higher than 90%
GCN = 5
PS2 = 5
XBX = 2
Source: http://www.gametab.com/cat/ps2

Looks like I picked the right systems!
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Agent on March 08, 2003, 05:21:18 AM: 1. Rated by who?
2. Matter of an opinion. Theres no proof.
3. Even if this were fact, instead of opinion, PS2 is matching GC, so how does that make it the winner?
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Nintendo on March 08, 2003, 05:49:00 AM: "In theory" that would make the GC the winner because the PS2 has been out almost twice as long.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Tsunekazu on March 08, 2003, 06:32:11 AM: I think you need to look up the definition of proof.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: nolimit19 on March 08, 2003, 07:16:11 AM: more proof.....gamerankings.com

1. Halo XBox Microsoft 92 8.8 95.1% 95.4%
2. Splinter Cell XBox Ubi Soft 77 8.7 92.6% 93.0%
3. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 XBox Activision 48 8.0 90.8% 91.1%
4. NFL 2K3 XBox Sega 40 8.3 90.6% 91.0%
5. Panzer Dragoon Orta XBox Sega 52 8.5 90.7% 90.3%

1. Metroid Prime NGC Nintendo 62 8.2 95.9% 96.6%
2. Zelda: The Wind Waker NGC Nintendo 8 8.5 96.0% 96.0%
3. Zelda: OOT & Master Quest NGC Nintendo 10 9.1 91.8% 92.2%
4. Super Mario Sunshine NGC Nintendo 78 8.3 91.1% 91.7%
5. Super Smash Bros. Melee NGC Nintendo 68 8.7 90.6% 91.5%
6. Resident Evil NGC Capcom 73 8.5 90.8% 90.8%
7. Tiger Woods 2003 NGC Electronic Arts 14 7.5 90.7% 90.8%
8. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 NGC Activision 44 8.1 90.4% 90.5%
9. TimeSplitters 2 NGC Eidos Interactive 30 8.3 91.3% 90.2%

1. Grand Theft Auto III PS2 Rockstar Games 94 8.7 94.9% 95.3%
2. Metal Gear Solid 2 PS2 Konami 89 8.6 94.8% 95.1%
3. Grand Theft Auto: Vice City PS2 Rockstar Games 75 8.4 94.8% 94.3%
4. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 3 PS2 Activision 76 8.5 93.3% 94.0%
5. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec PS2 SCEA 93 8.7 93.5% 93.6%
6. Pro Evolution Soccer 2 PS2 KCEJ 12 8.2 92.0% 93.1%
7. Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 4 PS2 Activision 41 8.1 92.2% 93.0%
8. Final Fantasy X PS2 Square 96 8.8 91.9% 92.1%
9. Madden NFL 2003 PS2 EA Sports 39 8.4 92.3% 92.0%
10. Madden NFL 2002 PS2 Electronic Arts 53 8.5 92.1% 91.9%
11. SSX PS2 Electronic Arts 80 8.3 92.0% 91.8%
12. Devil May Cry PS2 Capcom 81 8.4 90.6% 91.7%
13. NFL 2K3 PS2 Sega 30 7.7 91.1% 91.6%
14. Virtua Fighter 4 PS2 Sega 69 8.4 91.3% 91.5%
15. NBA 2K3 PS2 Sega 24 8.3 92.2% 91.2%
16. TimeSplitters 2 PS2 Eidos Interactive 57 8.1 92.2% 91.0%
17. ICO PS2 SCEA 79 8.6 90.9% 91.0%
18. SSX Tricky PS2 Electronic Arts 65 8.7 90.6% 90.9%
19. NCAA Football 2003 PS2 EA Sports 28 8.4 91.7% 90.5%
20. Pro Evolution Soccer PS2 Konami 12 8.0 91.1% 90.5%
21. Twisted Metal: Black PS2 SCEA 76 8.1 90.4% 90.1%

ps2 is the clear winner i think.....but a lot of those arent exclusive. take out all the multi console games and u get this.

1. Halo XBox Microsoft 92 8.8 95.1% 95.4%
5. Panzer Dragoon Orta XBox Sega 52 8.5 90.7% 90.3%

1. Metroid Prime NGC Nintendo 62 8.2 95.9% 96.6%
2. Zelda: The Wind Waker NGC Nintendo 8 8.5 96.0% 96.0%
3. Zelda: OOT & Master Quest NGC Nintendo 10 9.1 91.8% 92.2%
4. Super Mario Sunshine NGC Nintendo 78 8.3 91.1% 91.7%
5. Super Smash Bros. Melee NGC Nintendo 68 8.7 90.6% 91.5%
6. Resident Evil NGC Capcom 73 8.5 90.8% 90.8%

5. Gran Turismo 3 A-Spec PS2 SCEA 93 8.7 93.5% 93.6%
6. Pro Evolution Soccer 2 PS2 KCEJ 12 8.2 92.0% 93.1%
8. Final Fantasy X PS2 Square 96 8.8 91.9% 92.1%
12. Devil May Cry PS2 Capcom 81 8.4 90.6% 91.7%
14. Virtua Fighter 4 PS2 Sega 69 8.4 91.3% 91.5%
17. ICO PS2 SCEA 79 8.6 90.9% 91.0%
20. Pro Evolution Soccer PS2 Konami 12 8.0 91.1% 90.5%
21. Twisted Metal: Black PS2 SCEA 76 8.1 90.4% 90.1%

i am not sure about pro evolution soccer, but i thikn its only on ps2.....and i am not sure what ico is but it seems to me ps2 still has the better exclusives if u are going by numbers, and gamecube is no doubt a clear second.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Don'tHate742 on March 08, 2003, 08:20:37 AM: I'm sure Waverace and Starwars Rouge squad 2 are in the 90s. Also, what about Pikmin, SMBall 2, Eternal Darkness, Phatasy star online, Skies of Arcadia, Animal crossing, RE 0, and some others I can't remember right now. Those are all great games I think.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: StRaNgE on March 08, 2003, 09:18:12 AM: why did you remove GTA vice city ?
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: nolimit19 on March 08, 2003, 09:30:47 AM: i removed it because it is on pc. some people still consider it exclusive, but i dont.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: thecubedcanuck on March 08, 2003, 10:53:07 AM: Quote
i removed it because it is on pc. some people still consider it exclusive, but i dont.

Yes, feel free to add and remove stuff so as to better prove your invalid point.

There is no proof at all, everything here is OPINION. The numbers you quote are reviews, simply put they are people who give their opinions.

Topics like this are just plain stupid.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Scyth3r on March 08, 2003, 11:12:35 AM: .You guys really that insecure with your Cube?
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: StRaNgE on March 08, 2003, 11:15:27 AM: i know gta 3 is a pc port now but vice city?
already? damn that was quick...
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: WesDawg on March 08, 2003, 11:23:44 AM: I love my Cube, but if you look at GameRanking's you'll also notice that GC got alot of the lowest rated games ever too. It's kinda sad, considering the great stuff that can be done with it, the crap that some publishers will put out. Makes you almost wish Ninty would go back to the old days when their system was hard to make games for and the crappy developers stayed away... but not quite.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Hostile Creation on March 08, 2003, 11:54:04 AM: Plus Halo is going to come out for PC, leaving Xbox with a measly one, and it's barely even above 90. . .

GC has generally higher scores than PS2, though. . . at least the Nintendo ones, anyway. . .

Wait till Nintendo's huge line-up this year comes out. . . should get some good scores. . .
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: nolimit19 on March 08, 2003, 02:42:36 PM: Quote
Originally posted by: thecubedcanuck
Quote
i removed it because it is on pc. some people still consider it exclusive, but i dont.

Yes, feel free to add and remove stuff so as to better prove your invalid point.

There is no proof at all, everything here is OPINION. The numbers you quote are reviews, simply put they are people who give their opinions.

Topics like this are just plain stupid.

someone has a serious sttitude problem, and even thoug this may be a dumb thread, gtavc is not exclusive imo. halo is though. thats why i kept it on the list. halo has been out for over a year now and still isnt on pc.....gtavc will be on pc shortly. and what is my point.....if u even took the time to read u whould have seen this.

"i am not sure about pro evolution soccer, but i thikn its only on ps2.....and i am not sure what ico is but it seems to me ps2 still has the better exclusives if u are going by numbers, and gamecube is no doubt a clear second."

hahahaha did i successfully prove my invalid point that the ps2 has the most quality exclusives??? tastes in video games may be opinions, but so are the oscars when it comes to movies.......i dont care how many people think spider man should be movie of the year, it shouldnt win anything but the most over achieving movie of all time.....it doesnt matter how many people think steel battilion is a better game then every game on gamecube......cuz it isnt. i hope u get the point....all though everyone is entitled to their own opinions, only a select few would disagree with the fact that.....

ps2 has the most amount of good exclusives
gamecube is second
xbox is a distant 3rd

there ya go. there are lots of good games on the xbox that are on all consoles and pc, but when talking strictly exclusives.....thats just the way it is.....i hope i didnt make anyone cry.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Razex on March 08, 2003, 03:35:53 PM
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: theaveng on March 08, 2003, 05:28:56 PM: If you take the reviews of several dozen professional reviewers and average them together, you get a consensus view of how good or bad that game is. That's what gametab.com and gamerankings.com do.

All I and nolimit did was list all the games with *average* scores over 90%, and then we counted them. The result shows that PS2 has the most games rated over 90%, GameCube has the second most, and X-box has the least.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Infernal Monkey on March 08, 2003, 06:39:46 PM: ....
*Shrugs shoulders*

*Goes back to playing quality games on all three systems. Uh, at once!*

No system can claim to have the best games all round. That's just crap.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: PIAC on March 08, 2003, 08:00:26 PM: unless it has a complete monopoly then by defintion it has the best games
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: rodtod on March 09, 2003, 07:40:08 PM: there's no point in trying to support or contradict this. either you agree or disagree, but in the end the only thing that matters is in what you think of the games you play. other peoples' opinions don't have that big an impact on your own gaming experiences, at least they shouldn't. so why bother saying the GCN is or isn't the ultimate system, for most gamers are really too self-centered, and too immersed in videogames, to care about other people's opinions.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Hybrid Hunter on March 10, 2003, 01:12:25 AM: Like everyone has been saying, its all a matter of opinion.
You get a console because you like their games, not because its fot the most Ultra High Quality games according to some site.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: Termin8Anakin on March 10, 2003, 01:35:12 AM: I think Microsoft held the XBox exclusivity of Halo for so long, that I don't think that many people will buy it for people, since many would have gotten the XBox just for this game.
I played the game for a while, and it was sh!tty. The music was tops, but everything else sucked. The frame reate dropped too often, and the sound effects just didn't convince enough. The gameplay was alright, but it just didn't have that 'feel'.
Title: GameCube has the most Ultra High Quality games (the proof)
Post by: theaveng on March 10, 2003, 05:36:32 AM: Quote
Originally posted by: Hybrid Hunter
You get a console because you like their games, not because its fot the most Ultra High Quality games according to some site.
I REPEAT:
If you take the reviews of several dozen professional reviewers and average them together, you get a consensus view of how good or bad that game is. That's what gametab.com and gamerankings.com do.

All I and nolimit did was list all the games with *average* scores over 90%, and then we counted them. The result shows that PS2 has the most games rated over 90%, GameCube has the second most, and X-box has the least.