I've put about 40 hours into the first game, 30 into the second, and I think around 20 into Xenoblade 2. I probably shouldn't have voted but I did for the first game since I like the combination of story, place, and exploring the best. X does beat it on exploring but I'm not sure if 2 beats it on story yet but I still like the 2 titan setup better.
The one that won is the only one I haven't played so I couldn't say I agree or disagree and the other two are so close in percentages that it isn't like one is getting a raw deal either.
I haven't beaten either of the first two and probably got further in the first one. I actually never even got to the point where I was using a mech in X. I love these games but they're unfortunately really huge and I just can never seem to dedicate enough consecutive free time to get far with them. Something in life comes up, grown up **** if you will, and I don't end up playing the game for a few weeks and then it all just falls by the wayside because I've forgotten where I am and what I was doing. This is a problem with games in general but it really affects these titles because they're so long. I can fit a 20-30 hour game in no problem but 100 hours? I wish at least one of these came out when I was under 23. I would have loved these games and had the flexibility then to play them fully.
That's kind of my problem. I bought X without finishing Chronicles and now bought 2 without finishing the previous ones since I do love what Monolith Soft built with the franchise. My problem isn't remembering the story or what I was doing when "grown up ****" pulls me away for weeks or months but rather the systems. I've really tried to get back into X since the exploration is great but every time I do I spend an hour fumbling around half relearning mechanics, systems, and menus before realizing I have other games I can play and finish sometime soon. So it returns to the backburner.