Nintendo World Report Forums

NWR Interactive => TalkBack => Topic started by: Bloodworth on March 23, 2005, 05:34:10 AM

Title: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bloodworth on March 23, 2005, 05:34:10 AM
Silicon Knights and SEGA are collaborating on a new franchise for next generation systems.

SEGA Partners With Silicon Knights To Create Next Generation Content


Acquisitions of Western Content Prime SEGA for Growth


SAN FRANCISCO & LONDON (March 23, 2005) – SEGA of America, Inc. and SEGA, Europe Ltd. today announced an agreement to acquire and publish next-generation game content from Silicon Knights, the Ontario, Canada-based development team responsible for such hits as Metal Gear Solid: The Twin Snakes, Blood Omen: Legacy of Kain, and Eternal Darkness. The partnership brings SEGA more Western-developed content in preparation for high-growth opportunities presented by next-generation hardware platforms.


Under the terms of the worldwide exclusive deal, SEGA and Silicon Knights will collaborate on creating a new franchise for next generation console systems. This agreement, along with recent partnerships with publisher, Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment (project: The Matrix Online); developer, Monolith Productions (project: Condemned); and the acquisition of esteemed developer, The Creative Assembly (project: Spartan: Total Warrior) continues to highlight SEGA's emphasis on the Western market.


"We intend to establish SEGA as a leading publisher on the next generation of game hardware and only the highest possible quality of Western-developed content will get us there," said Simon Jeffery, President and COO, SEGA of America. "Silicon Knights has a rich history of developing great games that push hardware technology, so we expect this relationship will result in a powerful, new, and highly commercial franchise."


"Silicon Knights believes that the next generation systems will be the catalyst propelling video games as the dominant form of entertainment in this century," said Denis Dyack, President of Silicon Knights. "We are very excited to collaborate with SEGA on a next generation project because we share a vision – to take the medium of games to new heights and move people as never before." SEGA will manage all marketing and distribution activities and work in hand with Silicon Knights to supervise ongoing game development. Both companies have decided not to release product, platform, or release details at this time.

Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: ThePerm on March 23, 2005, 05:45:28 AM
So SK is owned by Sega now? Or is it just partnership?  I'm betting the reason why SK fell out with Nintendo is because they wanted to be purchased just for a nice taste of security. I would feel completely screwed over working for Sega management considering their track record of blunders. Maybe Nintendo will finaly come around and buy Sega...lol
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Avinash_Tyagi on March 23, 2005, 05:51:00 AM
Well this kind of indicates to me we won't be seeing SK on the REV for a while, if ever, sega doesn't seem very interested in working with Ninty except with the Sonic property.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 05:55:50 AM
I am completely and utterly confused now!

(Ack, Sega + SK = worst sales ever?)
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Pale on March 23, 2005, 06:03:57 AM
This is really the farthest thing from what I expected.  Some of Sega's teams like Nintendo.  Hopefully Silicon Knights still likes Nintendo.  Maybe this will lead to better Sega support on the systems...  and by Sega support I mean Silicon Knights support.
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Avinash_Tyagi on March 23, 2005, 06:04:24 AM
Quote

Originally posted by: Bill Aurion
I am completely and utterly confused now!

(Ack, Sega + SK = worst sales ever?)



It would serve them right for snubbing Ninty.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: pudu on March 23, 2005, 06:05:27 AM
It says they are only "collaborating on a new franchise", which doesn't indicate any sort of takeover.  Sega will be the publisher of this new game franchise while SK is the developer.  Now if only we knew what kind of franchise would a company like Sega want a company like SK to develope for?  Something more mature?  An RPG perhaps?
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Savior on March 23, 2005, 06:17:07 AM
Pretty suprising. I would have thought SK would like Konami more


Too Human published by Sega on the X-box 360? Id say so... For shame,
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: kennyb27 on March 23, 2005, 06:32:39 AM
I didn't see this coming at all.  How could they have differences with Nintendo, but then embrace Sega like this?  No sense...
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Ian Sane on March 23, 2005, 06:50:17 AM
Leaving Nintendo for Sega?  Is SK living in 1992 or something?

Sega sucks now.  Ever since Sammy bought them they just release total junk with formally well respected franchises names on the box.  Their fanbase has given up on them and they for all intents and purposes are no longer the same company.

There's no advantage to working with them.  Sammy doesn't care for game art.  They just want product so it's not like this would be great for artistic freedom.  And Sega is like a total money pit now so it's not like there's big money to be made.  Nintendo is a much safer publisher for ensuring sales.

This still doesn't answer the big question.  Why did SK leave Nintendo?  I want to know.  Did Nintendo do something bad?  Is the Revolution going to be too weird so SK bailed?  Was SK offered moneyhats by Sega?  WHAT?
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 06:54:11 AM
Actually this proves nothing in terms of exclusivity...What's another recent SK game that wasn't published by Ninty?
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Smash_Brother on March 23, 2005, 07:16:42 AM
Remember the Penny Arcade comic about Sega's games directly equating snuff films? Yeah, I thought that was pretty damn accurate.

And up until this point, I thought Dyack was a reasonably sensible guy...

-SB
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: ThePerm on March 23, 2005, 07:20:36 AM
i just hope nintendo has the rights to eternal darkness
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 07:23:12 AM
Word Mark      ETERNAL DARKNESS
Goods and Services    IC 009. US 021 023 026 036 038. G & S: computer game discs; computer game programs; computer game software; electronic game programs; electronic game software; video game discs; video game programs; video game software. FIRST USE: 20020624. FIRST USE IN COMMERCE: 20020624
Mark Drawing Code    (1) TYPED DRAWING
Serial Number    75672853
Filing Date    April 1, 1999
Current Filing Basis    1A
Original Filing Basis    1B
Published for Opposition    August 8, 2000
Registration Number    2715977
Registration Date    May 13, 2003
Owner    (REGISTRANT) Nintendo of America Inc. CORPORATION WASHINGTON 4820-150th Avenue N.E. Redmond WASHINGTON 98052
Attorney of Record    Jerald E. Nagae
Type of Mark    TRADEMARK
Register    PRINCIPAL
Live/Dead Indicator    LIVE  
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: couchmonkey on March 23, 2005, 08:50:02 AM
This just leads to more questions!  I really don't think Revolution is going to be so weird that Silicon Knights would bail out for that reason alone - it's going to be backwards compatible, after all.  Then again maybe that decision was made after they left.

My very wild guess is that Nintendo wanted Silicon Knights to be its personal slave.  I mean, there was a lot of talk about how great it was working on Metal Gear Solid and how much they love the game and Konami and everything, but Silicon Knights seems to value its independence and the Metal Gear Solid deal may have hinted to Silicon Knights that Nintendo had an agenda and it wasn't going to give Silicon Knights the freedom it wanted.

This is the trend I've seen: On the GameCube, Nintendo has been cutting loose developers and forcing it's franchises on them more often.  Rare's only GameCube title had Starfox crammed into it; Treasure got Wario, Left Field (or was it Angel?) was working on 1080 until Nintendo decided their version of 1080 was too arcade-like, and cut the developer loose.  Retro was reduced from four original titles to the Metroid studio, and instead of hiring new second parties to develop original content, Nintendo has been farming its franchises out to other developers like Capcom, Sega and Namco.

I think Nintendo is becoming a bit control-freaky.  It's not all Nintendo's fault: Rare sure hasn't paid off for Microsoft and Retro seemed to be in serious trouble before Nintendo took control of the situation, but I think Nintendo is starting to lose interest in helping developers make exclusive new franchises.  It prefers the safe bet of giving a popular franchise to a competent developer.  My feeling is that is what scared SK away.
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Savior on March 23, 2005, 08:53:34 AM
I dont blame Sega. They lost the all sports titles now. They need games like Matrix Online and SK to maintain some sort of hold on the Western market.
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: pyrokamileon on March 23, 2005, 09:07:58 AM
I wonder if Reggie reads this stuff?  our opinions I mean...
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Ian Sane on March 23, 2005, 09:12:20 AM
"I think Nintendo is becoming a bit control-freaky. It's not all Nintendo's fault: Rare sure hasn't paid off for Microsoft and Retro seemed to be in serious trouble before Nintendo took control of the situation, but I think Nintendo is starting to lose interest in helping developers make exclusive new franchises. It prefers the safe bet of giving a popular franchise to a competent developer. My feeling is that is what scared SK away."

That's pretty likely.  At the time when Twin Snakes was revealed I was pretty annoyed that they were using SK as a glorified port house.  I really liked the final product but there's virtually no SK touches in it (though to be fair I'm only familiar with ED).  It was a great remake/port of a Konami game and felt like such.  Realistically any somewhat competent dev could have made it.

I don't think Nintendo's being control freaky (though they do have a history of being bad at that) I think they're just way too focused on their franchises.  Aside from Pikmin, ED, and Animal Crossing (which in Japan was not a new franchise on the Cube) Nintendo hasn't really released any new franchises this gen.  It's been all sequels and spinoffs.  They always talk about how their franchises are like their legacy.  They NEVER said stuff like that before.  It was originally all about great games and new ideas.  I don't think they're forcing devs to use franchises that much.  They're probably just offering it every time and naturally, due to franchise sales having less risk, the devs agree to it.  I don't think they got Sega to make them a game and then said "it's going to be F-Zero dammit!"  More likely they asked Sega if they wanted to work with one of their franchises and Sega for obvious reasons said yes.  It's not so much that they're forcing devs to work with franchises but that they're just not encouraging the creation of new content.

Denis Dyack seemed really interested in working with Metal Gear.  I don't think Nintendo twisted his arm or anything.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Don'tHate742 on March 23, 2005, 09:16:16 AM
I say we wait to see what they have to offer in terms of this new franchise.

Let's just thank God that Sega isn't forcing one of their franchises on SK. Completely new means a completely new possibility it's good. And let's thank God again that Sega isn't developing this game. It now officially has a chance of being a great game.

I just hope it's either Too Human or Raven Blade.  
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Rob91883 on March 23, 2005, 09:21:31 AM
"Denis Dyack seemed really interested in working with Metal Gear. I don't think Nintendo twisted his arm or anything. "


I thought I read that Nintendo asked them if they wanted to work with Metal Gear, and Denis was more than accepting of the idea.  We really don’t know why Silicon Knights stopped being a 2nd party, but I can tell you that being made to work on Metal Gear isn't the case.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 09:42:43 AM
I just hope it's either Too Human or Raven Blade.

Errr, Raven Blade is Retro Studios' game...

And it's absurd to think Metal Gear was forced on SK, drop that line of thinking pronto...

That out of the way, anyone care to theorize about why Ninty's logo is STILL on SK's site?  I don't want to hear "because they haven't updated," because the site has been modified as recently as this past September...There has been plenty enough time to cut out a single freaking line of html text...
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Avinash_Tyagi on March 23, 2005, 10:21:35 AM
Well this is probably reading too much into it but perhaps its a signal that Nintendo may recieve the first release of its new game(hopefully).

But likely its just an oversight on the part of the webmaster.
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Cubik83 on March 23, 2005, 10:27:53 AM
Eternal Darkness: Shadows' Adventure?
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: BlackNMild2k1 on March 23, 2005, 10:57:54 AM
"We are very excited to collaborate with SEGA on a next generation project because we share a vision – to take the medium of games to new heights and move people as never before." said Denis Dyack, President of Silicon Knights.

Doesn't that sound kinda familiar?
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Deguello on March 23, 2005, 11:30:00 AM
Sounds like ReggIwata-speak.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Pale on March 23, 2005, 11:35:23 AM
Yeah, in general, based on what we already knew, this is great news.  I mean, it could have been Microsoft.  It also could have been Konami (and we know how well the support the cube)  At least we got one of the few Devs who has actually released Cube Exclusives (kind of).
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: joshnickerson on March 23, 2005, 12:04:17 PM
This is great news!

*remembers Sega's publishing "Shadow the Hedgehog"*

SIIIGHHH.....
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: BiLdItUp1 on March 23, 2005, 12:29:07 PM
I don't know what to make of this; it depends on Sega's stance on the Rev (hehe, the Rev...could be misconstrued as Reverend). So far I've only cared for AV's stuff (F-Zero GX, Monkey Ball), and they haven't done anything since fzero anyway. WE'll have to take a wait-and-see approach on this one.
Good point about not getting rid of the Nintendo logo, it is a bit ridiculous...all in all, another reason to look forward to E3.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: couchmonkey on March 23, 2005, 12:32:09 PM
Well, people may have connected a few too many dots, and I may have been too ranty, in my first post.  I don't think Nintendo is forcing franchises on developers in most cases, and in particular I  don't think that was the case when it comes to Metal Gear Solid, either.

But I do think that Nintendo is getting into a situation where it isn't as interested in having second party developers that make brand-new franchises anymore.  Rare alone developed about six new franchises for the Nintendo 64 and the other second parties were working on a quite a few new franchises back then as well.  Eternal Darkness is the one and only new franchise to come out of a second-party relationship with Nintendo this generation.  I'm just taking a wild guess that this may not have appealed to Silicon Knights.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: ruby_onix on March 23, 2005, 01:12:40 PM
This ranks very high on my "WTF" meter.

I really don't see how Twin Snakes could've been a problem. According to Denis Dyack, Shiggy asked Hideo Kojima over coffee why he hasn't made anything for the Cube. Kojima said "Too busy." Shiggy said "I think I know some great people who aren't doing anything right now." Shiggy grabbed Denis and asked "Do you know Hideo Kojima?" Denis said "Hell yeah!" Shiggy asked "Do you want to work with him on a GameCube game?" Denis said "HELL YEAH!1!!" Shiggy said "Well, that was easy. Denis, meet Hideo. You two can go nuts" and wandered off.

That GameCube game being a remake of MGS1 was apparently Denis's idea, and the reason it bombed is obviously because Konami seemingly-deliberately overshadowed the game entirely with MGS3, in every way that they could.


Denis's apparent explanion for leaving Nintendo, about having "incompatible philosophies" and stuff like that still makes no sense, and still doesn't synch at all with the gushing praise for Nintendo that he was always dumping on us.

The only thing that changed is that he's doing it for Sega now. The only conclusion that pops up in my mind is that Denis Dyack is a disingenuous brown-noser, who will say anything to anyone if it has a minor chance of improving his own position. But... then why the heck would he switch from brown-nosing Nintendo to brown-nosing Sega? That just makes no sense.


Also, I noticed this part...
Quote

SEGA of America, Inc. and SEGA, Europe Ltd. today announced an agreement to acquire and publish next-generation game content from Silicon Knights...

Just Sega of America and Europe? Not Sega-Sammy, or Sega of Japan? That seems a little odd.


Also, what was up with Matt from IGN saying that SK was "working on Xbox games as we speak" several months ago?


Oh and, the big red Nintendo logo is still front-and-center on http://www.siliconknights.com/
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 01:22:08 PM
Important Dyack quote of the moment...

"If people are searching for how Nintendo is being really aggressive in the future, look to how we're reaching out for collaborations."~February 2004
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: The Omen on March 23, 2005, 01:47:33 PM
Quote

That out of the way, anyone care to theorize about why Ninty's logo is STILL on SK's site? I don't want to hear "because they haven't updated," because the site has been modified as recently as this past September...There has been plenty enough time to cut out a single freaking line of html text...


I will speculate.  It's because Nintendo will partner up with Sega who partners up with SK for exclusive titles for the REV.  Or it's jujst to fuel this damn rumor mill...I certainly6 hope it's because Nintendo has a deal in place with Sega though.  If not, nothing makes sense...not the SK move to Sega, not the logo on the site...I mean, Sega?!  This is taint amount to industry suicide without a stable force partnering up with them.  Enter the masters of stability...Nintendo.  
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: ThePerm on March 23, 2005, 02:04:40 PM
also sk rarely updates their website..even before they partnered with nintendo..its as if they forget they have a website....i think rick offered to do their wwebsite even....
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: NinGurl69 *huggles on March 23, 2005, 02:16:18 PM
Well apparently SK's site's been updated as of TODAY and the Ninty logo is still present on the front page
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: TheYoungerPlumber on March 23, 2005, 04:01:34 PM
Sega could be really good for Silicon Knights, just from a multiplatform standpoint.  I predict this game will be multiplatform...and I see no reason Revolution wouldn't be included.  SK knows they have fans from their Nintendo partnership, and supporting a third system is not that much trouble.

Honestly my biggest fear is that Sega will rush SK near the end of development.  Sega tends not to care as much about tweaking and polishing when compared to Nintendo and other Japanese publishers.

Also, don't read a thing into having "Nintendo" still on the web site.  Most game developers like SK have NO time to  update their website.  Posting a press release is nothing.  Redesigning a web site is a lot of work.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 04:18:35 PM
But we aren't talking about redesigning a site, we are talking about removing a single line of html...

And this needs explanation...
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Djunknown on March 23, 2005, 05:17:35 PM
What do you know, one fartfetched rumor becomes true (most of it anyway, I believe the rumor went that Sega and SK were developing an Xbox exclusive).

Quote

"We intend to establish SEGA as a leading publisher on the next generation of game hardware and only the highest possible quality of Western-developed content will get us there,


Sad but true. Its been said probably a billion times, but eastern developed titles such as Jet Set Radio Future, Panzer Dragoon Orta, Shenmue II, got the shaft, not by poor advertising(you could trip over all the adverstising they did with JSRF and PDO), but by Xbox-gamers.  I'm taking a wild guess that at least on the 'Cube, they would've have a fighting chance of good sales.  No sense in imagining what-if, what's done is done. Now if they Sega the publisher can't reach Western tastes with Western titles, they need to just go home. Take up knitting or something.

New franchise= Too Human? Its sure as hell not a sequel to Eternal Darkness.  Seeing has how ED went from the 64 to the 'cube, it would mean 3 console changes  for Too Human if that's what they're developing (Playstation, 'Cube[?], unspecified nex-gen platform.)
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: ruby_onix on March 23, 2005, 05:50:43 PM
From the SK site's description of Sega...
Quote

The company develops, publishes and distributes interactive entertainment software products for a variety of hardware platforms including PC, wireless devices, and those manufactured by Nintendo, Microsoft and Sony Computer Entertainment.

Is there anything to be said for the order in which the console makers were listed?
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Bill Aurion on March 23, 2005, 06:28:22 PM
Okay, for some reason my cache wouldn't show that SK updated their site with the Sega news...So now the site has been updated, and yet the Nintendo logo still remains...What gives?

Another interesting quote...

"Collaboration is going to become essential. I remember when Spielberg and Lucas got together to make Raiders of the Lost Ark; I looked at that thing and said "that is the weirdest thing I've ever seen", but when I saw it, it was incredible (...) I think those kinds of collaborations are going to be the future of our industry."
~February 24, 2004 (1up interview)
 
Title: RE:Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Arbok on March 23, 2005, 09:55:56 PM
Quote

Originally posted by: TheYoungerPlumber
Also, don't read a thing into having "Nintendo" still on the web site.  Most game developers like SK have NO time to  update their website.  Posting a press release is nothing.  Redesigning a web site is a lot of work.


Speaking from someone who runs a large website, and looking at Silicon Knight's page, I will say I don't agree with that statement at all.

In fact, it takes more work to put up the press release than remove the Nintendo logo in the current design. Here look, I removed the img tag in the code (that's it, took less than 10 seconds) and this is what I got:

Site without logo

If one has Fire Fox and ad blocker, then can do it themselves as well. The Nintendo logo is not an important part of the design. I'd buy that the webmaster there is simply clueless, and maybe didn't notice a huge Nintendo logo on his site, but I'm not going to buy that it's beacuse of the amount of work that has to be put into removing it.  
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: TheYoungerPlumber on March 23, 2005, 11:23:49 PM
Hmm, yes, for some reason I was under the impression it was more integral.  I still think it could be "I haven't gotten around to it" syndrome (remember  how long Retro's website was in shambles?), but the "simply clueless" is also possible.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: Mario on March 24, 2005, 01:22:35 AM
I'm not going to believe, assume or think ANYTHING about anything Silicon Knights related until I see video evidence of a game in motion.
Title: RE: Silicon Knights Partners with SEGA
Post by: couchmonkey on March 24, 2005, 05:15:36 AM
I'm corporate webmonkey...if you're really busy, you do exactly what the assignment says and nothing more.  Post a Press Release.  I've left out-of-date stuff that would have taken 10 seconds to fix on our sites because I have more important stuff to do.  I'll make the change only when management thinks it's important enough to ask for it.  Maybe if I'm having a really slow week I'll point it out and they'll tell me to fix it...but usually they tell me just to ignore it.  It could be chalked up to laziness or preoccupation with more important things.