I sacrificed myself on day one. I could have saved myself and let Bustin die. I should win the prize. That is all.
Oh, and I could pretty much tell the story of what happened, though I wasn't too involved, for me, it was pretty easy to see what happened.
My vote goes to Pale. Without him, the mafia couldn't have done it. No, really. Had Pale spoken up about Khush's betrayal, he would have been able to collect the townies together to figure everything out. But, Pale, afraid of something I can't put my hands on, did not. See, Khush took secret option B right away to join the mafia as a mole. with the conditional that Pale would find out as soon as the investigator, a Mr. stevey, had investigated him, I believe.
Stevey investigated Khush day one. So, Pale knew about Khush for basically the entire game. What's more, Pale wouldn't have been killed by the mafia had the secret gotten out. Why? Because the mafia wanted Khush alive, since I was to be gone, he was certainly, beyond any shadow of a doubt, going to be the mafia's strategist, even if he was known as a mafia member. Sure, his word meant nothing to the townies, but they wouldn't have voted out Khush so they could keep Pale alive. After all, what good is a mafia member when everyone knows who he is? In theory, there's not much he could do. So basically, all I'm saying is that after the killer was dead, Pale had no reason to withhold his info, but chose to anyways. At worst, he would be voted out and Khush would die, and his sacrifice would probably lead to townie victory. At best, everyone would steer clear of both Khush and Pale, stevey would investigate Pale, and the story would officially "check-out" and the townie players remaining would be able to congregate together, or at least the few roled players would have.
Anyways, there are some serious clues out there that Khush was a mole, and most of you didn't really pick up on any of them until it was too late. Too bad.
For allowing our victory, I'd like to vote Pale. His silence gave us the win. If I can't do that, I've narrowed my vote between Khush and TVman. I didn't talk to them after I died, really, so I don't know who did more. My guess is that Khush did, just because he lives to win, but TVman is much more clever than he may appear, so I'm not deciding between either yet.
So, can anyone tell me the odds of the bomber being voted off day one, under the condition that the vote is just random? Low, right? The same for any other specific role, I think for this game, the chance would be 1/18, but I don't remember for sure.
Now, can anyone tell me the odds that the bomber is voted off on day one when he's posting messages saying he's the bomber, posting threatening messages, and the like? Even lower. Who would vote away someone that might kill them on day one? Isn't that fishy? Isn't it strange that the person Khush "randomly" picked was the bomber? Isn't it strange that I was hounding for others to vote for this guy? Then, it turns out, he's the bomber. That should have been hint enough to suspect that something was fishy right there. There's more big clues out there, but I don't feel like listing them all. Players need to start questioning "Why?" or "What if" a little more, honestly, especially when something that should be mostly coincidence turns out to be very one-sided. That should cause some serious questions.
Oh, and then there's this whole BS about never trusting Khush that's going to pop up. Well, if you didn't trust Khush, who's going to figure everything out? At least one of you will have to step up if that's your decision, since you can't just rely on his shoulders anymore. To be a good mafia player, you don't need to just shut up and do what you're told. You've got to make your conclusions yourself. Especially, if you're just a normal townie, because then you've got nothing to lose at all. Start questioning things. Why did Khush blame Kashogi on Day 3, then turn everyone's attention elsewhere in private messages? Didn't anyone notice this is what happened? I did right away, reading the day. I saw some good questions after I was blown up, but they were just dismissed immediately. In order to be a good mafia player, you've got to base decisions on what you know and what's good for your team. If you're the Killer, if you're the bomber, then decisions are made on what's best for you. For everyone else, you've got to play for your team. That means you've got to vote effectively and switch votes effectively. It means you can act suspicious to cover up someone else. It means you should try to asses what each player's goal has been in the current game. It can mean anything, but it doesn't automatically mean "Yes sir."
Topic: Winter Mafia Day 7 (Read 12511 times)
